Skip to content
Episode 238 February 2, 2022 · 54:24
238. Exploring Buffalo Trace Mashbills

238. Exploring Buffalo Trace Mashbills

Jim & Mike decode all 4 Buffalo Trace mash bills, pouring E.H. Taylor, Eagle Rare, Weller 107, Blanton's-family Ancient Age, and both Sazerac and E.H. Taylor ryes.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt settle in at Jeptha Bend Farm for a deep dive into one of the most misunderstood corners of the bourbon world: the four mash bills that underpin virtually everything Buffalo Trace Distillery produces. From the entry-level Benchmark line all the way up to the unicorn bottles of the Buffalo Trace Antique Collection, Jim and Mike walk through each mash bill family, clear up persistent myths (no, Eagle Rare is not a wheated bourbon), and explore the fascinating history of Age International and its ownership of the Blanton's and Ancient Age brands. Along the way they uncover surprises — including which E.H. Taylor expression sits in the wheated mash bill and why the Weller lineup and the Van Winkle lineup share the same recipe.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • E.H. Taylor Small Batch: A Bottled-in-Bond bourbon at 100 proof from Buffalo Trace Distillery's Mash Bill #1 (low-rye, under 10% rye). Part of the Colonel E.H. Taylor line, this expression delivers classic low-rye character with a refined, accessible profile. (00:03:49)
  • Eagle Rare 10 Year: A 10-year-old bourbon from Buffalo Trace Distillery's Mash Bill #1, bottled at 90 proof. Despite its soft, approachable sweetness, it is firmly a low-rye bourbon — not wheated as some assume. Age is noted on the back label. (00:04:14)
  • Ancient Age 80 Proof: An affordable, approachable bourbon from the Age International / Buffalo Trace Mash Bill #2 (high-rye, 12–15% rye). A screw-top everyday sipper that shares its DNA with the far more sought-after Blanton's family. (00:13:31)
  • Elmer T. Lee Single Barrel: A single barrel bourbon from Mash Bill #2, named for the legendary Buffalo Trace master distiller who pioneered the single barrel category. Shares its mash bill with Blanton's and Rock Hill Farms. (00:13:16)
  • Weller Antique 107: A wheated bourbon at 107 proof from Buffalo Trace Distillery's wheated mash bill — the same recipe used for the Van Winkle family. Approximately seven years old, it delivers warm spice, cherry, and a cinnamon finish that belies its wheat-forward grain bill. (00:24:57)
  • Weller Full Proof (Single Barrel Pick): A store-selected single barrel pour of Weller Full Proof from the wheated mash bill, representing the Weller lineup at barrel entry proof. This particular bottle is a pick made by Jim at a retail store. (00:25:00)
  • E.H. Taylor Straight Rye (Bottled-in-Bond): A 100-proof straight rye whiskey from Buffalo Trace Distillery's rye mash bill, bottled in bond at a minimum of four years. Shows candied orange, a fresh menthol quality, and lighter clove notes. (00:34:44)
  • Sazerac Rye (6 Year): The younger expression in Buffalo Trace's rye mash bill lineup — sometimes called "Baby Saz" — bottled at 90 proof. A high-rye spirit with a pronounced Kentucky heat that makes it a natural cocktail workhorse, particularly in a classic Sazerac cocktail. (00:35:53)

This episode is essential listening for anyone who has ever puzzled over why a $10 bottle of Ancient Age and a bottle of Blanton's come from the same still, or why George T. Stagg and Buffalo Trace bourbon taste nothing alike. Jim and Mike also announce a listener giveaway — a single barrel Buffalo Trace pick — and preview a big week ahead that includes a bonus episode on bourbon scammers and a Thursday special. Whether you are new to the Buffalo Trace portfolio or a seasoned collector, this mash bill breakdown reframes how you will look at the shelf.

Full Transcript

Buffalo Trace Distillery mash bill wheated bourbon Weller Blanton's Eagle Rare E.H. Taylor Sazerac Rye Ancient Age Age International Takara Shuzo Van Winkle Pappy Van Winkle George T. Stagg Elmer T. Lee Rock Hill Farms Buffalo Trace Antique Collection low rye bourbon high rye bourbon bourbon education

The Conversation