Old Overholt 12-Year Cask Strength Rye (Jim's Review)

117 Proof 12 Years Cask Strength Rye Jim Beam (Old Overholt) $110 MSRP

Nose

Dignified and elderly. Deep leather and dried cranberry.

Palate

Drier and more complex than bright young ryes. Deep leather, dried cranberry, and peppery spice. Extra age transforms the profile completely.

Finish

Dry and peppery with lingering leather. A contemplative finish.

Overall Score

4.5 / 5

Revisited on Jim's return — the 12-year confirms its status as the crown jewel of the Overholt lineup.

4.5

1.0 Undrinkable

2.0 Substandard

3.0 Average

4.0 Very good

5.0 Perfection