Skip to content
Episode 266 May 9, 2022 · 18:09
266. Basil Hayden Subtle Smoke Bourbon Review

266. Basil Hayden Subtle Smoke Bourbon Review

Jim & Mike crack open Basil Hayden Subtle Smoke — an 80-proof hickory-smoked barrel finish — the morning after Derby.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt settle in for a post-Derby Sunday out at Jephtha Creed Farm, trading race-day stories for a relaxed glass of something genuinely new. With the horses rested and the ice chest finally empty, the boys turn their attention to a limited release that has been generating quiet buzz in bourbon circles: Basil Hayden Subtle Smoke. Jim Beam sent the bottle their way, and the guys are upfront about that — but they are equally upfront about letting the juice speak for itself.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Basil Hayden Subtle Smoke: An 80-proof extension of the classic Basil Hayden line, finished in a secondary barrel that was toasted, lightly charred, and then infused with burning hickory chips before the bourbon ever touched the wood. The nose opens with rich caramel, a pronounced Mexican vanilla sweetness, and a toasted-marshmallow quality, with just a wisp of hickory smoke that earns the "subtle" in its name. On the palate it is smooth and approachable — butterscotch, a gentle cinnamon-toothpick warmth, and that familiar campfire-in-someone's-living-room character that hickory smoke brings. The finish is short to medium, clean, and easy-drinking, with the smokiness lingering as a background note rather than a statement. The liquid itself pours noticeably dark for an 80-proof expression, a testament to what that smoked secondary barrel contributed in color and depth. Retails in the $50–$60 range as a limited release. (00:03:31)

With Derby weekend behind them and a bottle worth talking about in hand, Jim and Mike close out the episode by pointing listeners toward the USA Cares Gala on July 23rd in Texas — a black-tie charity event supporting veterans in financial need, featuring a curated bourbon pool and silent auction that includes a hand-painted Blanton's tribute and a bourbon rocking chair from a Northern Kentucky barrel maker. If you have bottles to donate or simply want to support the cause, reach out through the show's social channels. New episodes drop several times a week — subscribe, leave a five-star review on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or Amazon, and come find the community inside the Bourbon Roadies private Facebook group.

Full Transcript

Intro/Outro Voice Mike Hyatt Tasting Bourbon Finished Kentucky Texas Jim Beam Basil Hayden Subtle Smoke Basil Hayden Jim Beam smoked bourbon hickory smoke bourbon review secondary barrel finish 80 proof bourbon Kentucky Derby bourbon bourbon podcast The Bourbon Road Jim Shannon Mike Hyatt limited release bourbon USA Cares veteran charity bourbon barrel finish bourbon smoky whiskey bourbon tasting Bourbon Roadies