Skip to content
Episode 219 November 29, 2021 · 23:49
219. Stagg Jr Bourbon Batch 16 Review

219. Stagg Jr Bourbon Batch 16 Review

Jim & Mike crack open Stagg Jr. Batch 16 at 130.9 proof — chocolate, cinnamon, cherry, and a serious Kentucky hug.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt are back in Studio 1A — otherwise known as Mike's basement bar in Simpsonville, Kentucky — for another Monday bottle deep dive. The guys settle in among the shelves, swap stories about deer season, venison economics, and the rising cost of beef before getting down to business with one of Buffalo Trace's most beloved high-proof expressions.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Stagg Jr. Batch 16: A barrel-proof bourbon from Buffalo Trace Distillery bottled at 130.9 proof. Produced from Buffalo Trace's undisclosed Mash Bill #1 (low-rye, shared with Eagle Rare, E.H. Taylor, and the Buffalo Trace flagship), this release carries an undisclosed age statement that Jim and Mike estimate at eight-plus years based on its deep, dark color. On the nose, dark baker's chocolate, maraschino cherry, and cinnamon emerge with surprising restraint for the proof. The palate is mouth-coating and full-bodied — described as a cream that covers every corner of your mouth — with burnt toffee, oak, and a moderate sweetness that never overwhelms. The heat is present but well below what 130.9 proof might suggest, landing closer to 115 in feel. The finish is medium to medium-long, with a serious chest-warming hug that lingers. Retail price: $49.95. (00:01:23)

Jim and Mike close out with a strong recommendation: if you can find Stagg Jr. Batch 16 at or near retail, it's a buy. They'd pay up to $75 for it but draw the line at $100. This is not a daily sipper — it's a pour-two-and-put-it-back bottle best enjoyed fireside on a cold Kentucky winter night. The guys also remind listeners about their private Facebook community, the Bourbon Roadies, now 2,500 members strong, and encourage five-star reviews to help grow the show and the broader bourbon community.

Full Transcript

Stagg Jr Stagg Jr Batch 16 Buffalo Trace Distillery Buffalo Trace Mash Bill 1 barrel proof bourbon high proof bourbon George T Stagg Eagle Rare E.H. Taylor Kentucky bourbon bourbon review bourbon podcast The Bourbon Road Jim Shannon Mike Hyatt Simpsonville Kentucky low rye mash bill cask strength bourbon Buffalo Trace Antique Collection bourbon tasting notes