Skip to content
Episode 106 October 28, 2020 · 54:54
106. Knappogue Castle - 12 Year Bourbon Cask Irish Whiskey

106. Knappogue Castle - 12 Year Bourbon Cask Irish Whiskey

Tony Carroll of Nappogue Castle joins Jim & Mike to taste the 12, 14, and 16 Year Old Irish single malts — aged in bourbon barrels and finished in sherry.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt welcome a very special guest to The Bourbon Road for a detour off the beaten bourbon path and onto the emerald roads of Ireland. Joining them is Tony Carroll, international markets representative for Nappogue Castle Irish Whiskey, who guides Jim and Mike through a vertical tasting of one of Ireland's most storied single malt expressions. Built on a foundation of aged-in-America grade-one bourbon barrels and finished with some of Europe's finest wine casks, Nappogue Castle offers a compelling case for why Irish whiskey deserves a permanent place on any serious whiskey shelf.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Nappogue Castle 12 Year Old Single Malt Irish Whiskey (86 proof): Aged for 12 years in grade-one, grade-three char American white oak ex-bourbon barrels, this triple-distilled single malt is Nappogue Castle's entry-level expression — though "entry-level" undersells it considerably. The nose opens with light golden fruit — peach, pear, and what Mike memorably describes as banana Laffy Taffy — alongside a faint aromatic mint quality. On the palate, the fruit recedes slightly in favor of biscotti, baked goods, white pepper, and a buttery, creamy texture that Tony Carroll calls the hallmark of triple distillation. The finish offers a gentle warmth — what the guys call a shallow Kentucky hug — that lingers pleasantly on the back of the palate. MSRP approximately $35.99. (00:01:46)
  • Nappogue Castle 14 Year Old Single Malt Irish Whiskey (92 proof / 46% ABV): A marriage of 80% 14-year bourbon-cask-aged single malt and 20% 14-year Oloroso sherry-cask-aged single malt, this expression steps up both in complexity and in proof. The nose blooms with apple, apricot, and floral notes alongside strong vanilla and a hint of orange marmalade. On the palate, Mike picks up unmistakable vanilla cake frosting — rich, buttery, and sweet — with fruity-nutty depth and a clear but refined sherry influence. Less peppery than the 12, the 14 is described as a full-flavored, approachable warm-weather sipper at a price that punches well above its weight class. MSRP approximately $60.00. (00:24:27)
  • Nappogue Castle 16 Year Old Single Malt Irish Whiskey (86 proof): Aged for 14 years in grade-one ex-bourbon barrels and then transferred for a full two years into Oloroso sherry casks, the 16 Year Old represents Nappogue Castle's most dramatic wood-influence expression in the core lineup. The color deepens noticeably compared to the 12 and 14, and the nose is immediately and unmistakably dominated by sherry. On the palate, Jim finds rich, creamy sweetness, deeper fruit, and a fuller body than either younger expression, with the oak and sherry working in concert to produce what he describes as a savory undercurrent beneath the sweetness. The proof is dialed back to 86 to ensure the sherry and barrel character take center stage rather than the alcohol. MSRP approximately $100.00. (00:38:02)

Closing Thoughts:

Tony Carroll brings an infectious enthusiasm for Irish whiskey and a refreshingly honest perspective on its history — including the practical, wartime economics that led Irish distillers to embrace the American bourbon barrel as their aging vessel of choice. From the accessible smoothness of the 12-year to the bold sherry-forward complexity of the 16-year, Nappogue Castle makes a compelling argument for Irish single malt as a natural companion — not a competitor — to the bourbon that Jim and Mike love. Find Nappogue Castle at Total Wine, Reserve Bar, and select Irish pubs across the United States, and follow the brand on Instagram and Facebook at Nappogue Whiskey.

Full Transcript

Nappogue Castle Irish whiskey single malt Irish whiskey Tony Carroll Jim Shannon Mike Hyatt The Bourbon Road bourbon barrels Oloroso sherry cask sherry finish triple distilled Middleton County Cork Irish distillery whiskey vertical tasting premium Irish whiskey whiskey aging ex-bourbon cask wine cask finish whiskey tasting notes Irish whiskey brands

The Conversation