Skip to content
Episode 75 July 15, 2020 · 56:26
75. Bourbon and Coke Challenge

75. Bourbon and Coke Challenge

Jim & Mike blind-taste 6 whiskies in Coke — Wild Turkey 101, Larceny, Weller Special Reserve, Jim Beam Single Barrel, Old Forester Rye & Four Roses Yellow Label.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Welcome back to The Bourbon Road with hosts Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt, recording live at Jephtha Ben Farrell on a scorching summer day. With the heat bearing down outside, the guys settle in with a cold glass and a mission: to find out which whiskey makes Coca-Cola taste the best. Six bottles, one jigger each, poured over ice into roughly four to six ounces of Coke — it's a blind tasting like you've never heard on the show before. Along the way, Jim and Mike swap stories about granddad reflexes, designated driving misadventures, goat castrations, bison wrestling fantasies, and the timeless joy of Saturday morning cartoons.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Wild Turkey 101 Bourbon: A Kentucky straight bourbon bottled at 101 proof from Wild Turkey Distillery in Lawrenceburg, KY. Mashbill is corn-forward with a rye secondary grain. In the mix, the bourbon takes a subdued role, allowing the Coke's sweetness to lead without the whiskey asserting itself prominently. (00:04:34)
  • Old Forester Rye: A straight rye whiskey bottled at 100 proof from Brown-Forman's Old Forester Distillery in Louisville, KY. High-rye mashbill lends significant spice. Mixed with Coke, it produces a notably sweet, almost cherry-like quality that surprised both hosts. (00:14:46)
  • Larceny Small Batch Bourbon (94 proof): A wheated Kentucky straight bourbon at 94 proof from Heaven Hill Distilleries in Bardstown, KY. The wheat secondary grain softens the profile. In Coke, it brings out caramel notes while delivering a clean, well-integrated bourbon presence without excessive sweetness. (00:26:29)
  • Jim Beam Single Barrel Bourbon: A single barrel expression from Jim Beam Distillery in Clermont, KY, bottled at higher proof than the standard white label. Mixed with Coke it delivers a balanced blend of spice and sweetness with caramel coming through, presenting as the quintessential bourbon-and-Coke experience. (00:33:53)
  • Four Roses Yellow Label Bourbon: The entry-level expression from Four Roses Distillery in Lawrenceburg, KY, using a blend of their ten recipes. At 80 proof, it is one of the more accessible bourbons on the shelf. In Coke, the hosts detected an unexpected bitterness on the front palate that stood out in this context. (00:41:16)
  • Weller Special Reserve Bourbon: A wheated Kentucky straight bourbon from Buffalo Trace Distillery in Frankfort, KY, bottled at 90 proof. The wheat-forward mashbill shared with the Pappy Van Winkle line gives it a soft, approachable character. Mixed with Coke, dark fruit notes — described as plum and prune — emerged, mellowing as ice diluted the drink over time. (00:47:21)

By the end of six pours on a blazing summer afternoon, Jim and Mike have a clear sense of which bottles shine brightest when mixed with America's most iconic soft drink — and which ones are better left to a neat pour. Whether you're a lifelong bourbon-and-Coke loyalist or a curious sipper looking for your next mixer, this episode is a refreshing reminder that the road to great bourbon doesn't always have to be a straight one. Grab a tall glass, drop in some ice, and ride along. We'll see you down the Bourbon Road.

Full Transcript

Mike Hyatt Tasting Interview Bourbon Rye Wheated Single Barrel Small Batch Kentucky Wild Turkey Distillery Old Forester Distillery Jim Beam Distillery Four Roses Distillery Buffalo Trace Distillery Brown-Forman Heaven Hill Jim Beam Buffalo Trace Wild Turkey Four Roses Old Forester bourbon and coke whiskey and coke blind tasting Larceny bourbon Wild Turkey 101 Old Forester Rye Jim Beam Single Barrel Four Roses Yellow Label Weller Special Reserve Heaven Hill Buffalo Trace Brown-Forman Jim Beam Distillery wheated bourbon rye whiskey bourbon mixer bourbon cocktail Kentucky bourbon summer bourbon The Bourbon Road podcast