Skip to content
Episode 216 November 17, 2021 · 01:25:33
216. Bourbon Hunting and Allocated Bottles

216. Bourbon Hunting and Allocated Bottles

Bourbon hunting season is on — Jim, Mike, Adam, Drew & Jason compare hauls, debate lotteries vs. lines, and pour Elijah Craig BP, George T. Stagg, Penelope Barrel Strength & more.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt welcome listeners to another trip down the Bourbon Road alongside moderators Adam Boothby (Chattanooga, TN), Drew Allen (Memphis, TN), and Jason Waller (South Carolina) for a wide-ranging conversation about bourbon hunting season. With fall allocations flowing and distillery lotteries shaking up the game, the crew compares notes on what they've snagged, what they're still chasing, and how the culture of sharing makes the hunt worthwhile — whether you're standing in a parking lot overnight or building a quiet relationship with a local shop owner.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Wild Turkey 101: The iconic Kentucky straight bourbon at 101 proof from Wild Turkey Distillery. A dependably balanced pour of caramel, vanilla, and baking spice that Jason Waller chose as his opening glass of the evening. (00:02:30)
  • All the Cookies Bourbon (Old Dominic Distillery R&D): An experimental release from Old Dominic Distillery's research-and-development program in Memphis, TN. Drew Allen describes the nose and palate as a wave of baking spices and oatmeal-cookie sweetness that practically makes you hungry. (00:02:37)
  • Fourgate Bluegrass Trilogy 2: The second entry in Fourgate's Bluegrass Trilogy series. Adam Boothby calls it fantastic and notes it has deepened his obsession with Fourgate releases. (00:03:10)
  • Cypress Still Young Peated Bourbon (CYPB): Mike Hyatt's opening pour — a peated straight bourbon that Mike had first encountered thanks to Adam Boothby. Described as a genuinely impressive, flavor-forward whiskey well worth hunting at its suggested retail price. (00:03:18)
  • Castle & Key 2021 Restoration Rye: Jim Shannon's opening glass, the 2021 vintage of Castle & Key's Restoration Rye out of Frankfort, KY. A craft rye that the hosts note is part of a growing single-barrel program the distillery has begun rolling out weekly. (00:03:49)
  • Old Fitzgerald Bottled in Bond 9 Year: A bottle from Heaven Hill's decanter series of Old Fitzgerald bottle-in-bond releases, this nine-year expression poured by Mike Hyatt is described as oily and complex — soft up front with a pleasant spice on the back end. (00:25:59)
  • George T. Stagg (2017 or 2018 vintage): Jim Shannon's second pour, a cask-strength Buffalo Trace Antique Collection bourbon clocking in around 129.2 proof (estimated 2017) or 134.4 proof (2018). Savored in bittersweet acknowledgment that no 2021 release will be made this year. (00:42:34)
  • Rockhill Farms Single Barrel Bourbon: Adam Boothby's second pour — a single-barrel wheated bourbon from Buffalo Trace at 100 proof. A sought-after allocated bottle poured in tribute to one of Drew Allen's all-time favorites. (00:45:48)
  • Penelope Rose Cask Finish Bourbon: Mike Hyatt opens a birthday gift from Adam Boothby — a four-grain straight bourbon finished in a rosé wine cask, bottled at 94 proof. The nose carries that distinctive four-grain stickiness and sweetness the hosts prize in the style. (00:41:03)
  • Penelope Barrel Strength Toasted (Black Label): Drew Allen's second pour at 117 proof. A toasted-barrel expression from Penelope Bourbon that Drew describes as an ode to s'mores — crispy marshmallow, chocolate, and graham cracker on the palate. (00:41:47)
  • Iron Root Harbinger: Jason Waller's second glass, the Harbinger expression from Iron Root Republic Distillery in Denison, TX, bottled at 115 proof. A Texas straight bourbon that Jason has had to drive over an hour to obtain in South Carolina. (00:42:31)
  • Elijah Craig Barrel Proof Batch A119: Mike Hyatt's third pour — the first batch of 2019 from Heaven Hill's Elijah Craig Barrel Proof line, bottled at 135.2 proof. An uncut, unfiltered expression the group enthusiastically endorses as a strong buy anywhere near its suggested retail price. (00:52:09)

The evening wraps with the group reflecting on what bourbon hunting truly means: not just the score, but the stories, the friendships forged in overnight parking-lot vigils, and the joy of handing a unicorn bottle to someone who needs it more than you do. Whether you're chasing a William Larue Weller, a Parker's Heritage, or simply the next great craft release you've never tried, the crew agrees the best bottle is always the one shared with good company. Cheers to the hunt.

Full Transcript

bourbon hunting season allocated bourbon Buffalo Trace Antique Collection George T. Stagg Elijah Craig Barrel Proof Penelope Bourbon Rockhill Farms Old Fitzgerald Bottled in Bond Heaven Hill Wild Turkey 101 Castle and Key Fourgate Old Dominic Distillery Iron Root Republic Four Roses Limited Edition Cypress Still Young Peated Bourbon bourbon lottery bourbon secondary market craft distillery wheated bourbon