Skip to content
Episode 106 October 28, 2020 · 54:54
106. Knappogue Castle - 12 Year Bourbon Cask Irish Whiskey

106. Knappogue Castle - 12 Year Bourbon Cask Irish Whiskey

Tony Carroll of Nappogue Castle joins Jim & Mike for a vertical of the 12, 14, and 16 Year Old Single Malt Irish Whiskeys.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt welcome listeners to another trip down the Bourbon Road — but this week they're taking a scenic detour off the main road and into the rolling green hills of Ireland. Joining them on Stream Yard is Tony Carroll, brand ambassador for Nappogue Castle Irish Whiskey, who guides Jim and Mike through a vertical tasting of three expressions from one of Ireland's most storied and historic whiskey brands. The conversation ranges from the 15th-century McNamara clan and their 42 castles in Munster, to the American entrepreneur who rescued Nappogue Castle from ruin and bottled a legendary 1951 vintage, to the modern craft of sourcing grade-one bourbon barrels from Louisville cooperages and finishing casks from the finest bodegas in Spain and wine estates in France and Italy.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Nappogue Castle 12 Year Old Single Malt Irish Whiskey: Triple-distilled single malt aged 14 years in grade-one, grade-three-char American white oak ex-bourbon barrels, bottled at 43% ABV (86 proof). The lightest and most approachable expression in the lineup, it pours a bright golden amber with long, linear legs on the glass. The nose opens with fresh stone fruit — peach, pear, and a hint of banana taffy — alongside a light aromatic mintiness. On the palate it delivers creamy vanilla, gentle white pepper, and warm biscotti, with a soft, shallow warmth that lingers on the mid-palate. The finish is smooth and inviting, making this an ideal entry point into super-premium single malt Irish whiskey. (00:02:02)
  • Nappogue Castle 14 Year Old Single Malt Irish Whiskey: A marriage of 80% grade-one ex-bourbon cask and 20% Sherry Oloroso cask, both aged a full 14 years, bottled at 46% ABV (92 proof). The step up in proof is immediately perceptible — the nose blooms with apple, apricot, and a floral quality, with vanilla cake frosting and a whisper of orange marmalade woven through. On the palate the bourbon-cask foundation delivers rich vanilla and a nutty sweetness, while the Oloroso influence adds dried-fruit depth and a Christmas-cake warmth. The mouthfeel remains creamy and approachable despite the higher proof, and the finish carries a gentle citrus note. (00:33:51)
  • Nappogue Castle 16 Year Old Single Malt Irish Whiskey: Fourteen years in grade-one ex-bourbon barrels followed by a full two-year finish in Sherry Oloroso casks, bottled at 43% ABV (86 proof). The extended Oloroso finish announces itself immediately — the color deepens noticeably compared to the younger expressions, and the nose is loud with sherry, dark fruit, and malty richness. On the palate it is full-bodied and luscious, with a creamy, viscous mouthfeel, layers of baked oak, a subtle savory note, and a lingering sweetness that coats the mid-palate. The proof is dialed back deliberately to let the cask character speak without alcohol heat overshadowing the Oloroso influence. (00:47:27)

Tony Carroll brings warmth, deep expertise, and genuine enthusiasm to every glass, tracing the history of Nappogue Castle from its medieval origins through its unlikely American revival and into its current era of wine-cask finish expressions. Whether you are a lifelong bourbon drinker curious about Irish single malt or a seasoned whiskey traveler looking for a remarkable value in the super-premium category, this episode is a worthy detour down a very beautiful side road.

Full Transcript

Announcement/Intro Tony Carroll Mike Hyatt Tasting Interview Bourbon Single Malt Kentucky Nappogue Castle Irish whiskey single malt Irish whiskey Tony Carroll Jim Shannon Mike Hyatt The Bourbon Road Sherry Oloroso finish ex-bourbon barrel Middleton County Cork triple distilled 12 year old whiskey 14 year old whiskey 16 year old whiskey super premium whiskey whiskey vertical tasting Irish distillery bourbon barrel aging wine cask finish Kelvin Cooperage