Skip to content
Episode 383 February 7, 2024 · 01:07:25
383. An Ohio Whiskey Roadies Trip

383. An Ohio Whiskey Roadies Trip

Jim Shannon & Ohio Roadies taste Echo Spirits, Indian Creek, Watershed, Minglewood BIB, Middle West Dark Pumpernickel Rye & Doc Schmickle's Root Beer Whiskey.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon loads up the car, heads north out of Kentucky, and lands in Northwestern Ohio for a table full of fellow Bourbon Roadies and a lineup of Ohio-made whiskeys. Joining Jim and Melody are Mark and Amy Ratliff, Rhett and Kelly Francis, and Doug and Laura Keller — all Upper Sandusky-area bourbon lovers who assembled six Ohio whiskeys, three pizzas from local joints, and plenty of good conversation about craft distilling, control-state hunting, and the surprisingly deep bench of Ohio distilleries.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Echo Spirits Barrel Proof Straight Bourbon Whiskey (Batch 1): A 112-proof high-rye corn bourbon from Columbus, Ohio's Echo Spirits Distillery, released around 2019. Younger in age but lively on the nose with floral aromatics, sweet honey, and a tea-like quality. The palate delivers spiced pear, a pronounced rye kick, and a long warming finish. Around $50 at retail. (00:04:25)
  • Indian Creek Distillery American Bond House Bourbon Whiskey #1: A bold 120-proof, two-year-old straight bourbon from New Carlisle, Ohio, made on an 1820 pot still and double pot-distilled. Mash bill is 95% corn and 5% malted barley. Deceptively gentle on the nose with vanilla and fruit sweetness, it opens up on the palate with surprising balance, a rich corn sweetness, and a long, warming finish. Available only at the distillery for around $75. (00:11:50)
  • Watershed Distillery Bottled in Bond Bourbon Whiskey: A 100-proof, at-least-four-year bonded bourbon from Watershed Distillery in Columbus, Ohio. Non-chill filtered with an undisclosed mash bill. Light on the nose with soft honey notes, it presents a silky, full-mouth texture on the palate — gentle sweetness, mild spice, and a smooth, approachable finish. Available in select states and via mail order for around $50. (00:19:43)
  • Minglewood Distilling Bottled in Bond 100 Proof Bourbon Whiskey: A five-year-old, 100-proof bonded bourbon from Minglewood Distilling in Wooster, Ohio. Mash bill is 70% yellow corn, 25% winter rye, and 5% soft winter wheat. The nose is clean and vanilla-cream forward. On the palate it delivers a dry, high-rye spice with a cooling, minty finish and a long rye-forward back-palate. Available only at the distillery for around $65. (00:33:43)
  • Middle West Spirits Dark Pumpernickel Rye Straight Rye Whiskey (Batch 017): A 96-proof four-grain straight rye from Middle West Spirits in Columbus, Ohio, made with pumpernickel rye, soft winter wheat, yellow corn, and malted barley — all Ohio-sourced grains. The nose is distinctly earthy and aromatic, evoking fresh cedar shavings and a pine forest floor. The palate explodes with layered, complex flavor — sweet, full-bodied, and rich — with a long, evolving finish. (00:45:50)
  • Doc Schmickle's Small Batch Root Beer Whiskey (by Minglewood Distilling): A 70-proof flavored whiskey from Minglewood Distilling in Wooster, Ohio, released in October 2023. Crafted to evoke the classic root beer barrel hard candy, it opens with a pronounced root beer aroma and delivers an authentic root beer candy finish while still allowing the whiskey character to come through. Available only at the distillery. (00:57:40)

From a quietly growing Columbus scene to a 200-year-old family distillery resurrection near Dayton and a converted ice house in Wooster, this episode makes a compelling case that Ohio is writing its own chapter in American whiskey history. Jim and the crew wrap up with praise for the state's craft producers, a round of laughs about mice in Rick house paintings, and a promise to get back to Columbus for more distillery visits. Cheers from Northwestern Ohio.

Full Transcript

Echo Spirits Distillery Indian Creek Distillery Watershed Distillery Minglewood Distilling Middle West Spirits Dark Pumpernickel Rye Ohio bourbon Ohio whiskey craft distillery bottled in bond barrel proof bourbon high rye bourbon Doc Schmickles root beer whiskey Columbus Ohio distillery Wooster Ohio distillery New Carlisle Ohio bourbon roadies straight rye whiskey four grain whiskey Ohio craft spirits