Skip to content
Episode 405 August 7, 2024 · 01:16:16
405. Going Off-Road with Todd Ritter

405. Going Off-Road with Todd Ritter

Jim & Todd ditch bourbon entirely for sotol, Ilegal Mezcal Añejo, JT Melick rice whiskey, Foursquare Détente rum, and a 147.9-proof Indiana apple brandy.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Todd Ritter take the Bourbon Road completely off-pavement this week, swapping their usual bourbon and rye lineup for a passport-worthy flight of world spirits. After a warm-up pour straight from a fresh barrel pick, the guys head south of the border and beyond, exploring everything from a Mexican desert-plant spirit to an Indiana apple brandy that nearly melts the thermometer. If your palate has been craving a detour, this is the episode for you.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Bardstown Bourbon Company 95.5 Rye Single Barrel (Mashing Journeys Pick): A 6-year-old, 95.5% rye mash bill single barrel finished in a second-use cherrywood barrel, bottled at 118 proof. Fresh off the barrel just days before recording, this pick delivers root beer and sassafras on the nose, a silky texture, and a long cinnamon-spice finish that the guys compare to Necco wafers dipped in Fireball. Chosen as the feature barrel for the Mashing Journeys "Bardstown Blitz" event. (00:03:25)
  • Hacienda de Chihuahua Sotol Plata (Cazul 100): An unaged, 80-proof sotol distilled from the desert spoon shrub (Dasylirion) grown in northern Mexico — not agave, and legally distinct from tequila or mezcal. The nose offers lightly smoked lime and grilled citrus; the palate turns herbaceous and vegetal with a whisper of medicinal smoke on the finish. One plant yields roughly one bottle, and maturity takes 15–25 years. (00:15:13)
  • Ilegal Mezcal Añejo: A handcrafted, 80-proof Oaxacan mezcal made from Espadin agave, roasted over lava and wood in an open pit and aged a minimum of one year in oak. The nose presents vanilla cream and a cleaner smoke than the sotol; the palate is satiny and well-balanced with light caramel, a touch of smoke, and a faint medicinal note on the tail. Retail runs roughly $90–$110 for the 750ml. (00:26:28)
  • JT Melick Louisiana Rice Whiskey Single Barrel (Mashing Journeys Pick): A 4-plus-year, 100% Louisiana rice whiskey bottled at 119 proof from a family farm established in 1896. The nose is strikingly bourbon-like — vanilla pudding and sweet oak — while the palate opens with silk-smooth sweetness before drifting toward a syrupy, cereal-forward finish the guys describe as "pancake syrup." Single barrels retail around $65. (00:39:03)
  • Foursquare Rum "Détente": A 102-proof, 10-year Barbadian blended rum combining a 10-year bourbon-barrel-aged rum with a rum aged 4 years in bourbon barrels then 6 years in port casks. Dark molasses, burnt caramel, and dried fruit on the nose give way to a palate of sweet smoke, creamy texture, and lingering complexity — so bourbon-adjacent that Todd dubs it "brum." Retail approximately $70. (00:53:54)
  • Spirits of French Lick "Old Clifty" Apple Brandy Single Barrel (Bonus Pour): A double-pot-distilled Indiana apple brandy made from Michigan apples, distilled at 135 proof, entered the barrel at 135 proof, and bottled at a staggering 147.9 proof. The nose is surprisingly approachable — buttery baked apple and Apple Jacks cereal — while the palate delivers a rich, buttery wave of apple before the proof announces itself firmly. A creation of former distiller Alan Bishop. (01:00:50)

Whether you're a devoted bourbon loyalist looking for a weekend adventure or a curious spirits explorer seeking community, Jim and Todd's off-road excursion proves that exceptional craft and great storytelling have no geographic boundaries. Grab your passport, find a comfortable chair, and let this lineup take you somewhere new.

Full Transcript

Tasting Bourbon Finished Single Barrel Kentucky Indiana Bardstown Bourbon Company Bardstown Bourbon Company rye whiskey cherrywood finish sotol Cazul 100 desert spoon Ilegal Mezcal anejo mezcal espadin agave JT Melick Louisiana rice whiskey Foursquare rum Detente rum Barbados rum Spirits of French Lick apple brandy Alan Bishop Mashing Journeys world spirits off-road spirits