Skip to content
Episode 218 November 24, 2021 · 01:19:28
218. Wigle Whiskey

218. Wigle Whiskey

Mike visits Pittsburgh's Wiggle Whiskey with Director of Production Michael Fogle to taste four expressions: Pennsylvania Straight Bourbon, Single Barrel, Port Rye, and the smoky Kilted Cask.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt welcome listeners to another trip down the Bourbon Road with a special road-trip episode. Mike recently made the drive up to Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, visiting the historically rich neighborhood along the Allegheny and Monongahela rivers — the very confluence where the Ohio begins and where American whiskey history runs deep. Before sitting down at Wiggle Whiskey, Mike shares stories from the journey, including a stop at the famous Primanti Brothers sandwich shop and a Texas Longhorns road game in Morgantown, West Virginia.

Wiggle Whiskey's Director of Production, Michael Fogle, joins Mike inside the distillery for a guided tasting and conversation about the craft. Named after Philip Weigel — a central figure in the Whiskey Rebellion who refused to pay federal taxes on his rye — Wiggle is Pittsburgh's first distillery to open since Prohibition. Operating out of a building once connected by tunnel to the historic Phoenix Brewing Company, Wiggle has grown from a small family operation in 2012 to a portfolio of over 85 expressions, almost all distilled from organically sourced grain. Michael walks through the philosophy of terroir-driven whiskey making, the challenges of barrel aging across different warehouse environments, supply chain pressures on glass, and the art of blending consistency out of natural variability.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Wiggle Whiskey Pennsylvania Straight Bourbon: A blended straight bourbon made from organic yellow dent corn, organic malted barley, and wheat. A blend of 53-gallon barrels aged at least four years and 25-gallon barrels aged two to three years, bottled at standard proof. USDA certified organic. On the nose: honey, toasted marshmallow, roasted orange peel. On the palate: light and approachable with pop-rocks tingle, toasted marshmallow, and a medium finish with gentle spice. (00:13:43)
  • Wiggle Whiskey Single Barrel Straight Bourbon: A single 53-gallon barrel expression from the same organic mash bill as the standard bourbon, aged five years and eight months, bottled at 100 proof — meeting bottled-in-bond criteria. On the nose: roasted citrus, warmth, slightly less honey sweetness than the blend. On the palate: pop-rocks tingle, toasted marshmallow, roasted lemon-citrus character, more oak presence, and a refined medium-long finish. (00:27:02)
  • Wiggle Whiskey Port Rye (Pork Cask Finished Rye): A straight rye whiskey finished in a blend of Ruby and Tawny port barrels (two Tawny to one Ruby) for approximately two and a half to three years, after an initial three-year aging in charred new American oak. On the nose: honey, Welch's grape jelly, cereal sweetness, powerful and inviting. On the palate: mouth-coating, creamy, oily texture from residual wine sugars; port character beautifully integrated with aged whiskey backbone; approachable and richly layered. (00:37:55)
  • Wiggle Whiskey American Rye Kilted Cask (formerly Kilted Rye): A malted rye whiskey made from 95% organic malted rye and 5% organic malted barley, sourced through Valley Malt in Amherst, Massachusetts. Aged in new and used cooperage, then finished for at least one year in Laphroaig Scotch whiskey casks. On the nose: fireplace wood smoke, clean hardwood character, roasted orange citrus. On the palate: smoked toasted almonds, orange marmalade, honey sweetness, integrated peat smoke that bridges bourbon and Scotch styles without imitating either. (01:00:25)

Wiggle Whiskey is a Pittsburgh original with roots in the Whiskey Rebellion and a vision rooted in local grain, sustainable farming, and a wide-open approach to what American whiskey can be. Whether you're a seasoned bourbon collector or someone just beginning to explore spirits, Wiggle has something crafted with care for you. If you're passing through Pittsburgh, stop in — and raise a glass to Philip Weigel, the rascal who started it all.

Full Transcript

Intro/Outro Announcer Michael Fogle Mike Hyatt Tasting Bottled in Bond Interview Distillery Visit Bourbon Rye Finished Bottled in Bond Single Barrel Ohio Texas Pennsylvania Virginia Wiggle Whiskey Pennsylvania straight bourbon Pittsburgh distillery Michael Fogle Whiskey Rebellion Philip Weigel Monongahela rye port rye Laphroaig cask kilted rye craft distillery organic whiskey barrel finished whiskey single barrel bourbon malted rye whiskey Valley Malt bourbon road podcast American rye whiskey terroir whiskey Pittsburgh food district