Skip to content
Episode 75 July 15, 2020 · 56:26
75. Bourbon and Coke Challenge

75. Bourbon and Coke Challenge

Wild Turkey 101, Larceny, Old Forester Rye, Jim Beam Single Barrel, Four Roses Yellow Label & Weller Special Reserve go head-to-head in Coke — blind.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt are back at Jephtha Ben Farm for a hot summer day episode of The Bourbon Road, and they are keeping things cool with ice in the glass. Rather than sipping neat, the guys turn the format on its head and explore a question every bourbon drinker has faced at some point: which whiskey makes the best bourbon and Coke? Six bottles line the counter, and Mike pours them blind for Jim one at a time, letting the flavors speak for themselves against a backdrop of classic Coca-Cola. Along the way the guys swap stories about late-night designated driving duties, granddad reflexes saving a wayward teddy bear, a memorable dinner at Barn Eight in the Prospect-Goshen area outside Louisville, and the trials of mowing a hill farm in hundred-degree heat.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Wild Turkey 101 Bourbon: Produced at Wild Turkey Distillery in Lawrenceburg, Kentucky, at 101 proof, this high-rye mashbill staple is one of the most recognizable bottles on any shelf. Mixed with Coca-Cola it delivers a recognizable whiskey-and-Coke character, though the bourbon presence settles into the background rather than asserting itself forward. (00:04:38)
  • Old Forester Rye: Distilled at Brown-Forman's Old Forester Distillery in Louisville, Kentucky, this 100-proof straight rye brings a notably elevated sweetness to the glass, with a near cherry-Cola impression that surprises both hosts. The rye grain character integrates with the cola's own cane sugar in a way that pushes the drink toward dessert-sweet territory. (00:14:46)
  • Larceny Kentucky Straight Bourbon: Heaven Hill's wheated bourbon bottled at 92 proof, Larceny replaces the traditional rye secondary grain with wheat, producing the softer, rounder profile the brand is known for. In a Coke mix it brings forward caramel depth and a complementary sweetness without overwhelming the drink, allowing the bourbon itself to remain clearly present. (00:21:44)
  • Jim Beam Single Barrel Bourbon: A single-barrel expression from America's best-selling bourbon producer, bottled at 95 proof. In the glass with Coca-Cola it delivers what both hosts describe as a well-rounded, quintessential bourbon-and-Coke experience, balancing spice and sweetness with a caramel note that integrates cleanly with the cola. (00:33:50)
  • Four Roses Yellow Label Bourbon: Four Roses' entry-level expression, blending all five proprietary yeast strains across two mashbills and bottled at 80 proof. When mixed with Coca-Cola a slightly bitter, upfront note emerges that catches the hosts off guard, though the drink settles into a more familiar character as the ice melts and the flavors open. (00:41:16)
  • Weller Special Reserve Bourbon: Buffalo Trace Distillery's wheated entry-level expression, bottled at 90 proof and part of the highly sought-after Weller family. In the Coke mix dark fruit — described as plum and prune — emerges on the palate, an unexpected character that evolves as the drink opens up, shifting toward a softer cherry note with dilution. (00:46:21)

By the end of the session Jim and Mike have worked through all six expressions, found genuine surprises in the results, and reminded themselves — and their listeners — that there is absolutely no wrong way to enjoy bourbon. Whether you are a dedicated neat sipper or a loyal bourbon-and-Coke devotee, the important thing is that you are on the bourbon road at all. Cheers from Jephtha Ben Farm.

Full Transcript

bourbon and coke whiskey and coke blind tasting Larceny bourbon Wild Turkey 101 Old Forester Rye Jim Beam Single Barrel Four Roses Yellow Label Weller Special Reserve Heaven Hill Brown-Forman Buffalo Trace wheated bourbon rye bourbon bourbon cocktail bourbon mixer Kentucky bourbon bourbon podcast The Bourbon Road summer bourbon drinks

The Conversation