Skip to content
Episode 156 April 21, 2021 · 39:20
156. Should You Buy Store Brand Bourbons?

156. Should You Buy Store Brand Bourbons?

Jim & Mike taste Trader Joe's Kentucky Bourbon and Total Wine's new Earl Settler — two store-brand bourbons, two very different results.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt are back in Kentucky after a much-needed ten-day escape to Mexico, tanned, refreshed, and ready to pour something a little different. Rather than reaching for the usual high-shelf suspects, the guys turn their attention to two bourbons that most listeners have walked past a hundred times without giving a second glance — the house bourbons from two of America's largest retail chains. It's a rare bottom-shelf deep dive on The Bourbon Road, and the guys are determined to find out whether price and prestige are the only things separating these bottles from the rest of the rack.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Trader Joe's Kentucky Bourbon Whiskey: A 90-proof Kentucky straight bourbon, likely sourced from Barton 1792 Distillery under the Sazerac umbrella and bottled by Bourbon Square Distilling Company of Louisville, priced at $14.99. The nose opens with sweet caramel, red fruit, a hint of raisin, rich tobacco, and a touch of cinnamon, leading to a palate of nuttiness, cherry juice, and a dry, tannic oak finish reminiscent of a dry red wine. No age statement on label, suggesting at least four years in barrel. (00:06:21)
  • Earl Settler Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey: A brand-new 80-proof house bourbon exclusive to Total Wine, distilled by Artisan Distillery in Crestwood, Kentucky, priced at $9.99 and carrying a back-label minimum age statement of 24 months. The nose is sweet and approachable with kettle corn, caramel, cotton candy, and light fruit, while the palate is gentle and lightly sweet with corn-forward character and a notably soft, understated finish. (00:18:13)

Whether you're hunting for a budget-friendly sipper, a cocktail mixer, or just curious what the big retail chains are putting their name on, Jim and Mike have done the legwork so you don't have to. The guys also tease future reviews of Trader Joe's wheated Kentucky's Best bourbon and the Earl Settler Bottled in Bond expression, and look ahead to next week's deep dive into a new release from Barton 1792. As always, the Bourbon Roadies community is open, the glasses are full, and there's no such thing as a drain pour on this show.

Full Transcript

Intro/Outro Mike Hyatt Tasting Bottled in Bond Bourbon Wheated Bottled in Bond Kentucky Bourbon Square Distilling Artisan Distillery Trader Joe's bourbon Earl Settler bourbon Total Wine bourbon Barton 1792 Sazerac Bourbon Square Distilling Company Artisan Distillery Kentucky straight bourbon budget bourbon store brand bourbon bottom shelf bourbon sourced whiskey entry level bourbon 80 proof bourbon 90 proof bourbon bourbon review Jim Shannon Mike Hyatt The Bourbon Road bourbon podcast