Skip to content
Episode 324 December 14, 2022 · 01:00:58
324. The Most Surprising Whiskeys of 2022

324. The Most Surprising Whiskeys of 2022

Jason Calori of The Mashing Drum joins Jim to taste Hard Truth Sweet Mash Rye, Wild Turkey 12 Year Export, Jack Daniel's Single Malt & more surprising American whiskeys of 2022.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon welcomes back an old friend and fellow whiskey content creator, Jason Calori of The Mashing Drum, for a wide-ranging conversation about the American whiskey landscape in 2022. The two dig into what genuinely surprised them over the past year — the bottles that came out of nowhere and blew them away, the distilleries quietly doing exceptional work, and the trends reshaping the category. From a young Indiana rye that punched well above its age, to a landmark Jack Daniels single malt, to a small Kentucky distillery bottling barrel-proof weeded bourbon at full strength, the list covers serious ground. Along the way, Jim and Jason touch on the rapid consolidation happening across the industry, the rise of American single malt as a recognized category, the growing world of WhiskeyTube barrel picks, and what Jason may have in store for 2023.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Hard Truth Sweet Mash Rye, Batch 1 (Hard Truth Distilling Co., Nashville, Indiana): A two-to-three-year-old sweet mash rye made from a 94% rye, 6% malted rye mash bill, distilled in Brown County, Indiana. Despite its youth, it shows surprising depth and color, with a nose of spiced apples, caramel, and a touch of mint. The palate is viscous and mouth-coating, layering raisin, licorice, and dark coffee bean against a foundation of orchard fruit and brown sugar. A genuinely unexpected find that holds its own against much older ryes. (00:20:37)
  • Jack Daniel's Double Barrel Single Malt Finished in Oloroso Sherry Casks (Jack Daniel's Distillery, Lynchburg, Tennessee): A limited annual release in the Jack Daniel's Master series, this is the full expression of the distillery's Tennessee high-malt single malt program, finished in Oloroso sherry casks. The nose and palate lead with intense raspberry jam, dark chocolate, and brown sugar malt, while the Jack Daniel's DNA still shows through on the back end in the form of maple syrup and ripe banana. A rich, dessert-forward American single malt that surprised even a skeptical reviewer. (00:21:59)
  • Lincoln Pinch Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey — Single Barrel (Dueling Grounds Distillery, Franklin, Kentucky): A four-year-old, barrel-proof weeded single barrel bourbon bottled at 120 proof from one of Kentucky's smallest distilleries, located just north of the Tennessee state line. The nose offers spice drop candy and licorice. On the palate it is soft yet layered, with notable spice, raisin, and a long, warming finish that closes with candied jalapeño heat. Every drop of this bottle is made, aged, and bottled on site. (00:28:13)
  • Chattanooga Whiskey Founders 10th Anniversary Blend (Chattanooga Whiskey Company, Chattanooga, Tennessee): A special anniversary bottling that blends Chattanooga's own Tennessee high-malt distillate with sourced MGP whiskey from Lawrenceburg, Indiana, uniting the distillery's past and present in a single bottle. The result is mouth-coating and sweet, with chocolate, light smokiness, spicy tobacco, and a rich rye undercurrent. A tribute to Chattanooga's long fight to restore legal distilling to Hamilton County. (00:36:45)
  • Town Branch Virgin White Oak Cask American Single Pot Still Whiskey (Alltech's Lexington Brewing & Distilling / Town'us, Colorado): Billed as the first American single pot still whiskey produced in the United States, this 86-proof expression uses a traditional combination of malted and unmalted barley in the Irish style, matured a minimum of three years in virgin white oak. The nose opens with baking spice and nutmeg. The palate is buttery and honey-sweet, building into maple, toffee, and milk chocolate, before settling into toasted oak and ginger on a sessionable, lingering finish. (00:42:21)
  • Wild Turkey Unforgotten Masters' Keep (Wild Turkey Distillery, Lawrenceburg, Kentucky): The 2022 Masters' Keep release is a blend of 13-year-old Wild Turkey straight bourbon and eight-to-nine-year-old Wild Turkey straight rye, finished in rye casks and bottled at 105 proof. Sweet caramel and cinnamon open the nose. The palate moves through rye spice, stone fruit, dark ginger, and vanilla, maintaining its spice from front to back without going flat. A project conceived with significant input from Master Distiller Emeritus Bruce Russell. (00:46:46)
  • Wild Turkey 101 Proof 12 Year Old Export (Wild Turkey Distillery, Lawrenceburg, Kentucky): Available exclusively in Japan, South Korea, and Australia, this long-aged expression of Wild Turkey 101 presents the familiar distillery profile in a more refined, time-deepened form. The nose carries a distinct cherry note. On the palate, dried cherries carry through alongside brown sugar, cinnamon, clove, and a beautifully integrated oak that never turns tannic or medicinal. The finish is long, fruit-forward, and warm — a bottle that drinks below its stated proof and drew high praise from Wild Turkey historian David Jennings. (00:49:20)

Jim and Jason wrap up with a round of honorable mentions spanning Devil's River Bourbon's improved recent batches, Jeptha Creed Distillery's Red White & Blue release and their six-year weeded bourbon, Green River Distillery's everyday high-rye bourbon and the Wheel Horse 101, Watershed Distillery's reformed mash bill in Columbus, Ohio, and Leopold Brothers Three Chamber Rye — a bottle that ran out before show day but left a lasting impression. Whether you're hunting an affordable shelf staple or chasing a limited export, this episode maps out the American whiskey highlights that genuinely earned their surprise.

Full Transcript

Hard Truth Distilling Hard Truth Sweet Mash Rye Jack Daniels Single Malt Jack Daniels Double Barrel Dueling Grounds Distillery Lincoln Pinch Bourbon Chattanooga Whiskey Wild Turkey Unforgotten Wild Turkey Masters Keep Wild Turkey 101 Export Wild Turkey 12 Year Town Branch American Single Malt American Single Pot Still Jason Calori The Mashing Drum surprising American whiskey craft bourbon Kentucky barrel picks whiskey 2022

The Conversation