Skip to content
Episode 409 September 4, 2024 · 01:11:31
409. Some Like it Hot

409. Some Like it Hot

Jim & Todd taste 5 expressions of Stagg (Jr.) side by side — Batches 10, 12, 18, 23C & 24A — to see which vintage reigns supreme.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Welcome back to The Bourbon Road, where hosts Jim Shannon and Todd Ritter settle in at Studio A for another deep-dive comparison tasting. This time, they open five expressions of Buffalo Trace's barrel-proof powerhouse — Stagg (formerly Stagg Jr.) — spanning releases from 2018 through the summer of 2024. With proofs ranging from 125.9 to 132.3, these are not sipping whiskeys for the faint of heart, and Jim and Todd work their way through each one with characteristic humor, honest palate notes, and a healthy respect for the Buffalo.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Stagg Jr. Batch 10 (Spring 2018): 126.4 proof, Mash Bill #1, Buffalo Trace Distillery. A stout, leathery pour with cinnamon spice, brown sugar, dark cherry, and a pronounced deep-chest warmth that lingers well into the finish. (00:04:58)
  • Stagg Jr. Batch 12 (Summer 2019): 132.3 proof, Mash Bill #1, Buffalo Trace Distillery. The most talked-about batch in the lineup, delivering a silkier mouthfeel than expected at its proof — rich vanilla, caramel, brown sugar, and baking spices with a buttery texture and long, satisfying finish. (00:14:29)
  • Stagg Batch 18 (Winter 2022): 131 proof, Mash Bill #1, Buffalo Trace Distillery. The first release to drop the "Jr." designation, this pour opens with a minty or sassafras-adjacent nose, then delivers a front-and-back palate that skips the mid-section, finishing dry with a lingering back-palate presence. (00:23:48)
  • Stagg 23C (Winter 2023): 125.9 proof, Mash Bill #1, Buffalo Trace Distillery. The lowest-proof release in Stagg history shows a notably darker color, with a grainy cereal or hay note on the nose alongside brown sugar, and a full front-to-back bite on the palate with a medium-short finish. (00:38:41)
  • Stagg 24A (Summer 2024): 127.6 proof, Mash Bill #1, Buffalo Trace Distillery. The most current release leads with prominent vanilla custard on the nose and delivers a chewy, creamy, sweet palate with rich caramel, baking spices, and a long oaky finish that stays sweet rather than drying. (00:53:08)

Jim and Todd close the show by combining their remaining pours into a single impromptu blend — a reminder that great individual whiskeys don't always add up to a great combination. September marks the start of Bourbon Heritage Month, and the guys are gearing up for Kentucky Bourbon Festival and Bourbon on the Banks in Frankfort, where you can find them at the Bourbon Road bar pouring expressions that have appeared on the show throughout the year. Cheers to the road ahead.

Full Transcript

Stagg Jr Stagg Buffalo Trace barrel proof bourbon Mash Bill 1 George T Stagg bourbon comparison Kentucky bourbon bourbon tasting high proof bourbon bourbon heritage month Kentucky Bourbon Festival Bourbon on the Banks Frankfort Kentucky single barrel bourbon bourbon ranking craft bourbon Sazerac bourbon collection whiskey tasting

The Conversation