Skip to content
Episode 331 February 1, 2023 · 01:16:34
331. Old Carter Whiskey Co. - How Do They Do It?

331. Old Carter Whiskey Co. - How Do They Do It?

Mark & Sherry Carter of Old Carter pour four expressions — a 14yr single barrel, a 3-barrel Social Club VSB, double-oaked Batch 14, and their prized American Whiskey — live from Louisville HQ.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and co-host Brian Hyder take The Bourbon Road to downtown Louisville, Kentucky, stepping inside the world headquarters of Old Carter Whiskey Co. at 105 West Market Street. Joined by founders and master blenders Mark and Sherry Carter, the four settle in upstairs at the newly launched Old Carter Social Club — a members-only locker program tucked above the production floor — for an afternoon of blending talk, brand storytelling, and serious whiskey. Mark and Sherry walk listeners through how they navigate sourcing, double-oaking, and the painstaking trial-and-error of crafting each small batch, all while sharing how they rebuilt and expanded Old Carter through and after the COVID era.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Old Carter Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey, 14 Year, Barrel #1, Bottle #14 of 121, 117.6 proof: A stunning opener from the original hundred-barrel lot purchased in 2017. Despite its elevated proof, the nose is remarkably gentle — creamy caramel with a light smokiness you'd expect from a 14-year-old Kentucky bourbon. The palate is viscous and sweet up front, with spice building on the back end and a pleasantly dry, cigar-tinged finish that beckons another sip. (00:04:02)
  • Old Carter Very Small Batch (OC) Kentucky Straight Bourbon, ~117.6 proof, 507 bottles, Bottle #39: A three-barrel blend crafted exclusively for Social Club locker members, this very small batch showcases the brand's ability to make a multi-barrel blend feel as nuanced as a single cask. Tasting notes ranged from unfrosted strawberry Pop-Tart and cinnamon roll with frosting to a rich bakery sweetness throughout. Long finish. (00:23:57)
  • Old Carter Small Batch Bourbon #14, 100% Double-Oaked, 117 proof, 3,046 bottles: The largest small batch Old Carter has ever produced and their newest bourbon release at the time of recording. Entirely double-oaked with toasted heads, the whiskey delivers butterscotch, toffee, and a Pop Rocks-like tingle on the palate. Rich, full-flavored, and high-corn in its mash bill, it echoes the beloved Batch 5 profile that first excited the team about double-oaking. A long, enveloping finish defines the experience. (00:40:54)
  • Old Carter American Whiskey (Batch 10, with components ranging 8–16 years old, typically 130+ proof): The wildcard of the afternoon and Sherry's COVID companion, this 99% corn American whiskey enters used barrels at over 125 proof, putting it firmly outside bourbon territory and into its own distinctive category. The nose alone drew an audible reaction from Jim. Richer, more exotic, and more intense than the bourbons that preceded it, this expression represents everything the Carters love about pushing whiskey outside conventional lines. (00:58:28)

Beyond the glass, Mark and Sherry detail the Social Club locker program (with a waitlist already over 150 members), their in-house bottling operation, Sherry's hand-labeling tradition, the very small batch distributor selection program, plans for a new warehouse and expanded production space, and the couple's quiet but growing distillation program — 400 barrels of their own distillate nearly ready for blending. Whether you're chasing a bottle on a retail shelf in one of their 12 states or hoping to land a locker spot, this episode is a masterclass in thoughtful, integrity-first whiskey making.

Full Transcript

Old Carter Whiskey Co Mark Carter Sherry Carter Kentucky straight bourbon American whiskey double oaked bourbon single barrel bourbon small batch bourbon very small batch barrel strength bourbon Louisville Kentucky distillery bourbon blending bourbon Social Club Jim Shannon Brian Hyder The Bourbon Road aged bourbon high proof bourbon whiskey locker program craft whiskey

The Conversation