Skip to content
Episode 383 February 7, 2024 · 01:07:25
383. An Ohio Whiskey Roadies Trip

383. An Ohio Whiskey Roadies Trip

Jim Shannon & Ohio roadies taste Echo Spirits, Indian Creek, Watershed, Minglewood, Middle West Pumpernickel Rye & a root beer whiskey surprise.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Melody hit the road and headed north out of Kentucky into Northwestern Ohio, setting up shop with a table full of fellow Bourbon Road roadies for a night of Ohio whiskey exploration. Joining Jim at the table are Mark Ratliff, Rhett Francis, and Doug Keller — all longtime listeners and bourbon lovers — along with their wives Amy, Kelly, and Laura. The crew worked through five Ohio-made whiskeys (plus a bonus pour in each half), covering craft distilleries from Columbus to Wooster and beyond, paired with a spread of local Northwestern Ohio pizzas from Don Tomasso, Suzy's, and Spanky's.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Echo Spirits Barrel Proof Straight Bourbon Whiskey (Batch #1): A 112-proof straight bourbon from Columbus, Ohio's Echo Spirits, distillery founded around 2019. Made from a blended corn and high-rye mash bill. Floral and aromatic on the nose with sweet honey and tea notes; spicy on the palate with hints of spiced pear. Long, warming finish. (00:05:00)
  • Indian Creek Distillery American Bond House Bourbon Whiskey #1: A 120-proof, two-year-old bourbon from Indian Creek Distillery near New Carlisle, Ohio, made on stills dating to 1820. Mash bill is 95% corn and 5% malted barley, double pot-stilled. Deceivingly mild on the nose with fruit and vanilla sweetness; fuller and warmer on the palate, with a long, enveloping finish. Distillery-only release at $75. (00:12:00)
  • Watershed Distillery Bottled-in-Bond Bourbon (Bonus Pour, First Half): A 100-proof, at least four-year-old bonded bourbon from Watershed Distillery in Columbus, Ohio. Non-chill filtered with an undisclosed mash bill. Light honey nose; soft, creamy mouthfeel with vanilla and gentle sweetness. Minimal spice, medium finish with a clean, mild character. Available in six states and select online. (00:20:00)
  • Minglewood Distilling Bottled-in-Bond Bourbon Whiskey: A 100-proof, five-year-old bonded straight bourbon from Minglewood Distilling in Wooster, Ohio. Mash bill: 70% yellow corn, 25% winter rye, 5% soft winter wheat. Light vanilla cream nose; on the palate it delivers a dry, spiced finish with rye-driven pepper and a cooling, slightly minty character. Available only at the distillery, approximately $65. (00:35:00)
  • Middle West Spirits Dark Pumpernickel Rye Straight Rye Whiskey (Batch #017): A 96-proof straight rye whiskey from Middle West Spirits in Columbus, Ohio. Four-grain mash of pumpernickel rye, soft winter wheat, yellow corn, and malted barley (percentages undisclosed). Deeply unusual nose — earthy, cedar-like, reminiscent of a pine forest floor. The palate explodes with layered, complex flavors — full-bodied, sweet, and rich — releasing in waves across the tongue. Highly distinctive and unlike any other Ohio whiskey on the mat. (00:46:00)
  • Doc Schmickle's Small Batch Root Beer Whiskey by Minglewood Distilling (Bonus Pour, Second Half): A 70-proof flavored whiskey from Minglewood Distilling in Wooster, Ohio. Released in October, inspired by the classic root beer barrel hard candy. The whiskey backbone remains present while the root beer flavoring is well-integrated and not cloying. The finish delivers a dead-on root beer barrel candy impression. Distillery-only release. (00:55:00)

From Columbus craft distilleries to a centuries-old family operation in New Carlisle, Ohio's whiskey scene is quietly building something impressive. Jim and the roadies wrap the night with plans to visit Watershed, Indian Creek, and Middle West in person — and Doug reveals his new commission art business, Country Acres Art, specializing in Rick house paintings and farm animal portraits. If you're road-tripping through the Buckeye State, consider adding a few of these distilleries to your itinerary — you won't be disappointed.

Full Transcript

Echo Spirits Indian Creek Distillery Watershed Distillery Minglewood Distilling Middle West Spirits Dark Pumpernickel Rye Doc Schmickle Ohio bourbon Ohio whiskey craft distillery bottled in bond barrel proof rye whiskey Columbus Ohio Wooster Ohio bourbon road trip bourbon roadies Jim Shannon high rye bourbon flavored whiskey

The Conversation