Skip to content
Episode 198 September 15, 2021 · 01:08:35
198. Buffalo Trace Benchmark Bourbon Collection Review

198. Buffalo Trace Benchmark Bourbon Collection Review

Jim & Mike taste all six Benchmark expressions from Buffalo Trace — 80 proof to 125 proof — including the rare Single Barrel and the stunning Full Proof.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Welcome back to The Bourbon Road, where hosts Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt settle in at Jephthah Bend Farm for a deep dive into one of bourbon's most accessible and storied names. It's Bourbon Heritage Month, episode 198 is in the books, and the guys are closing in on a milestone 200th episode — all the more reason to pull out six bottles and let the whiskey do the talking. Today's focus is the newly expanded McAfee's Benchmark lineup from Buffalo Trace, a brand with roots stretching back to 1960 and named for the three McAfee brothers who surveyed the Kentucky wilderness and stumbled upon what would one day become one of the most famous distillery sites in the world.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Benchmark Old No. 8 Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey: The entry-level expression bottled at 80 proof and aged at least 36 months, as stated on the neck label. Light apple-juice color with a corn-forward, youthful nose and a palate that is clean but lean — light body, minimal sweetness up front, and a slightly bitter finish that fades quickly. Retails around $10.99 and is widely available. Best suited for mixing — think hot toddies, bourbon and Coke, or cooking applications. (00:06:48)
  • Benchmark Top Floor Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey: Stepping up to 86 proof, this expression is sourced from barrels that matured on the upper floors of the rickhouse, where heat accelerates aging. The color is a touch deeper than the entry-level, and the nose picks up a crisp green-apple fruitiness alongside light caramel. The palate delivers more body and a hint of mid-palate sweetness, with a short but present finish that adds a gentle warmth. Retails around $16.99. (00:10:01)
  • Benchmark Small Batch Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey: Bottled at 90 proof and selected by the master distiller from multiple barrels, this expression opens with a noticeably richer nose — caramel, vanilla, honey, and what the guys describe as a wrapped Neapolitan-style candy sweetness. On the palate, the corn sweetness softens in favor of a peppery, honeyed mid-section with a drying oak finish. At $14.99, it sits just below the Top Floor in price but a step above in proof. (00:17:22)
  • Benchmark Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey: At 95 proof, this is the hardest expression in the lineup to track down. The nose is markedly more developed — sorghum, molasses, dried fig, crisp apple, and honey butter — and the palate follows with butterscotch-forward richness, a growing spice presence, and a noticeably longer finish with palm fruits and dark dried fruit character. Rumored to contain barrels aged up to ten years, though no age statement appears on the label. Retails around $24.99. (00:31:20)
  • Benchmark Bonded Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey: Bottled in bond at 100 proof, this expression meets all four requirements of the Bottled-in-Bond Act — same distillery, same distilling season, same master distiller, and a minimum of four years age. The nose is rich with caramel, butterscotch, Medjool dates, and honey butter. The palate delivers a satisfying mid-section of palm fruits and baking spices, with a pleasant warming finish. At $19.99, it represents outstanding value in the growing category of bonded bourbons. (00:44:16)
  • Benchmark Full Proof Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey: The showpiece of the lineup, bottled at 125 proof — the barrel-entry proof, meaning nothing has been added or diluted beyond what naturally occurred during aging. Deep amber in color, the nose leads with rich butterscotch, caramel, Medjool dates, and a hint of anise. The palate is full and wide, delivering sweetness across the entire experience — front, mid, and finish — with a lively pop-rocks tingle on the sides of the tongue, layers of dark candy, and a long, satisfying close with notes of sassafras and horehound. Retails around $21.99, making it one of the most impressive value propositions in the full-proof category. (00:49:39)

Jim and Mike close out episode 198 with a clear appreciation for what Buffalo Trace has built with the expanded Benchmark lineup — a complete range from $10 mixer to $22 sipping whiskey, all under one historically rooted name. Whether you're stocking a bar cart on a budget or looking for a crowd-pleasing pour to share with friends around a fire this fall, there's a Benchmark expression worth your attention. Catch them at the Bourbon Festival, the Duck Duck Bourbon charity event on September 25th in Shelbyville, Kentucky, and at Bourbon on the Banks in Frankfort on October 22nd and 23rd — and stay tuned, because episode 200 is right around the corner.

Full Transcript

Benchmark bourbon McAfee's Benchmark Buffalo Trace Benchmark Full Proof Benchmark Single Barrel Benchmark Bonded Bottled in Bond bourbon Benchmark Top Floor Benchmark Small Batch Buffalo Trace distillery Kentucky straight bourbon bourbon heritage month budget bourbon high proof bourbon bourbon tasting Sazerac Frankfort Kentucky bourbon on the banks Westport Whiskey and Wine value bourbon

The Conversation