Skip to content
Episode 24 September 25, 2019 · 01:47:27
24. Collaboration - A Look Through The Bourbon Lens

24. Collaboration - A Look Through The Bourbon Lens

Jim & Mike host The Bourbon Lens guys (Scott & Michael) for a five-bottle cast-strength rye showdown: Peerless, Kentucky Owl Batch 1, Willett Estate, Sagamore, and Jay Mattingly.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim and Mike from The Bourbon Road welcome Scott and Michael from The Bourbon Lens podcast for a night of cast-strength rye whiskey in Simpsonville, Kentucky. With a hundred-degree day ruling out the planned backyard bonfire, the four settle indoors and work through five carefully chosen bottles from a lineup of twelve cast-strength ryes, letting conversation about distilleries, daily drinkers, and the bourbon community flow as freely as the whiskey.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Peerless Three-Year Single Barrel Rye "Spiced Tea" (Cask Strength, ~110 proof): Kentucky Peerless Distilling Co.'s single-barrel straight rye, released with a named tasting profile on the label. Bottled at approximately 110 proof and aged three years in Louisville, KY. The nose opens with deep buttery caramel and toffee, with floral and orange citrus accents. The palate delivers an extraordinary mouthfeel for its age — oily, coating, and expansive — with cinnamon spice, orange peel, and a persistent peppery finish reminiscent of Pop Rocks. A hint of licorice root and horehound candy rounds out the experience. (00:04:33)
  • Kentucky Owl Straight Rye Whiskey Batch 1 (110.6 proof, 11 years): Hand-blended by Dixon Deadman and bottled in Bardstown, KY, this small-batch rye carries an age statement of at least 11 years and is bottled at 110.6 proof. The nose leads with rich deep caramel and a warm sweetness. On the palate it is viscous and oily with slow-forming legs in the glass, offering sugar-coated orange slices, mocha, and a building cinnamon warmth. The spice arrives more on the back end, with clove and cedar notes rounding out a full and satisfying finish. (00:20:44)
  • Willett Family Estate Bottled Small Batch Rye (111.8 proof, 4 years): Produced at Willett Distillery in Bardstown, KY, this four-year straight rye is bottled at 111.8 proof under the "Family Estate" label. The nose is distinctly bright and minty — a hallmark character of the Willett profile — with floral notes and a hint of juniper. The palate is less overtly peppery than expected, with a prominent floral character, boysenberry fruit, and a gently toasted quality. The finish lingers with subtle herbaceous complexity. (00:42:01)
  • Sagamore Spirit Cask Strength Rye (112.2 proof): Distilled in Indiana and bottled by Sagamore Spirit in Maryland, this no-age-statement straight rye is bottled at 112.2 proof. The nose is unexpectedly fruity and somewhat unusual — described as bitter stone fruit, possibly apricot or fig. The palate, however, is a pleasant surprise: sweet, juicy, and candy-like, with notes of Twizzlers, cinnamon candy, and a rich nectarine or fig Newton quality. The finish is notably long and deepening, with oak and wood building behind the lingering fruit sweetness. (01:07:45)
  • Jay Mattingly 1845 "Fickle Mistress" Single Barrel Straight Rye (129 proof, 4 years): A single-barrel rye selected by Jay Mattingly of Bourbon 30 Spirits in Georgetown, KY, distilled in Indiana and bottled at 129 proof from a barrel that yielded approximately 120 bottles. The color is extraordinarily dark — nearly opaque, deeper than most aged bourbons — which belies its four-year age statement. The nose is surprisingly approachable for the proof, with cocoa powder and rich sweetness. The palate is bold, thick, and syrupy with maple syrup, Hershey's chocolate, caramel, and a deep coffee-like richness. The finish is long and warming. (01:21:17)

Four bourbon guys venturing deep into cast-strength rye territory make for an honest and entertaining tasting session. The Bourbon Lens team bring genuine enthusiasm and a community-first philosophy that mirrors everything The Bourbon Road is about — sharing stories, meeting people, and letting what's in the glass speak for itself.

Be sure to check out The Bourbon Lens wherever you listen to podcasts, follow them on Instagram at @bourbonlens, and visit bourbonlens.com. Thanks for riding along with us.

Full Transcript

Kentucky Peerless Distilling Peerless rye whiskey Kentucky Owl rye Dixon Deadman Willett Distillery Willett Family Estate rye Sagamore Spirit Jay Mattingly Bourbon 30 Spirits cast strength rye cask strength whiskey The Bourbon Lens podcast MGP Indiana rye single barrel rye straight rye whiskey bourbon podcast Bardstown Kentucky Simpsonville Kentucky rye whiskey tasting American whiskey

The Conversation