Skip to content
Episode 297 August 24, 2022 · 01:23:05
297. A Whiskey Day in the Basement Rickhouse

297. A Whiskey Day in the Basement Rickhouse

Jim & Mike visit Frankfort's Basement Rick House, tasting a Castle & Key Rye pick & a jaw-dropping Brazilian Amburana-finished Starlight single barrel with hosts Logan & Mack.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt head to Frankfort, Kentucky — the heart of Bourbon Country — and settle in at one of the most envy-inducing home bars in the state: the Basement Rick House. Hosts Logan and Mack have turned their walk-out basement into a full-scale rick house experience, complete with 14 barrels of aging spirit, copper accents inspired by Buffalo Trace, and a bar that seats 10. The couple behind the popular Basement Rick House TikTok channel join Jim and Mike for a wide-ranging conversation covering stories behind the stories — from Catherine Carpenter's forgotten role in sour mash history to Madam Mary Dowling's bourbon-smuggling adventures in Prohibition-era Mexico. Logan's six years on the Buffalo Trace tasting panel and Mack's deep dive into women in whiskey give the conversation a depth that goes well beyond a typical home-bar hangout.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Castle & Key Restoration Rye Single Barrel Pick (Basement Rick House Selection, Barrel #260, 5 Year): An early barrel — one of the first 260 rolled into Castle & Key's rick house — this five-year rye was selected by Logan and Mack as a deliberate "bridge rye," approachable enough for bourbon drinkers who claim to dislike rye while still satisfying committed rye fans. Tasting notes lean toward red hot candy and baking spices rather than sharp heat, with complexity that rewards slow sipping. (00:03:39)
  • Starlight Distillery Four-Grain Bourbon Finished in Brazilian Amburana Oak, Single Barrel Pick (Basement Rick House Selection, 114.6 Proof): Distilled at Starlight in Indiana — a true farm-to-glass operation where the bees that pollinate the grain are kept on property — this four-grain bourbon was finished in Brazilian Amburana (a South American hardwood) to produce what Logan calls the most unique whiskey he has ever tasted. The nose arrives before the glass reaches your face: an immediate wave of snickerdoodle cookie, cinnamon, and the cedar-humidor character of a freshly opened cigar box. On the palate it starts silky and sweet, transitions through layers of cinnamon and nutmeg, and dries on the back of the palate with assertive spice. At 114.6 proof it drinks well below its stated strength. Only two bottles of this pick remain in the Basement Rick House. (00:34:32)

Logan and Mack bring the same approachable, story-first philosophy to their home bar that has earned them tens of thousands of followers on Bourbon TikTok — and after an evening in their basement, it is easy to understand why. Whether you are brand new to bourbon or a certified steward looking for the rest of the story, the Basement Rick House is exactly the kind of place the industry needs more of. Find them at basementrickhouse.com and on TikTok and Instagram at basement_rickhouse.

Full Transcript

Logan Mike Hyatt Mack Tasting Bourbon Finished Single Barrel Kentucky Indiana Starlight Distillery Buffalo Trace Castle & Key Basement Rick House Castle and Key Restoration Rye single barrel pick Starlight Distillery Brazilian Amburana four grain bourbon Frankfort Kentucky Buffalo Trace bourbon tasting women in whiskey Catherine Carpenter sour mash history bourbon TikTok certified bourbon steward Stave and Thief bourbon stories barrel finish rye whiskey bourbon tourism