Skip to content
Episode 216 November 17, 2021 · 01:25:33
216. Bourbon Hunting and Allocated Bottles

216. Bourbon Hunting and Allocated Bottles

Bourbon hunting season is on — Mike, Jim, and the moderators share their best fall grabs, from Four Roses OESB to Elijah Craig Barrel Proof, and debate lines vs. lotteries vs. store relationships.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt welcome listeners to another trip down the Bourbon Road, joined this episode by three of the show's moderators: Adam Boothby from Chattanooga, Tennessee; Drew Allen from Memphis, Tennessee; and Jason Waller from the South Carolina Lowcountry. The conversation centers on bourbon hunting season — the annual fall ritual of chasing allocated and limited releases — covering everything from lottery systems and overnight line-sitting to store relationships, secondary market pricing, and the craft distillery bottles quietly stealing the spotlight.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Wild Turkey 101: A reliable 101-proof staple from Wild Turkey Distillery in Lawrenceburg, Kentucky. Classic rye-forward spice, caramel, and vanilla with a warm, well-balanced finish — a wise choice to open any evening. (00:02:32)
  • Old Dominick "All the Cookies" Bourbon: The newest R&D release from Old Dominick Distillery in Memphis, Tennessee. Rich baking spices combine with cookie-dough sweetness, oatmeal notes, and warm vanilla in a limited, distillery-only drop that disappears quickly. (00:02:37)
  • Fourgate Bluegrass Trilogy 2: The second installment in Fourgate's Bluegrass Trilogy series, a craft release that leans into complex, layered Kentucky grain character. Sipped neat, it showcases why the Fourgate line has earned a devoted following. (00:03:23)
  • Cypress Still Yard Private Barrel (CYPB): A wheated bourbon private barrel selection from Buffalo Trace Distillery. Soft wheat-forward sweetness, rich caramel, light oak, and a gentle, lingering finish — representative of why this style commands so much attention during hunting season. (00:03:30)
  • Castle & Key 2021 Restoration Rye: A 2021 release of the straight rye whiskey from Castle & Key Distillery in Frankfort, Kentucky. Bright, herbal rye spice with floral notes and a clean finish that reflects the distillery's continued maturation as a craft producer. (00:03:49)
  • Michter's 10-Year Single Barrel Bourbon: A 94.4-proof, single barrel, decade-aged Kentucky straight bourbon from Michter's. Deep caramel, dried fruit, toasted oak, and a long, warming finish characterize this highly allocated annual release. (00:04:39)
  • Four Roses Single Barrel Barrel Strength OESB: A barrel-strength expression from Four Roses Distillery using the OESB recipe — high-rye mash bill with a delicate yeast strain. Full-proof intensity amplifies ripe fruit, soft floral notes, and a lingering spicy finish. (00:04:44)
  • Michter's Toasted Barrel Finish Bourbon: A Kentucky straight bourbon finished in a custom toasted (non-charred) new oak barrel from Michter's. Butterscotch, toasted wood, and warm baking spice define a finish-forward profile that became a near-instant bottle kill when opened. (00:05:41)
  • Old Fitzgerald Bottled-in-Bond 9-Year: A 100-proof, 9-year-old wheated bourbon from Heaven Hill Distillery, released in the iconic decanter bottle. Oily texture, dark fruit, caramel, and a subtle spice on the back end — one of the most satisfying expressions in Heaven Hill's allocated decanter series. (00:25:58)
  • Elijah Craig Barrel Proof Batch A119: The first batch of 2019 from Heaven Hill's Elijah Craig line, bottled at 135.2 proof without chill-filtration or dilution. Intense dark chocolate, charred oak, dried cherry, and a bold, warming finish that rewards patience and a drop of water. (00:52:09)
  • Rock Hill Farms Single Barrel Bourbon: A 100-proof, single barrel wheated bourbon from Buffalo Trace Distillery. Rich and approachable, with honeyed sweetness, soft caramel, light floral notes, and a smooth, medium-length finish — one of the most sought-after squat bottles in the Buffalo Trace portfolio. (00:45:48)
  • Penelope Rose Cask Finish Straight Bourbon: A four-grain, 94-proof straight bourbon finished in a rosé wine cask from Penelope Bourbon. The grain complexity delivers sticky sweetness and soft fruit, while the wine finish adds a delicate floral and berry character on the nose and palate. (00:40:53)
  • George T. Stagg (2017 or 2018 Vintage): An uncut, unfiltered barrel-proof wheated bourbon from Buffalo Trace Distillery, bottled at approximately 129.2–134.5 proof. Dense and viscous, with dark fruit, tobacco, vanilla, and an enormous, slow-burning finish — sipped in solemn recognition of the missing 2021 release. (00:42:34)

As the glasses empty and the conversation winds down, the crew lands on the theme that defines the bourbon road at its best: the hunt is more fun when it ends with sharing. Whether you're sitting overnight in a parking lot, building a relationship with a local shop owner, or simply cracking open something special for a friend who has never tried it, the best bottle is always the one in good company. Here's to a great hunting season — may your unicorn find its way to your shelf.

Full Transcript

bourbon hunting season allocated bourbon Four Roses OESB Elijah Craig Barrel Proof George T Stagg Old Fitzgerald Bottled in Bond Buffalo Trace Michter's 10 Year Rock Hill Farms Penelope Bourbon Castle and Key Rye Old Dominick Distillery Heaven Hill Weller Pappy Van Winkle craft distillery bourbon bourbon lottery bourbon secondary market wheated bourbon Kentucky bourbon

The Conversation