Skip to content
Episode 409 September 4, 2024 · 01:11:31
409. Some Like it Hot

409. Some Like it Hot

Jim & Todd crack open 5 bottles of Stagg — Batch 10, 12, 18, 23C & 24A — to find out which release truly reigns supreme.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Todd Ritter are back in Studio A for another deep-dive comparison tasting, this time turning their attention to Buffalo Trace's barrel-proof flagship — Buffalo Trace Stagg (formerly Stagg Jr.). Spanning more than six years of releases, the guys crack open five bottles ranging from the early numbered batch era all the way through the newest 2024 drop, exploring how the expression has evolved, why certain batches have become legendary, and what the rebranding from "Junior" to simply "Stagg" really means for collectors and casual drinkers alike.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Stagg Jr. Batch 10 (126.4 proof): Released spring 2018, this Mash Bill #1 entry opens with cinnamon, brown sugar, leather, and a hint of dark cherry. The palate is stout and warming — almost meaty — with a deep chest finish that the guys liken to being gently compressed from the inside out. (00:05:42)
  • Stagg Jr. Batch 12 (132.3 proof): The summer 2019 release widely regarded as a fan favorite. Softer and more approachable on the nose than expected, with prominent vanilla, caramel, and baking spice. The palate is silky and mouth-coating with a buttery texture, dark fruit layering, and a long, satisfying finish that rewards slow sipping. (00:14:29)
  • Stagg Batch 18 (131 proof): The first release to drop the "Jr." designation, arriving winter 2022. Peppermint and cinnamon open the nose with an intriguing herbal note. The palate delivers an initial buttery wash but skips the mid-palate almost entirely, landing on a dry, zingy back-of-tongue finish that the hosts find disjointed compared to its predecessors. (00:23:03)
  • Stagg 23C (125.9 proof): The lowest-proof Stagg ever released, dropped winter 2023. Darker in color than the others, it shows a cereal or "hay" quality on the nose alongside brown sugar and lighter vanilla. The palate bites front, middle, and back but fades more quickly than expected — medium-short finish, though balanced across the tongue. (00:38:54)
  • Stagg 24A (127.6 proof): The current release as of summer 2024. Vanilla custard dominates the nose with gentle baking spice underneath and virtually no heat on the sniff. The palate is notably chewier and creamier than the others, with rich caramel sweetness up front giving way to a clean, well-integrated oak on a longer-than-average finish. (00:53:08)

Beyond the pours, Jim and Todd swap notes on Buffalo Trace Mash Bill #1, the distillery's decision to quietly skip a George T. Stagg release when quality didn't clear the tasting panel, the jump in secondary market pricing from the $50 original MSRP to well over $300 for coveted older batches, and the fun of closing the show with a five-way Frankenstein blend. With Bourbon Heritage Month kicking off and both Kentucky Bourbon Festival and Bourbon on the Banks on the horizon, the energy is high and the glasses are full.

Full Transcript

Buffalo Trace Stagg Stagg Jr Stagg vertical tasting Buffalo Trace distillery Mash Bill 1 barrel proof bourbon high proof bourbon bourbon comparison bourbon tasting notes bourbon heritage month Kentucky Bourbon Festival Bourbon on the Banks Frankfort Kentucky George T Stagg bourbon collecting secondary market bourbon baking spice bourbon buffalo trace antique collection Jim Shannon Todd Ritter