Skip to content
Episode 267 May 11, 2022 · 47:15
267. Protect Your Bourbon

267. Protect Your Bourbon

Weller 12 & Wild Turkey Decades get pulled off Mike's sunlit shelf to answer the question: does bourbon actually go bad?

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt settle in at the Hyatt homestead for a conversation that's equal parts practical wisdom and bourbon celebration. The topic? A question Mike's brother Mitch sent in: how long does bourbon last once it hits the shelf? The hosts dig into the real-world factors that affect an open bottle over time — light exposure, oxygen, fill level, and storage position — and share their honest take on when it's time to drink up, consolidate into an infinity bottle, or break out the sample jars. It's the kind of grounded, experience-backed advice that only comes from living with a well-stocked bourbon wall for years.

The second half broadens the conversation to the Kentucky bourbon festival calendar, with Jim and Mike walking through three major events happening in September and October 2022: Bourbon and Beyond (Louisville, September 15–18), the Kentucky Bourbon Festival (Bardstown, September 16–18), and Bourbon on the Banks (Frankfort, October 1). The hosts weigh the trade-offs between the music-forward mega-festival and the more intimate, bourbon-centric Bardstown gathering, and preview what listeners can expect at the Bourbon Road Lounge tent during Bourbon on the Banks.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Weller 12 Year (90 Proof, Wheated Bourbon, Buffalo Trace Distillery): A wheated mash bill expression that has been sitting at roughly half-full on Mike's bourbon wall — a north-facing room with indirect ambient light — for approximately a year and a half to two years. The bottle serves as the first live test of the episode's shelf-life thesis. On the pour it presents as clean, warm, and immediately recognizable, showing no signs of degradation from its time on display. Soft and approachable at 90 proof, it delivers the gentle sweetness and light oak character that have made it one of the most sought-after wheated bourbons in the country. (00:02:27)
  • Wild Turkey Decades (104 Proof, High-Rye Bourbon, Wild Turkey Distillery): A limited release crafted by Eddie Russell from select barrels deep in the Wild Turkey rickhouses, originally released in February 2017 and acquired by Mike in 2018. The bottle is roughly three-quarters full and has spent approximately four years on Mike's bourbon wall under the same ambient-light conditions as the Weller 12. Despite that extended shelf exposure, it pours clean and drinks beautifully — rich, complex, and fully intact. A rare and collectible expression that rewards patience and, as this episode demonstrates, is more resilient than many collectors might fear. (00:22:51)

Whether your bottles are hidden in darkness or proudly displayed under the lights, Jim and Mike make a compelling case for drinking what you love, sharing generously, and keeping that infinity bottle topped off. Cheers to the roadies — and we'll see you at the festivals this fall.

Full Transcript

Weller 12 Wild Turkey Decades Buffalo Trace Distillery Wild Turkey Distillery Eddie Russell wheated bourbon high-rye bourbon bourbon shelf life infinity bottle bourbon storage bourbon oxidation Kentucky Bourbon Festival Bourbon and Beyond Bourbon on the Banks Bardstown Kentucky Frankfort Kentucky Louisville Kentucky USA Cares bourbon festivals 2022 Seldom Seen Farms maple syrup