Skip to content
Episode 289 July 27, 2022 · 01:12:15
289. Four Gate Whiskey Company

289. Four Gate Whiskey Company

Bill Straub of Fourgate Whiskey pours Batches 21–24 — Port Perry Perry, Indiana Foundation, Barossa Creek BriRye, Bourbon Down Under — plus a stunning 144-proof 14-year bonus dram.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt load up the Red Chariot and head west to the Fourgate Whiskey Company East headquarters for a sit-down with founder Bill Straub. Bill and his partner Bobby D'Antoni built Fourgate on a simple but demanding premise: start with genuinely great whiskey, finish it thoughtfully in world-class cooperage, and never try to hide an inferior spirit behind an exotic barrel. The result is a small-batch, barrel-proof lineup that has grown from a handful of barrels in 2019 to roughly 3,000 barrels today, distributed across eight states and several online retailers. Bill walks Jim and Mike through the company's origin story — from his days running the modernthirst.com blog and consulting for national brands, to that fateful phone call that sent him pulling over on a Kentucky interstate to secure nearly 12-year-old bourbon for Batch 1 — and previews what's coming next, including a year-round split-stave bourbon and single-barrel program.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Fourgate Whiskey Company Batch 22 – Indiana Foundation (10 Year): A 10-year-old Indiana straight bourbon from Dearborn County distilled on the lower-rye mash bill (75% corn, 21% rye, 4% malted barley), bottled at barrel proof at approximately 109 proof with roughly 1,130 bottles produced. The nose opens with candied citrus zest, mandarin orange, tangerine, and what Jim calls raisin cinnamon toast with orange marmalade. The palate echoes that citrus candy character — think orange spice candies with a sugar coating — and the finish is warm and approachable. Available in Kentucky, Indiana, Louisiana, and Illinois, as well as sealbox.com, bourbonoutfitter.com, and caskers.com. (00:03:17)
  • Fourgate Whiskey Company Batch 21 – Port Perry Perry (8 Year Rye): An 8-year-old Indiana straight rye whiskey finished in Australian tawny port casks, coming in at 112 proof with approximately 2,148 bottles. The nose delivers strawberry taffy, a hint of salt air, and a deep candy sweetness. On the palate, candied spice arrives first, followed by a black pepper bite and a lingering warmth reminiscent of spicy root beer barrel candies. Named after two gentlemen named Perry who were instrumental in Fourgate's early days. Available in all eight Fourgate states — Kentucky, Indiana, Tennessee, Georgia, Florida, Texas, Louisiana, and Illinois — plus online retailers. (00:17:57)
  • Fourgate Whiskey Company Batch 23 – Barossa Creek (BriRye): Fourgate's third iteration of their proprietary BriRye blend — a marriage of 6- and 7-year-old Kentucky straight bourbon (75% corn, 21% rye, 4% malted barley) and 8-year-old Indiana straight rye (95.5% rye), finished in Australian tawny port casks. Bottled at 121.3 proof with approximately 1,280 bottles. The nose is creamy, caramelly, and butterscotch-forward with a Heath bar-like richness. The palate delivers a full flavor explosion of caramel, chocolate, butterscotch, and back-end fruit notes that some have likened to a rum finish. A long, warming finish. Available in Kentucky, Georgia, Tennessee, Florida, Texas, and Louisiana, plus online. (00:33:46)
  • Fourgate Whiskey Company Batch 24 – Bourbon Down Under: A high-rye Indiana straight bourbon (60% corn, 36% rye, 4% malted barley), approximately 6.5 years old, finished in Australian parish area casks — the Australian analog to Oloroso sherry, running slightly sweeter than European expressions. Bottled at 116.6 proof with approximately 2,178 bottles. The nose shows deep red floral notes like roses, burnt toffee, and a buttery nuttiness. The palate delivers baker's chocolate, dark plum, stewed fruits, salted caramel, and a pop-rocks tingle on the finish that Bill attributes to the high-rye mash bill. Available in all eight Fourgate states plus online. (00:33:46)
  • Fourgate Whiskey Company – Indiana Foundation 14 Year (Bonus / Unreleased): A rare 3-barrel release of 14-year-old Indiana straight bourbon yielding fewer than 120 bottles total, bottled at an extraordinary 144.3 proof. The concentrated ethanol evaporates on contact with the tongue, leaving behind a deeply sweet, cherry cobbler-like richness — dark cherry fruit that has somehow endured through 14 years of oak. Retailing around $450, this ultra-limited bottling will be released at a single Kentucky location (Justin's) with a case or two available online. (00:56:33)

Four batches officially hitting shelves and one jaw-dropping bonus pour — it's a full afternoon at Fourgate HQ. Bill Straub is as generous with his knowledge as he is with his whiskey, and whether you're hunting the spicy BriRye Barossa Creek or chasing down one of the fewer-than-120 bottles of the 14-year Indiana Foundation, this episode gives you everything you need to know before you hit the buy button.

Full Transcript

Fourgate Whiskey Bill Straub Bobby D'Antoni Kelvin Cooperage MGP Indiana Indiana bourbon barrel finishing tawny port finish Australian sherry BriRye high rye bourbon straight rye whiskey sourced whiskey small batch bourbon barrel proof bourbon bourbon blog modernthirst bourbon tasting craft whiskey limited release bourbon

The Conversation