Skip to content
Episode 289 July 27, 2022 · 01:12:15
289. Four Gate Whiskey Company

289. Four Gate Whiskey Company

Bill Straub of Fourgate Whiskey joins Jim & Mike to pour Batches 21–24 plus a stunning 144-proof 14-year Indiana bourbon bonus.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt load up the Red Chariot and head west to visit Bill Straub, co-founder of Fourgate Whiskey Company, at the brand's East headquarters in Louisville, Kentucky. Bill walks the guys through the story of how Fourgate was born — from Bill's blogging days at ModernThirst.com to a late-night phone call that launched a partnership with Bobby D'Antoni and the legendary cooperage Kelvin Cooperage. With nearly 3,000 barrels in inventory and distribution expanding across eight-plus states through Republic National, Fourgate has grown from a scrappy startup into one of the most respected barrel-finishing operations in American whiskey. Bill shares insights on sourcing strategy, the art of light finishing, the new Gettysburg bottle design, and what's coming next — including a consistent year-round SKU and a second round of single barrel releases.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Fourgate Batch 22 – Indiana Foundation (10 Year): A rare unfinished release from Fourgate, this 10-year-old Indiana straight bourbon carries the lower rye mash bill (21% rye) from the Dearborn County distillery. Bottled at approximately 109 proof from just over 1,100 bottles, it delivers candied orange zest, raisin cinnamon toast, and a sweet, easy-drinking profile that Bill himself warns disappears quickly. Available in Kentucky, Indiana, Louisiana, and Illinois. (00:03:16)
  • Fourgate Batch 21 – Port Perry Perry (8 Year Rye): Named in honor of two pivotal early contacts named Perry, this 8-year-old Indiana straight rye is finished in Australian tawny port barrels and bottled at 112 proof barrel strength. Roughly 2,150 bottles were produced, distributed across all eight Fourgate states. Expect strawberry taffy, salt air, candied spice, and a long peppery finish with root beer barrel warmth. (00:17:57)
  • Fourgate Batch 23 – Barossa Creek (BRye): Fourgate's third iteration of their signature BRye blend — a marriage of 6- and 7-year-old Kentucky straight bourbon (75% corn, 21% rye, 4% malted barley) and 8-year-old Indiana straight rye (95.5% rye), finished in Australian tawny port barrels. Bottled at 121.3 proof from just under 1,300 bottles, this one pours creamy caramel and butterscotch on the nose with a Heath bar richness on the palate, dark fruit on the finish, and a warming depth that some have likened to a rum finish. (00:33:35)
  • Fourgate Batch 24 – Bourbon Down Under: A high-rye Indiana bourbon (60% corn, 36% rye, 4% malted barley) aged approximately 6.5 years and finished in Australian Pares Sherry casks — Australia's sweeter answer to Oloroso. Bottled at 116.6 proof with around 2,178 bottles, it shows deep red floral notes, burnt toffee, baker's chocolate, salted caramel, and a tingling pop-rocks finish that Bill attributes to the high-rye mash bill. (00:48:38)
  • Fourgate Indiana Foundation 14 Year (Bonus / Unreleased): A breathtaking single-lot release of just under 120 bottles sourced from three barrels of 14-year-old Indiana bourbon, bottled at a staggering 144.3 proof. The barrels were on their last leg, yielding a concentrated, almost evaporating palate experience — smoke-touched cherry cobbler, deep sweetness, and an ethereal finish unlike anything else in the Fourgate lineup. Retail around $450 and available exclusively at Justin's in Louisville plus a handful of online cases. (00:56:33)

Bill also teases what's ahead for Fourgate: a year-round split-stave bourbon and rye at a slightly lower $175 price point, a returning Oloroso-rum finish expression, 40 single barrel releases finishing in toasted casks, and the possibility of contract distillation as early as 2025. Whether you're a longtime Fourgate collector or hearing about the brand for the first time, this episode is a masterclass in thoughtful sourcing, barrel finishing philosophy, and what it means to build a whiskey company around great liquid first.

Full Transcript

Intro/Outro Narrator Bill Straub Mike Hyatt Tasting Distillery Visit Bourbon Rye Finished Single Barrel Kentucky Indiana Fourgate Whiskey Bill Straub barrel finishing Indiana bourbon MGP tawny port finish Australian sherry cask BRye Kelvin Cooperage sourced bourbon high rye bourbon straight rye whiskey barrel proof bourbon Bobby D'Antoni craft whiskey small batch bourbon bourbon road podcast Pares Sherry hazmat proof bourbon bourbon finishing