Skip to content
Episode 136 February 10, 2021 · 01:13:28
136. Davidson Reserve - Nashville's Pennington Distilling Co.

136. Davidson Reserve - Nashville's Pennington Distilling Co.

Jeff Pennington & Carter of Pennington Distilling pour Davidson Reserve Weeted Bourbon, 100% Rye, Tennessee Whiskey & the rare Genesis Bourbon in Nashville.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt take The Bourbon Road south to Nashville, Tennessee, pulling up a seat inside Pennington Distilling Company — one of the earliest craft distilleries to open in the state. Owner Jeff Pennington and his versatile distillery lead Carter sit down with the guys for a deep dive into what makes Davidson Reserve whiskey a uniquely Tennessee expression. From grain sourcing on Renfro Farms in West Tennessee to the philosophy of letting time do its work on full-sized barrels, the conversation covers the founding of the distillery, the art of small-batch blending with master blender Ashley Barnes, and the painstaking process of cooking a 100% rye mash bill that gives their stills a serious workout.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Davidson Reserve Weeted Bourbon: A 60% corn, 22% wheat, 18% malted barley mashbill bottled at 101.7 proof. A nine-barrel small-batch blend of five-and-a-half to six-year-old whiskey aged on-site in Nashville. Chocolate-covered cherries on the nose lead into a mid-palate sizzle with dried fruit sweetness and a hint of peanut butter on the finish. Priced around $39.99–$44.99 at retail, with cask-strength single barrels available around $49.99. (00:03:11)
  • Davidson Reserve 100% Rye Whiskey: A mash bill of 90% rye grain and 10% rye malt, bottled at 100 proof and technically meeting bottled-in-bond standards, though not labeled as such. A six-barrel blend aged approximately five and a half years. Pot-distilled and minimally filtered, delivering a remarkably viscous, oily mouthfeel. Baking spice and allspice on the nose, with dried dates, dried apricots, and a creamy, full-bodied palate. Available at $49.99–$54.99. (00:20:00)
  • Davidson Reserve Tennessee Whiskey: A high-rye mash bill of 70% corn, 25% rye, and 5% malted barley, bottled at 100 proof. A five-year-old blend charcoal-mellowed through a six-inch sugar maple charcoal tube using a rapid-flow gravity process designed to smooth without stripping body. Double gold at the San Francisco World Spirits Competition, 94 points from Tastings, and listed as the #3 North American Whiskey of the Year by BTI. Soft and balanced across the palate with cooked-sugar sweetness and lingering spice. (00:36:41)
  • Davidson Reserve Genesis Bourbon: The same 70% corn, 25% rye, 5% malted barley mash bill as the Tennessee whiskey, but produced without the Lincoln County charcoal-mellowing step — making it a straight bourbon. Bottled at 100 proof as a genuine bottled-in-bond expression. Only 1,017 bottles released each year on October 17th, the anniversary of the distillery's first barrel fill. A six-year-old blend delivering toasted marshmallow, caramel kettle corn, and creme brûlée on the nose, with a rich, full-bodied palate and a long, sweet finish. (00:48:31)

Jeff Pennington and Carter close out the conversation with a look ahead — expanded distillery capacity, a new 130-gallon pilot still for experimental grain recipes, and plans to push Davidson Reserve into roughly ten states. If you find yourself in Nashville with time to fill before the honky tonks open, Pennington Distilling is worth the short drive west on I-40. And if you can track down a bottle of the Genesis, open the damn thing.

Full Transcript

Pennington Distilling Company Davidson Reserve Tennessee whiskey weeted bourbon 100% rye whiskey Genesis bourbon bottled in bond Jeff Pennington Carter distiller Nashville distillery craft distillery Lincoln County process charcoal mellowing Ashley Barnes master blender small batch bourbon Tennessee Whiskey Trail sour mash barrel aging rye whiskey

The Conversation