Skip to content
Episode 405 August 7, 2024 · 01:16:16
405. Going Off-Road with Todd Ritter

405. Going Off-Road with Todd Ritter

Jim & Todd go fully off-road: sotol, Ilegal Mezcal añejo, a Louisiana rice whiskey at 119 proof, Foursquare Detente rum, and a 147.9-proof Indiana apple brandy.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Todd Ritter take The Bourbon Road completely off the pavement this week, swapping bourbon and rye for a globe-trotting flight of spirits that spans Louisiana, Mexico, Barbados, and Southern Indiana. The episode opens with a warm-up pour of a freshly picked Bardstown Rye — a 95.5 rye mash bill single barrel selected just days earlier as part of the Mashing Journeys Bardstown Blitz event — before the duo officially declares this an "off-road" episode and shifts gears entirely. Along the way, Todd and Jim discuss the upcoming Bourbon on the Banks Festival in Frankfort, Kentucky (October 5th), the Mashing Journeys Bardstown Blitz weekend (September 28–29), and the art of stepping outside your whiskey comfort zone.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Bardstown Rye Single Barrel (Mashing Journeys Pick) — 95.5 Rye Mash Bill, 118 Proof, ~6 Years: A freshly pulled single barrel selected by Todd and the Mashing Journeys crew just three days before recording. Aged in a second-use cherrywood barrel for roughly 18 months on top of a ~4.5-year base age. The nose delivers dark fruits, smoke, and rich barrel char. The palate is silky and full, with root beer, sassafras, cinnamon, and a long, spicy Necco wafer finish that simply refuses to leave. (00:03:28)
  • Kazool 100 Sotol — 80 Proof, Unaged (Blanco/Plata): A Mexican spirit distilled from the desert spoon plant (Dasylirion genus), sourced from one of its three appellations of origin. Completely clear and unaged, this $42.99 bottle from Total Wine opens with a lightly smoky, grilled citrus nose — lime zest and pineapple — and delivers an herbaceous, vegetal palate with a subtle medicinal finish reminiscent of lightly peated Scotch. Refreshing, complex, and a genuine revelation for anyone who thinks Mexico only makes tequila. (00:15:21)
  • Ilegal Mezcal Añejo — 80 Proof, Aged 1+ Year in Oak, Espadin Agave: A handcrafted Oaxacan Mezcal made from Espadin agave, roasted over lava and hot coals, aged at least one year in barrel. Priced around $90–$110 for the 750ml, Ilegal is considered a premium expression in the Mezcal category with a small batch yield of roughly 4,800 bottles. The nose is cleaner than expected — vanilla cream, light caramel, and restrained smoke. The palate is satiny and well-balanced, with caramel, gentle vanilla, and a whisper of the signature medicinal agave note on the very tail end of the finish. (00:26:16)
  • JT Melick Louisiana Rice Whiskey Single Barrel (Mashing Journeys Pick) — 119 Proof, 4+ Years: A single barrel rice whiskey from Branch, Louisiana, distilled by a family that has been farming rice since 1896. Made 100% from Louisiana rice and aged over four years in new oak. At nearly 120 proof, it drinks with shocking softness — the nose is sweet vanilla pudding with warm oak, strikingly bourbon-like on first approach. The palate is pure silk: sweet, syrupy, and buttery with a cereal-forward, pancake-syrup quality that gently departs from bourbon convention. The finish lingers beautifully. Around $65 for this single barrel selection. (00:39:14)
  • Foursquare Detente Single Blended Rum — 102 Proof, 10 Years, Barbados: A release from the acclaimed Foursquare Distillery in Barbados, blending a 10-year bourbon-barrel-aged rum with a component aged four years in bourbon barrels then finished six additional years — arriving at a 10-year age statement. The nose is intensely dark: molasses, burnt caramel, and deep dark fruit. The palate follows with sweet molasses, a subtle sweet smokiness, and impressive texture. Todd dubs it "brum" for its striking bourbon-like character. Around $70 a bottle and a genuine gateway for whiskey lovers curious about fine aged rum. (00:53:56)
  • Old Clifty Apple Brandy Single Barrel (Spirits of French Lick) — 147.9 Proof, Double Pot Distilled: A jaw-dropping cask-strength apple brandy from Spirits of French Lick in Indiana, distilled from Michigan apples using a double pot still process and entered into barrel at 135 proof — climbing to a staggering 147.9 proof by the time of bottling. Despite the extreme proof, the nose is approachable and genuinely beautiful: fresh apple, Apple Jacks cereal, and warm orchard fruit. The palate is buttery, rich, and surprisingly smooth neat, with a full-throttle apple smash and a warming finish. A few drops of water open the nose dramatically. A small pour of water cuts it to approximately 80 proof for a more traditional brandy experience. (01:00:50)

From a freshly-picked cherrywood-finished rye to a nearly 150-proof apple brandy, this off-road episode is a reminder that the world of distilled spirits is vast, surprising, and endlessly rewarding. Jim heads to Puerto Vallarta the morning after recording, and Todd is already planning the next detour. Whether you're a devoted bourbon roadie looking for a palate reset or a curious newcomer, this episode is your permission slip to explore. Subscribe so you never miss a turn, and we'll see you down The Bourbon Road.

Full Transcript

Bourbon Road podcast sotol Kazool 100 Ilegal Mezcal mezcal añejo JT Melick rice whiskey Louisiana rice whiskey Foursquare Detente rum Foursquare Barbados Old Clifty apple brandy Spirits of French Lick Bardstown Rye Mashing Journeys Bourbon on the Banks off-road spirits world whiskey apple brandy mezcal vs tequila cask strength brandy single barrel picks

The Conversation