Skip to content
Episode 18 August 14, 2019 · 01:15:57
18. Third Pour - Bourbon Under $20 - Blind Bottle Challenge

18. Third Pour - Bourbon Under $20 - Blind Bottle Challenge

Jim, Randy, Mike & Brian brown-bag blind taste Fighting Cock, Old Overholt Rye, Heaven Hill BiB 6yr, and JTS Brown BiB — all under $20.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Welcome back to the Bourbon Road! In this third-pour episode, hosts Jim Shannon and Randy Minick are joined by friends Mike and Brian for a laid-back brown-bag blind tasting challenge. The rules were simple: bring a bottle of bourbon under $20 in a paper bag, and let the juice speak for itself. With no labels to influence the palate, the four men pour, nose, sip, and score their way through four bottles — including a surprise rye and a discontinued gem — proving once again that the bottom shelf is full of hidden heroes.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Heaven Hill Fighting Cock Bourbon (103 Proof): A Heaven Hill expression bottled at 103 proof, made to compete in the high-proof value space. Originally released as a six-year, the age statement was later removed, with all liquid aged at least four years. The nose offers light vanilla and a subtle sweetness reminiscent of fresh-baked quick breads. The palate is sweet with a mild white pepper finish that arrives quickly and fades. (00:08:40)
  • Old Overholt Straight Rye Whiskey Bottled in Bond (100 Proof): One of America's oldest rye whiskey brands, bottled at 100 proof under the bottled-in-bond designation. The nose is notably restrained with a light fruitiness and faint corn sweetness. On the palate, a mild spice emerges alongside hints of raisin and plum, with a subtle oiliness. The finish is brisk, fading quickly but leaving a lingering impression of dried fruit. (00:17:12)
  • Heaven Hill Bottled in Bond 6 Year Bourbon (100 Proof): A six-year straight bourbon from Heaven Hill, bottled at 100 proof under the bottled-in-bond designation. This expression is now discontinued and has become a collector's item on the secondary market. The nose is rich and inviting with notes of graham cracker, brown sugar, nutmeg, and warm baking spices. The palate is well-rounded and sweet, with a smooth, lingering finish that showcases the benefits of the six-year age statement. (00:28:40)
  • JTS Brown Bottled in Bond Bourbon (100 Proof): A Heaven Hill-produced bottled-in-bond expression bottled at 100 proof, available at a remarkable everyday price. The nose carries familiar baking spice, gingerbread, and a bolder alcohol presence than its counterparts. The palate is robust and full-flavored for its price point, with a well-developed finish that holds its own among the evening's offerings. A touch of bitterness on the back end can be softened with a small addition of water. (00:39:40)

The Bourbon Road crew wraps up the night diving into infinity bottles, Louisville dining recommendations, and a spirited conversation about what makes bottom-shelf bourbon worth your time and your glass. Whether you're a seasoned collector or a casual sipper, this episode is a reminder that great bourbon doesn't have to break the bank — sometimes the best stuff is hiding right there on the lowest shelf.

Full Transcript

bourbon blind tasting budget bourbon bottom shelf bourbon Heaven Hill Fighting Cock bourbon Old Overholt rye JTS Brown Heaven Hill bottled in bond bottled in bond 100 proof bourbon rye whiskey Heaven Hill 6 year blind tasting podcast bourbon under 20 dollars Louisville Kentucky bourbon road podcast whiskey tasting Heaven Hill distillery value bourbon third pour episode

The Conversation