Skip to content
Episode 24 September 25, 2019 · 01:47:27
24. Collaboration - A Look Through The Bourbon Lens

24. Collaboration - A Look Through The Bourbon Lens

Scott & Michael from The Bourbon Lens join Jim & Mike to taste 5 cast-strength ryes: Peerless, Kentucky Owl Batch 1, Willett Family Estate, Sagamore Cask Strength, and Jay Mattingly 1845.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim and Mike welcome Scott and Michael from The Bourbon Lens podcast for an evening of cast-strength rye whiskeys at Jim's place in Simpsonville, Kentucky. What was originally planned as a backyard bonfire session got moved indoors thanks to triple-digit heat, but the hospitality was warm all the same. With a table full of roughly a dozen cast-strength ryes to choose from, the four guys narrowed the field to five of the most interesting bottles and worked through them one by one, trading stories about distillery visits, podcast origins, daily drinkers, and the bourbon community that keeps pulling people together.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Peerless Single Barrel Straight Rye Whiskey "Spiced Tea" (3 Year): A single-barrel, non-chill-filtered Kentucky rye from Peerless Distilling in Louisville. Bottled at approximately 110–111 proof, this three-year expression delivers a rich, buttery toffee and butterscotch nose with a floral undertone and a hint of oak. On the palate it explodes with pepper, citrus, orange, and a pop-rock-like intensity that coats every corner of the mouth. The finish carries licorice root and a faint horehound candy note, lingering with surprising complexity for its age. (00:04:33)
  • Kentucky Owl Straight Rye Whiskey Batch 1: A small-batch, hand-blended rye crafted by Dixon Deadman and bottled at 110.6 proof. Aged a minimum of 11 years, this Kentucky rye pours with deep, slow-forming legs and delivers a rich dark caramel nose alongside warmth from the proof. The palate opens with an oily, almost syrupy texture, then moves through cinnamon, mocha, and sugar-coated orange-slice sweetness before a long, peppery finish. Described on the label as "The Wise Man's Rye," the bottle design was created by Sherry Carter. (00:40:41)
  • Willett Family Estate Bottled Small Batch Straight Rye Whiskey (4 Year): Distilled and bottled at Willett Distillery in Bardstown, Kentucky, this small-batch rye comes in at 111.8 proof. On the nose it offers pronounced floral and minty notes that are immediately recognizable as a Willett hallmark. The palate is lively with fruit — a boysenberry or mixed-berry quality — alongside some floral brightness and a gentle spice. The finish is softer on the pepper than expected, with a clean, slightly herbaceous character. (01:01:41)
  • Sagamore Spirit Cask Strength Straight Rye Whiskey: Distilled in Indiana and bottled in Maryland by Sagamore Spirit, this no-age-statement rye comes in at 112.2 proof. The nose reads as an unusual and somewhat sharp bitter fruit that catches the group off guard. The palate, however, surprises with a lush, juicy fruitiness — nectarine, fig Newton, and cinnamon candy — that diverges completely from the nose. The mouth feel is rich and the finish is extraordinarily long, building in depth and oakiness as it goes, leaving a warm, mouth-watering sensation well after the sip. (01:07:45)
  • Jay Mattingly 1845 "Fickle Mistress" Single Barrel Straight Rye Whiskey (4 Year): A single-barrel selection by Jay Mattingly for Bourbon 30 Spirits in Georgetown, Kentucky, distilled in Indiana and bottled at 129 proof. Only 120 bottles were drawn from the barrel. The color is extraordinarily dark — nearly opaque — for a four-year whiskey, suggesting aggressive rick-house aging. Despite the high proof, the nose is restrained, offering cocoa powder and rich wood. On the palate it is bold, syrupy, and deeply concentrated, with maple syrup, Hershey's chocolate, caramel, and a coffee-adjacent richness that recalls a well-aged bourbon. The finish is hot but full, with lasting dark-sweet complexity. (01:21:17)

From swapping origin stories about how two bourbon podcasts got started — Michael's cubicle-daydream moment versus Jim's inspiration from the Mash and Drum YouTube channel — to debating bottle pricing philosophy, barrel placement, and what it really means to drink bourbon your way, this is a relaxed and genuine gathering between people who clearly love the craft and the community around it. Raise a glass to Scott, Michael, Jim, and Mike for a night well spent on the Bourbon Road.

Full Transcript

Podcast Introduction (AI/Automated) Michael Scott Mike Tasting Interview Distillery Visit Bourbon Rye Cask Strength Single Barrel Small Batch Kentucky Indiana Peerless Distilling Willett Distillery cast strength rye whiskey Peerless Distilling Kentucky Owl Willett Family Estate Sagamore Spirit Jay Mattingly Bourbon Lens podcast The Bourbon Road Dixon Deadman Caleb Kilburn MGP Indiana rye single barrel rye Bourbon 30 Spirits rye whiskey tasting Kentucky whiskey bourbon podcast cask strength whiskey small batch rye bourbon community Simpsonville Kentucky