Skip to content
Episode 267 May 11, 2022 · 47:15
267. Protect Your Bourbon

267. Protect Your Bourbon

Weller 12 & Wild Turkey Decades put shelf-aging claims to the test as Jim & Mike dig into how long bourbon really lasts on the shelf.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt are back on The Bourbon Road for episode 267, tackling one of the most common questions in the bourbon community: how long does whiskey actually last once it's sitting on your shelf? Whether you're a new collector just getting started or a seasoned enthusiast staring at a half-empty bottle that's been catching sunlight for two years, Jim and Mike break down what you need to know about oxidation, light exposure, oxygen levels, and when it's time to move a bottle along. The conversation is warm, practical, and grounded in real-world bar setups — including Mike's north-facing great room wall and Jim's darkened whiskey den.

To put the theory to the test, the guys crack open two highly sought-after bottles that have been living on Mike's shelf in varying conditions — a half-full Weller 12 Year that's been up there for about a year and a half to two years, and a bottle of Wild Turkey Decades that has been sitting in that bright room since 2018. The verdict on both is reassuring for collectors everywhere.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Weller 12 Year: Buffalo Trace Distillery's wheated mashbill expression, bottled at 90 proof. This bottle had been sitting on Mike's shelf for approximately a year and a half to two years in an ambient-light room, roughly half full. On the pour it remains clean and inviting, delivering the classic W.L. Weller profile of soft caramel, vanilla, and gentle wheat sweetness that has made this bottle one of the most sought-after in the Buffalo Trace lineup. No signs of degradation from its time on the shelf. (00:02:42)
  • Wild Turkey Decades: A limited release crafted by Eddie Russell using select barrels pulled from Wild Turkey's warehouses, originally released in February 2017. This bottle was acquired in 2018 and has been resting in Mike's bright great room ever since — approximately four years of ambient light exposure with the bottle sitting at roughly three-quarter full. Despite the extended shelf time, the pour is clean and complex, showcasing the rich, full-bodied character that defines this celebrated expression. (00:22:51)

Beyond the bottles, Jim and Mike dig into the practical side of managing your collection: the infinity bottle strategy, when to move whiskey into sample bottles, and why the amount of oxygen headspace in a bottle matters more than most collectors realize. They also preview some major upcoming events — including the USA Cares Gala on July 23rd in Louisville, the Kentucky Bourbon Festival and Bourbon & Beyond both happening September 16–18, and Bourbon on the Banks in Frankfort, Kentucky on October 1st, where The Bourbon Road Lounge and the Roadie Bar will be in full effect. If you've been wondering whether that bottle you've been saving is still good, this episode is your answer — and a good excuse to finally open it.

Full Transcript

Weller 12 Wild Turkey Decades Buffalo Trace bourbon shelf life how long does bourbon last bourbon storage oxidation infinity bottle wheated bourbon Eddie Russell Wild Turkey W.L. Weller Kentucky Bourbon Festival Bourbon and Beyond Bourbon on the Banks USA Cares bourbon collecting sample bottles bourbon community Seldom Seen Farms

The Conversation