Skip to content
Episode 102 October 14, 2020 · 55:12
102. Fall Sipping Whiskey - Making a Seasonal Choice

102. Fall Sipping Whiskey - Making a Seasonal Choice

Jim & Mike crack open Bulleit 10 Year bourbon and WhistlePig 10 Year rye to build the ultimate fall sipping guide — plus a listener challenge with samples on the line.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Fall is in the air at Jephthah Bend Farm, and Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt have settled into Mike's basement studio — fireplace crackling, leaves turning, and two very deliberate bottles pulled from the cabinet. The occasion? A listener request from roadie Chris Taylor of Taylor Bay Knives, who wanted to know what to reach for as the temperatures drop. Jim and Mike walk through how their palates shift with the seasons, from lighter wheaters in summer and spring to the bolder, spicier, higher-proof whiskeys that feel right when you need something to warm your chest.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Bulleit 10 Year Straight Bourbon: A high-rye Kentucky bourbon at 91.2 proof, built on a mash bill of 68% corn, 28% rye, and 4% malted barley. Aged a minimum of 10 years with barrels reported to run as old as 11 and 12 years, this expression sits around $50 MSRP. On the nose, expect vanilla, caramel, and a gentle ethanol warmth. The palate opens with a buttery, viscous sweetness — caramel, butterscotch, and a faint floral note — before the rye grain pushes through on the back with black pepper, cinnamon, and a toasted, chocolatey oak that speaks to its decade in the barrel. The finish is warm and lingering with a butterscotch fade. Distilled at an undisclosed facility widely believed to be in Lawrenceburg, Kentucky, and bottled under the Diageo umbrella. (00:06:29)
  • WhistlePig 10 Year Straight Rye Whiskey: A 100-proof Canadian-sourced straight rye whiskey, aged 10 years and finished and bottled in Vermont under the guidance of the late master distiller Dave Pickerell. The nose is true rye — less ethanol sting than the bourbon despite higher proof — with baking spice, a minty herbal lift, and a hint of orange peel tea. The palate delivers immediate sweetness with caramel and butterscotch up front, followed by a drying tannic quality reminiscent of red wine along the sides and back of the tongue. Orange marmalade, warm spice, and a rounded depth from the barrel round out the mid-palate. The finish is long, warm, and persistently spiced — still present minutes after the last sip. A natural companion to cool-weather meals, campfires, and the kind of evening that calls for a blanket by the creek. (00:23:34)

Jim and Mike land on a clear throughline: the 10-year age statement does something to a whiskey that younger expressions simply cannot replicate — a deepening of oak, a layering of spice from both grain and barrel, and a warmth that feels earned. Whether your fall calls for a high-rye bourbon or a Canadian rye with Vermont credentials, both bottles deliver exactly what the season asks for. Keep an eye on the Bourbon Road blog for Jim and Mike's full Top 10 Fall Sippers list, and join the Bourbon Roadies Facebook group to get first access to the show's debut store pick.

Full Transcript

Bourbon Road Intro (Automated) Mike Hyatt Tasting Bourbon Rye Kentucky Bulleit 10 Year WhistlePig 10 Year fall bourbon fall rye whiskey high rye bourbon Canadian rye Dave Pickerell Diageo Lawrenceburg Kentucky bourbon seasons bourbon tasting straight rye whiskey Four Roses bourbon trail Kentucky Shelby County bourbon craft distillery barrel proof bourbon seasonal whiskey guide bourbon mash bill whiskey tasting notes