Skip to content
Episode 234 January 19, 2022 · 41:41
234. Top Four Affordable Rye Whiskeys

234. Top Four Affordable Rye Whiskeys

Jim & Mike taste 4 ryes under $30 — Redemption, Old Forester, Rittenhouse BIB & Old Overholt BIB — live from an Owensboro hotel lobby.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt are live on the road this week, recording from the lobby of their hotel in Owensboro, Kentucky — mimosas, Bloody Marys, and a full day of distillery visits already behind them. The boys settle in with four carefully chosen rye whiskies, all under thirty dollars, to make the case that affordable rye deserves a serious place on your bar and behind every great cocktail. Expect background chatter, curious hotel guests, and the kind of honest, easygoing conversation that makes The Bourbon Road feel like pulling up a barstool with old friends.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Redemption Rye: A 92-proof high-rye expression sourced from MGP in Indiana, built on a 95% rye / 5% malted barley mash bill. Delivers immediate spice up front — minty, peppery, with a pine forest quality on the nose — before giving way to a bright candy sweetness that Jim and Mike both find surprisingly approachable for a rye of this intensity. Around $27 and widely available. (00:06:31)
  • Old Forester Rye 100 Proof: A 100-proof, Kentucky-made rye from Brown-Forman distilled on a distinctive 65% rye / 20% malted barley / 15% corn mash bill — inspired by the historic Normandy rye recipe and co-developed by master distillers Jackie Zykan and Chris Morris. The nose offers orange zest and warm pie spice; the palate leans into cocoa, a subtle nuttiness, and the faint banana note characteristic of Brown-Forman's house style. Retails around $20–$22 in a no-frills screw-top bottle designed for the bar well. (00:19:55)
  • Rittenhouse Rye Bottled in Bond: Heaven Hill's 100-proof, four-year-old bottled-in-bond rye built on a barely-legal 51% rye / 37% corn / 12% malted barley mash bill — squarely in the Kentucky rye tradition. The higher malted barley content gives it an earthy, almost truffle-like depth alongside dried-fruit sweetness and a touch of corn warmth. A classic cocktail workhorse priced around $25. (00:23:34)
  • Old Overholt Bottled in Bond: One of the oldest continuously marketed American whiskey brands, dating to 1810 and now produced under the Beam Suntory umbrella, this 100-proof four-year-old rye carries an undisclosed mash bill with Pennsylvania rye heritage. The nose is minty and floral with a light sweetness; the palate brings a firm peppery spice, a distinct horehound candy character, and a long drying finish. Available for roughly $26–$28. (00:29:39)

Whether you are building a cocktail program, stocking a home bar, or simply exploring what American rye whiskey has to offer, Jim and Mike make a compelling argument that the best value in whiskey may be hiding on the bottom shelf. Top the evening off with a Lone Star concert and some legendary Owensboro barbecue, and you have a proper bourbon road trip.

Full Transcript

rye whiskey affordable rye Redemption Rye Old Forester Rye Rittenhouse Rye Old Overholt bottled in bond Heaven Hill Brown-Forman MGP Jim Beam Kentucky rye Pennsylvania rye bourbon cocktails old fashioned Manhattan Owensboro Kentucky Green River Distillery rye mash bill whiskey under 30