Skip to content
Cleveland Whiskey Company Wheat Penny Bourbon Whiskey
94 proof NAS Bourbon Cleveland Whiskey Company $37.99 51% corn, 45% wheat, 4% malted barley

Subtle chemical note suggesting youth, with hints of richness and oak from the toasted oak finishing. Smoke and dark fruit notes with cooked plum characteristics.

Initial sweetness across the front with caramel and toffee notes. Develops spice and a tannic dryness reminiscent of a Granny Smith apple. Mid-palate presents toffee and Heath candy bar flavors. Hug of heat that mellows as it progresses.

Medium finish with lingering toffee and oak influence. Dryness persists without becoming overpowering. Back-of-mouth whiskey with settled warmth.

Overall Score
3.4 / 5
A well-finished wheat bourbon with solid craftsmanship that masks its youth, though it would benefit from more pronounced front-palate sweetness typical of wheated expressions.
Play the excerpt from this tasting 00:01:52
Tasted on Episode 205 Wheat Penny 1958 Bourbon Review