Skip to content
Episode 219 November 29, 2021 · 23:49
219. Stagg Jr Bourbon Batch 16 Review

219. Stagg Jr Bourbon Batch 16 Review

Jim & Mike crack open Stagg Jr. Batch 16 (130.9 proof) from their basement bar — is this high-proof Buffalo Trace a must-buy at $49.99?

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt are back in Studio 1A — Mike's basement in Simpsonville, Kentucky — for another Monday deep-dive on the bourbon shelf. The duo settle into the couches, survey the bottles on the wall, and get straight to business with one of Buffalo Trace's most beloved high-proof releases. Between pours, the conversation wanders into deer season, the economics of venison versus beef, and holiday meal planning before snapping back to the glass at hand.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Stagg Jr. Batch 16: A barrel-proof Buffalo Trace Mashbill #1 bourbon bottled at 130.9 proof with an undisclosed age — likely 8–12 years. The pour reveals a deep, dark chocolate-ruby color with legs that cling to the glass. The nose offers Baker's chocolate, cinnamon, and a hint of dark cherry without the scorching heat one might expect at this proof. On the palate it is mouth-coating and full-bodied, delivering chocolate-covered cherry, cinnamon, burnt toffee, and well-integrated oak in a rich, almost creamy texture. The finish is medium to long, warming the chest with a slow-building hug. At a retail price of $49.95, Jim and Mike flag this as a definitive buy for any serious bourbon lover. (00:01:23)

Jim and Mike close out the episode with a reminder that Stagg Jr. is about to shed the "Jr." designation starting with Batch 18, making Batch 16 a small piece of bourbon history worth grabbing while it lasts. Whether you sip it fireside or break it out to impress a guest, this is a bottle built for bourbon veterans — not the faint of heart. Find the guys in the Bourbon Roadies Facebook group, reach out at jim@thebourbonroad.com or mike@thebourbonroad.com, or tag them on Instagram at @jshannon63 and @bigbourbonchief.

Full Transcript

Stagg Jr Stagg Jr Batch 16 George T Stagg Buffalo Trace Buffalo Trace Mashbill 1 barrel proof bourbon high proof bourbon Kentucky bourbon bourbon review bourbon podcast The Bourbon Road Jim Shannon Mike Hyatt Simpsonville Kentucky Buffalo Trace Antique Collection cask strength bourbon bourbon tasting notes bourbon gift guide craft bourbon bourbon community

The Conversation