Skip to content
Episode 238 February 2, 2022 · 54:24
238. Exploring Buffalo Trace Mashbills

238. Exploring Buffalo Trace Mashbills

Jim & Mike crack open 8 Buffalo Trace bottles to decode all 4 mash bills — and reveal why Blanton's doesn't actually belong to Buffalo Trace.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt settle in at Jeptha Bend Farm for a deep dive into one of bourbon's most misunderstood topics: the four mash bills that underpin virtually every whiskey produced at Buffalo Trace Distillery. If you've ever heard someone call Eagle Rare a weeded bourbon, or assumed Blanton's belongs entirely to Buffalo Trace, this episode is required listening. Mike and Jim work their way through all four mash bills — Low Rye (Mash Bill #1), High Rye (Mash Bill #2, with its surprising Age International / Takara Shuzo connection), the iconic Wheated Mash Bill, and the Rye Whiskey Mash Bill — sipping a representative bottle from each as they go.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • E.H. Taylor Small Batch Bourbon (Bottled in Bond, 100 Proof): A sought-after bottled-in-bond expression from Buffalo Trace's Mash Bill #1, the low-rye family. Jim notes he hadn't poured one in a while and was reminded how much he enjoys it — a clean, balanced pour that represents the accessible end of the EH Taylor lineup. (00:03:46)
  • Eagle Rare 10 Year Bourbon (90 Proof): Also from Mash Bill #1, the low-rye side of Buffalo Trace's portfolio. Despite its soft, approachable sweetness that sometimes leads drinkers to mistake it for a wheater, it is firmly a low-rye bourbon. The 10-year age statement now appears on the back label. Mike is sipping this one. (00:04:14)
  • Elmer T. Lee Single Barrel Bourbon: Part of the Age International / Takara Shuzo family and produced on Buffalo Trace's Mash Bill #2, the high-rye recipe (12–15% rye). Named for the legendary master distiller, this squatty-bottled expression is a genuine piece of bourbon history and a difficult find. Jim is pouring this one. (00:13:31)
  • Ancient Age 80 Proof Bourbon: The accessible anchor of the Mash Bill #2 / Age International lineup, and the only bottle Mike had to go out and purchase for this episode. Screw top, modest price tag, but sharing the same high-rye recipe as Blanton's and Elmer T. Lee. Mike is drinking this one. (00:13:43)
  • Weller Antique 107 Bourbon (107 Proof): From Buffalo Trace's Wheated Mash Bill, the same family as the entire Pappy Van Winkle lineup. Jim's pour. The 107 proof brings a spicy kick alongside classic wheated bourbon notes of cherry and cinnamon. Jim notes it may have been too bold a choice given the volume of whiskey already consumed. (00:24:57)
  • Weller Full Proof Bourbon (114 Proof) — Store Pick ("Kraken" pick): Mike's pour for the wheated mash bill segment — a barrel pick selected a couple of years prior. Same wheated mash bill family as Pappy Van Winkle and the full Weller lineup. Mike describes the store-pick full proof as a memorable bottle from a great day of selecting. (00:24:58)
  • Colonel E.H. Taylor Straight Rye (Bottled in Bond, 100 Proof): A high-rye straight rye whiskey from Buffalo Trace's rye mash bill, bottled in bond at 100 proof. Jim is tasting this one and finds it delivers a sweet, candy-forward rye character with candied orange, a hint of menthol and spearmint freshness, and limited clove — suggesting a very high rye grain percentage. A difficult bottle to locate, though secondary prices remain relatively modest. (00:34:44)
  • Sazerac Rye ("Baby Saz," 90 Proof): The younger sibling to the legendary Sazerac 18-Year, from Buffalo Trace's rye mash bill. Mike is tasting this one and finds it delivers a powerful Kentucky hug — not his first choice for neat sipping but acknowledged as a standout cocktail rye, particularly in a classic Sazerac cocktail. (00:35:53)

Full Transcript

Buffalo Trace mash bill wheated bourbon Weller Pappy Van Winkle Blanton's Eagle Rare E.H. Taylor Sazerac Rye Ancient Age Elmer T. Lee Age International Takara Shuzo low rye bourbon high rye bourbon rye whiskey bourbon education bottled in bond Buffalo Trace antique collection Kentucky bourbon