Skip to content
Episode 136 February 10, 2021 · 01:13:28
136. Davidson Reserve - Nashville's Pennington Distilling Co.

136. Davidson Reserve - Nashville's Pennington Distilling Co.

Jim & Mike visit Pennington Distilling in Nashville to taste Davidson Reserve Weeted Bourbon, 100% Rye, Tennessee Whiskey, and the rare Genesis Bourbon with owner Jeff Pennington.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt hit the Tennessee Whiskey Trail in Nashville, sitting down with Jeff Pennington, owner of Pennington Distilling Company, and Carter, the distillery's lead distiller, for a deep dive into one of Music City's most exciting craft whiskey operations. Built on a foundation of patience, authenticity, and grain-to-bottle integrity, Pennington Distilling has been quietly aging spirits since 2014 — waiting until the whiskey was ready before releasing a single bottle under their flagship Davidson Reserve label. The result is a lineup of mature, pot-distilled expressions that reflect both the terroir of Tennessee and the meticulous care of a team that refused to cut corners.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Davidson Reserve Weeted Bourbon: A nine-barrel small batch blend of 60% corn, 22% wheat, and 18% malted barley, bottled at 101.7 proof. Aged five and a half to six years, this Tennessee straight bourbon whiskey skips the charcoal mellowing process. Expect chocolate-covered cherries on the nose with a mid-palate sizzle, notes of cocoa powder, bright cherry fruit, and a medium-to-long finish with hints of peanut butter. Curated with master blender Ashley Barnes. (00:03:11)
  • Davidson Reserve 100% Rye Whiskey: A bold, viscous rye made from 90% rye grain and 10% rye malt, sourced from Renfro Farms in West Tennessee, bottled at 100 proof and aged five and a half years. Technically bottled-in-bond, though unlabeled as such. Baking spice and allspice lead the nose, giving way to an extraordinarily oily mouthfeel with dried dates, dried apricot, and a lingering caramel warmth. A perfect cocktail whiskey, especially in an Old Fashioned. (00:19:57)
  • Davidson Reserve Tennessee Whiskey: A high-rye Tennessee straight whiskey mashed at 70% corn, 25% rye, and 5% malted barley, aged five years and bottled at 100 proof. The distillate passes through a small six-inch gravity-fed sugar maple charcoal column to meet Lincoln County Process requirements. The result is a soft, beautifully balanced pour with a subdued nose, corn sweetness, and a smooth palate that retains surprising viscosity and depth. A double gold winner at the San Francisco World Spirits Competition. (00:36:41)
  • Davidson Reserve Genesis Bourbon: The founding expression of Pennington Distilling — 25 barrels laid down on October 17th with the same high-rye mash bill as the Tennessee Whiskey (70% corn, 25% rye, 5% malted barley), but without charcoal mellowing, qualifying it as a straight bourbon. Bottled-in-bond at 100 proof, aged six years, and released in limited runs of exactly 1,017 bottles each October 17th. Toasted marshmallow, caramel corn, crème brûlée, kettle corn, and a subtle Good & Plenty candy note on the finish. Bold, full-bodied, and deeply memorable. (00:48:31)

Beyond the whiskeys, Jeff and Carter share the full story of how Pennington Distilling was built — from a false start with smaller barrels to a patient restart under new investment, from the struggles of cooking a 100% rye mash to the revelation of working with master blender Ashley Barnes. They discuss the Lincoln County Process, the art of blending, the value of letting barrels develop on their own timeline, and the exciting future of Tennessee craft whiskey. If you're heading to Nashville, make a stop at Pennington Distilling and see a real working distillery in action. The bourbon road runs right through it.

Full Transcript

Carter Mike Hyatt Jeff Pennington Tasting Bottled in Bond Craft Bourbon Rye Tennessee Whiskey Bottled in Bond Small Batch Tennessee Pennington Distilling Pennington Distilling Company Davidson Reserve Tennessee whiskey weeted bourbon 100% rye whiskey craft distillery Nashville distillery Lincoln County Process charcoal mellowing bottled in bond Genesis bourbon Ashley Barnes master blender sour mash Tennessee Whiskey Trail Jeff Pennington pot distilled grain to bottle small batch bourbon craft whiskey