Skip to content
Episode 234 January 19, 2022 · 41:41
234. Top Four Affordable Rye Whiskeys

234. Top Four Affordable Rye Whiskeys

Jim & Mike go on the road in Owensboro, KY to taste 4 affordable ryes under $30: Redemption, Old Forester, Rittenhouse, and Old Overholt Bottled in Bond.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt hit the road for this episode of The Bourbon Road, recording live from the lobby of their hotel in Owensboro, Kentucky — surrounded by curious passersby, traveling basketball teams, and the ambient energy of a weekend getaway. Between a bottomless mimosa brunch at the famous Bistro, a visit to a local distillery, and tickets to see 90s country band Lone Star, the guys carved out time to do what they do best: pour some whiskey and talk about it. This episode is all about affordable rye whiskies — four bottles, all under $30, and all worth knowing.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Redemption Rye: A 92-proof high-rye expression sourced from MGP in Indiana using a 95% rye, 5% malted barley mash bill. This is one of the bottles that helped revive American rye whiskey, and it shows — delivering immediate spice, a minty pine-forest nose, cinnamon candy sweetness, and a peppery finish with lingering confectionary depth. (00:06:31)
  • Old Forester Rye 100 Proof: A 100-proof Kentucky-made rye built on a high-malt mash bill of 65% rye, 20% malted barley, and 15% corn, inspired by a 1940s Normandy rye recipe and crafted in collaboration with Master Distiller Chris Morris and Ambassador Jackie Zykan. The nose offers orange zest, pie spice, and brown sugar sweetness, while the palate delivers cocoa, a hint of banana, and a satisfying nutty warmth. (00:19:55)
  • Rittenhouse Rye Bottled in Bond: A 100-proof, four-year-old bottled-in-bond rye from Heaven Hill Distillery made with a 51% rye, 37% corn, and 12% malted barley mash bill — placing it squarely in the "barely legal" Kentucky rye category. The nose opens with corn sweetness and dried banana, while the palate brings earthy spice, a hint of truffle, and a subtle cocoa edge. (00:25:38)
  • Old Overholt Bottled in Bond: A 100-proof, four-year-old bottled-in-bond rye from Beam's portfolio with an undisclosed mash bill and roots stretching back to 1810. Once the only nationally distributed rye whiskey in post-WWII America, it delivers a classic rye nose of mint and floral sweetness, with horehound candy, menthol-adjacent spice, and a pleasantly drying finish on the palate. (00:29:39)

Whether you're stocking a home bar, looking for the perfect cocktail base, or just wanting to explore what American rye has to offer without breaking the bank, Jim and Mike have made the case loud and clear: for under $100, you can own all four of these bottles and have a serious rye whiskey education in a single sitting. Pair any of them with charcuterie, Indian food, or a classic old fashioned made with Seldom Seen Farms bourbon-aged maple syrup — and enjoy the ride.

Full Transcript

rye whiskey affordable rye Redemption Rye Old Forester Rye Rittenhouse Rye Old Overholt bottled in bond Heaven Hill MGP Jim Beam Brown Forman Kentucky rye rye mash bill cocktail whiskey bourbon road Owensboro Kentucky Green River Distillery rye whiskey history under 30 whiskey whiskey tasting

The Conversation