Skip to content
Episode 331 February 1, 2023 · 01:16:34
331. Old Carter Whiskey Co. - How Do They Do It?

331. Old Carter Whiskey Co. - How Do They Do It?

Jim & Brian visit Mark & Sherry Carter at Old Carter Whiskey Co. HQ in Louisville to taste four expressions including a 14-year single barrel and the newest Bourbon #14.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Brian Hyder take The Bourbon Road on location to downtown Louisville, Kentucky, visiting the world headquarters of Old Carter Whiskey Co. at 105 West Market Street. Hosts Mark and Sherry Carter welcome the crew upstairs to the Old Carter Social Club — a members-only locker program that has become the heartbeat of the brand's most passionate fans — for an afternoon of tasting, storytelling, and candid conversation about blending, double-oaking, contract distilling, and what it really takes to craft exceptional American whiskey at a small, intentional scale.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Old Carter Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey, Barrel #1, 14 Years, 117.6 Proof: A stunning single-barrel expression pulled from a lot of 100 barrels acquired in 2017. Creamy caramel on the nose with surprising softness for 117.6 proof, a viscous and sweet mid-palate, building spice on the back, and a pleasantly dry, cigar-friendly finish. Bottle 14 of 121. (00:04:04)
  • Old Carter OC Very Small Batch Bourbon (3-Barrel Blend), 117.6 Proof, 507 Bottles: A Social Club exclusive very small batch release representing the first OC-designated locker program drop. Layers of bakery notes — Pop-Tart pastry, cinnamon roll, and frosting — with remarkable balance and long-finish complexity that punches well above its tiny production size. (00:23:57)
  • Old Carter Small Batch Bourbon #14, 117 Proof, 3,046 Bottles: The brand's largest small batch to date and their most recent public release, crafted from 100% double-oaked, toasted-head barrels. Butterscotch and toffee on the nose transition to a rich, full corn-forward palate with pop-rocks tingle, deep wood character, and a long, beckoning finish. (00:44:54)
  • Old Carter American Whiskey (Batch featuring 8–16 Year Components), 130+ Proof: A high-corn, 99% corn mash bill American whiskey aged in used barrels, featuring some of the oldest liquid in the Old Carter portfolio. Dramatically different in profile from the bourbons — bold, expansive, and deeply complex, with a nose that commands attention and a palate that rewards patience. (00:58:28)

Mark and Sherry Carter pull back the curtain on their meticulous blending process — tasting through as many as 50 barrels to build a 12-barrel blend, running 23 or more trial blends before settling on a final expression, and finishing the process blind. They share the story behind the Old Carter Social Club locker program, their in-house bottling operation, their small on-site still, and their growing portfolio of contract-produced barrels approaching release age. Whether you're a longtime roadie or discovering Old Carter for the first time, this episode is a masterclass in doing small-batch whiskey right.

Full Transcript

Old Carter Whiskey Co Mark Carter Sherry Carter bourbon blending single barrel bourbon double oaked bourbon American whiskey Kentucky straight bourbon barrel strength bourbon small batch bourbon Louisville Kentucky distillery Old Carter Social Club locker program contract distilling 14 year bourbon high proof bourbon whiskey tasting craft whiskey bourbon road podcast Jim Shannon