Skip to content
Episode 215 November 15, 2021 · 26:25
215. Johnny Fever Bourbon Whiskey Review

215. Johnny Fever Bourbon Whiskey Review

Burnt Church Distillery's Johnny Fever Four Grain Straight Bourbon lands on the mat — plus the wild TSA story behind how it almost never made it home.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Welcome back to The Bourbon Road! This week Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt are back at the tasting mat for another Craft Distillery Monday, and this one comes with quite a story. Mike recounts a memorable trip to Bluffton, South Carolina, where he and his wife Vivian visited friends in the Margaritaville 55-plus community near Hilton Head — and naturally, a nearby distillery found its way onto the itinerary. What followed was a TSA mishap, a generous act of goodwill to a veteran at the airport USO, and ultimately a very kind gesture from the distillery itself that put two bottles of their flagship bourbon on the tasting table.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Burnt Church Distillery Johnny Fever Four Grain Straight Bourbon Whiskey: A 100-proof, four-grain straight bourbon from Burnt Church Distillery in Bluffton, South Carolina, contract distilled at Jeptha Creed Distillery in Kentucky. The striking bottle is topped with an oversized shotgun shell cork and features gold-leaf detailing — a natural fit for the hunting-season gifting crowd. On the nose, expect dense sticky sweetness reminiscent of sorghum molasses, caramel, a hint of juicy fruit chewing gum, and a light oak presence. On the palate the bourbon delivers a lively, almost pop-rocks-like tingle, with a marshmallow-like sweetness that lingers on the sides of the mouth. The corn sweetness has largely integrated into the oak, suggesting solid age, while the wheat and rye work together to create a uniquely balanced flavor profile. The finish lands in the medium-to-medium-long range with a pleasant warmth. The dark amber color and noticeable viscosity are impressive for the proof point. (00:07:55)

Burnt Church Distillery is a beautifully appointed tasting room destination near Hilton Head — leather couches, an expansive bar, and a team that clearly knows their bourbon. The distillery is actively installing its own stills and aims to be producing its own Kentucky-aged whiskey in the years ahead. While the $99 price point reflects the realities of a young craft operation still finding its footing, both Jim and Mike agree it drinks well right where it is, and that the bottle alone makes it a standout gift for any hunter or outdoors enthusiast in your life. If you find yourself between Savannah, Charleston, or Jacksonville, it is well worth the detour.

Full Transcript

Intro/Outro Mike Hyatt Tasting Interview Distillery Visit Bourbon Kentucky Craft Distillery Burnt Church Distillery Jeptha Creed Distillery Burnt Church Distillery Johnny Fever four grain bourbon craft distillery Bluffton South Carolina Hilton Head Jeptha Creed contract distilled bourbon straight bourbon whiskey 100 proof bourbon bourbon review Craft Distillery Monday The Bourbon Road bourbon podcast Jim Shannon Mike Hyatt South Carolina distillery bourbon gift hunting bourbon small batch bourbon