Skip to content
Episode 156 April 21, 2021 · 39:20
156. Should You Buy Store Brand Bourbons?

156. Should You Buy Store Brand Bourbons?

Jim & Mike return from Mexico to taste two big-box store bourbons: Trader Joe's Kentucky Straight and Total Wine's new Earl Settler.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt are back on Kentucky soil after a well-deserved ten-day vacation in Mexico, tanned, refreshed, and ready to dive back into bourbon. The duo reflects on their time away — poolside Bloody Marys, Coors Light stacks, and the realization that a break from bourbon only makes the homecoming pour taste that much sweeter. With spring greening up the farm and projects piling up, there's no better way to ease back in than by tackling a question listeners have quietly been asking: what about those bourbons sitting at the very bottom of the shelf, the ones nobody talks about?

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Trader Joe's Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey: A 90-proof straight bourbon bottled under the Trader Joe's label and widely believed to be distilled at the Barton 1792 Distillery in Bardstown, Kentucky, under the Sazerac umbrella through the Bourbon Square Distilling Company of Louisville. Carrying no age statement, it is presumed to be at least four years old. The nose opens with sweet caramel, red fruit, a hint of cherry, raisin, rich tobacco, and a touch of cinnamon with oak and leather underneath. On the palate it delivers an upfront sweetness with nuttiness and a note of cherry juice before a dry, spicy finish reminiscent of a dry red wine. The finish is medium length and develops pleasantly in the glass, showing some buttery character as it opens up. Retail price is approximately $14.99. (00:06:30)
  • Earl Settler Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey: Total Wine's newly released house bourbon, an 80-proof straight whiskey distilled at Artisan Distillery in Crestwood, Kentucky, and labeled with a minimum age of 24 months. The bottle carries a bold black-and-gold label with a fleur-de-lis motif and a Jack Daniels-style silhouette. The nose is sweet and approachable, with kettle corn, caramel, cotton candy sweetness, and light fruit. The palate is gentle, soft, and corn-forward with a clean, uncomplicated sweetness, though it presents as notably light-bodied with minimal mid-palate development and a very short finish. No off notes, no heat, and no spice — a smooth and inoffensive pour that the hosts suggest is well suited for cocktails, cooking, or as an introduction for new bourbon drinkers. Retail price is approximately $9.99. (00:19:57)

Jim and Mike wrap up the episode with a look ahead — they're hunting for Trader Joe's Kentucky's Best Wheated Bourbon (rumored to be Heaven Hill juice bottled by Luxco) and Earl Settler's Bottled-in-Bond expression, both of which promise to be worthy follow-up reviews. Next week brings a step up the shelf with a new release from Barton 1792. Whether you're grabbing something off the bottom rung to mix into a slushy or just trying to figure out if that $10 store-brand bottle is worth your dollar, Jim and Mike have done the legwork so you don't have to.

Full Transcript

Trader Joe's bourbon Earl Settler Total Wine bourbon Kentucky straight bourbon bottom shelf bourbon Barton 1792 Bourbon Square Distilling Company Artisan Distillery Sazerac entry level bourbon store brand bourbon wheated bourbon bottled in bond budget bourbon Jim Shannon Mike Hyatt The Bourbon Road bourbon review sourced whiskey bourbon tasting

The Conversation