Stagg 23C
125.9 proof
8–9 years
Bourbon
Buffalo Trace
$70
Buffalo Trace Mash Bill #1 (low rye)
Nose
Cereal grain and hay notes with brown sugar. Lighter on vanilla than previous releases. A hint of grape-jelly-like character typical of Buffalo Trace products.
Palate
Bite across the full palate with balanced, even warmth. Peanut-butter-sandwich-like toasted character. Less numbing than some peers, with even distribution of spice.
Finish
Notably short to medium-short compared to other releases in this flight. Fades quickly despite promising front-end warmth.
Overall Score
3.4 / 5
A well-balanced, lower-proof stag that delivers consistent warmth across the palate but sacrifices the extended finish that defines the line's strongest expressions.
1.0
Undrinkable
2.0
Substandard
3.0
Average
4.0
Very good
5.0
Perfection
Play the excerpt from this tasting