Skip to content
Episode 18 August 14, 2019 · 01:15:57
18. Third Pour - Bourbon Under $20 - Blind Bottle Challenge

18. Third Pour - Bourbon Under $20 - Blind Bottle Challenge

Mike & Brian join Jim & Randy for a blind brown-bag tasting: Fighting Cock, Old Overholt Rye, Heaven Hill BIB 6yr, and JTS Brown BIB — all under $20.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Welcome back to the Bourbon Road! This episode is a "Third Pour" session — a laid-back, free-flowing format where the mics roll and the bourbon does the talking. Hosts Jim Shannon and Randy Minick are joined by two friends of the show, Mike and Brian, for a brown-bag blind tasting challenge with one simple rule: every bottle had to cost under $20. Each guest arrived with their selection hidden in a paper bag, poured blind, scored on nose, taste, and finish, and revealed only after the group had their say. It's the kind of evening that proves the bottom shelf has more to offer than most people give it credit for.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Heaven Hill Fighting Cock Kentucky Straight Bourbon, 103 Proof: A Heaven Hill product originally positioned to compete with high-proof offerings in its class. At 103 proof with at least four years of age, it opens with a sweet, vanilla-forward nose carrying light floral and fruit hints. The palate leans sweet through the mid-tongue with a finish that arrives with a white pepper snap before fading relatively quickly. The bottle's unconventional label makes it a standout on the shelf. (00:08:42)
  • Old Overholt Straight Rye Whiskey Bottled in Bond, 100 Proof: A curveball entry — a rye whiskey slipped into an all-bourbon blind tasting. Old Overholt is one of America's oldest whiskey brands, and this bottled-in-bond expression comes in at 100 proof with at least four years of age. The nose is notably restrained, offering faint fruity corn notes with a light mustiness. The palate delivers mild spice and a hint of dried fruit, including raisin and plum, with a finish that exits quickly but cleanly. (00:17:12)
  • Heaven Hill Bottled in Bond 6 Year Kentucky Straight Bourbon, 100 Proof: A now-discontinued expression from Heaven Hill that was once available for under $15. At 100 proof and six years of age, it delivers a noticeably richer aromatic experience than the prior pours — graham cracker, brown sugar, nutmeg, allspice, and a hint of sorghum on the nose. The palate carries that baking-spice warmth forward, and the finish is the highlight: long, warm, and satisfying, with the kind of staying power that rewards patience. (00:29:04)
  • JTS Brown Bottled in Bond Kentucky Straight Bourbon, 100 Proof: Another Heaven Hill product, JTS Brown Bottled in Bond is one of the great bargain bottles in American whiskey, often found for under $10. At 100 proof, it shares DNA with its Heaven Hill stablemates but arrives with a bolder, more assertive presence on both nose and palate. Baking spices and gingerbread carry through from aroma to taste, and while there's a faint bitterness on the back end, a small splash of water tames it considerably and opens up additional sweetness on the front. (00:39:19)

After the tasting, the group reflects on bottom-shelf bourbon as a category — its value, its versatility in cooking and mixing, and the way blind tasting strips away label bias and lets the juice speak for itself. Whether you're hunting allocated bottles or just stocking your daily drinker shelf, this episode is a reminder that some of the best bourbon is hiding right at knee level. Cheers.

Full Transcript

Narrator/Intro Mike Randy Minick Tasting Bottled in Bond Interview Bourbon Rye Bottled in Bond Kentucky Heaven Hill Fighting Cock Old Overholt Heaven Hill Bottled in Bond JTS Brown Heaven Hill blind bourbon tasting bottom shelf bourbon rye whiskey bottled in bond budget bourbon bourbon blind tasting Jim Shannon Randy Minick third pour bourbon under 20 dollars Louisville bourbon bars Village Anchor Silver Dollar Louisville infinity bottle bourbon tasting notes