Skip to content
Episode 245 February 23, 2022 · 54:27
245. Garrison Brothers Distillery

245. Garrison Brothers Distillery

Big Chief Mike sits down with Garrison Brothers Master Distiller Donnis Todd to taste Small Batch, Guadalupe, and the legendary Cowboy Bourbon in Hye, Texas.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Big Chief Mike flies solo down to the Texas Hill Country, pointing his red chariot toward Hye, Texas, and one of the Lone Star State's most celebrated whiskey destinations — Garrison Brothers Distillery. Nestled on a working ranch outside Fredericksburg, Garrison Brothers is the kind of place that stops you in your tracks the moment you turn off the highway: barrel barns stretching across the landscape, 25,000 barrels quietly cooking in the famous Texas heat, and a team of passionate volunteers hand-dipping every bottle in wax. Mike is joined by Master Distiller Donnis Todd, a ten-year Air Force veteran turned whiskey craftsman who has been building Garrison Brothers' reputation one barrel at a time for over fifteen years.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Garrison Brothers Texas Straight Bourbon Whiskey Small Batch (Batch 2022-4, 94 Proof): The backbone of the entire Garrison Brothers lineup, this wheated Texas straight bourbon is built from a mash bill of 74% white corn, 15% two-row red soft winter wheat, and 11% barley malt — all sourced from Texas farmers Donnis knows personally. Aged in custom toasted-then-charred white American oak barrels and hand-selected 50 to 55 barrels at a time by Donnis, the nose opens with kettle corn, burnt toffee, and a whisper of campfire smoke. The palate is rich with cream corn sweetness, caramel, and warm butter, supported by a gentle white pepper spice on the finish. (00:02:06)
  • Garrison Brothers Guadalupe (107 Proof): A port-finished expression born from Donnis's barrel selection process — when barrels destined for small batch show natural port-like characteristics (raspberry, cinnamon, chocolate sauce), they are set aside, dumped, and finished for roughly two years in wet port barrels. Bottled at 107 proof without added water or filtration, Guadalupe opens with a beautiful floral potpourri nose that transitions into a rich, well-balanced palate. The port finish adds a pleasing crispness and slight drying on the back end while the core sweetness of the wheated bourbon remains front and center. (00:13:56)
  • Garrison Brothers Cowboy Bourbon (2021 Vintage, 131 Proof): Cast-strength and unfiltered, Cowboy is Donnis's seventh vintage of this fan-favorite release. Built entirely from what he calls "piggy bank" barrels — those nearly empty barrels left over from his small batch selection process, where all the flavor has concentrated into one or two gallons — these barrels are gathered, aged further, then married together and bottled exactly as they come from the barrel. The nose is an indulgent wave of buttered toffee, cinnamon bun, toasted marshmallow, and s'mores. On the palate the flavor completely masks the 131-proof proof point, delivering a long, sticky, candy-store finish with remarkable depth. (00:30:34)

Cocktail Feature — The John Daly: Garrison Brothers Small Batch bourbon combined with equal parts iced tea and lemonade — the distillery's riff on an Arnold Palmer, named for the hard-charging professional golfer. Light, refreshing, and dangerously easy-drinking, it paired beautifully alongside brisket, house-made sausage, German potato salad, and ranch-style beans from the legendary Salt Lick BBQ. (00:41:55)

From the rolling Hill Country ranchland to the volunteers hand-dipping bottles two days at a time, Garrison Brothers is proof that Texas bourbon is no longer a punchline — it's a destination. Mike and Donnis close out the afternoon with a preview of something truly special on the horizon: a cast-strength, honey-infused, cognac-finished bourbon that sounds like it might just be Garrison Brothers' most ambitious release yet. If you've never made the drive to Hye, Texas, consider this your invitation. And if you can't make it in person, find your way to a bottle of Cowboy Bourbon and pour yourself a John Daly — you'll understand the fuss immediately.

Full Transcript

Garrison Brothers Donnis Todd Texas bourbon Texas straight bourbon Cowboy Bourbon Guadalupe port finish small batch bourbon wheated bourbon sweet mash Texas Hill Country Hye Texas Fredericksburg Texas craft distillery barrel selection cast strength bourbon port finished whiskey John Daly cocktail Salt Lick BBQ bourbon tasting master distiller

The Conversation