Skip to content
Episode 253 March 23, 2022 · 01:33:13
253. Michter's Distillery

253. Michter's Distillery

Andrea Wilson & Dan McKee of Michter's pour Barrel Strength Bourbon & Rye alongside their core Small Batch Bourbon and Single Barrel Rye in Shively, KY.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt head to Shively, Kentucky — the heart of bourbon country — for an afternoon at Michter's Distillery, surrounded by the ghosts of National Distilleries, Stitzel-Weller, and Early Times. Sitting down with Chief Operating Officer and Master of Maturation Andrea Wilson and Master Distiller Dan McKee, the guys dig into the remarkable story of a brand that traces its roots to a Swiss Mennonite farmer in 1753 Pennsylvania, nearly disappeared in 1989, and came roaring back to life in Louisville through three distinct phases of production. From low barrel-entry proof to natural wood seasoning, heat cycling, and custom chill filtration, Andrea and Dan walk through the full philosophy behind what makes Michter's whiskey tick.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Michter's Small Batch Kentucky Straight Bourbon: A classic, well-balanced Kentucky straight bourbon bottled at 84.8 proof, batched in lots equivalent to just 20 full barrels. Entered into new charred oak at 103 proof — well below the legal maximum — and aged to taste profile rather than age statement, typically falling in the five-to-seven-year range. Nose delivers rich tobacco, caramel, leather, and cinnamon, with the palate echoing a warm rice pudding with raisins. Remarkably smooth for its style. (00:03:39)
  • Michter's Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Rye: An 84.8 proof Kentucky-style rye bottled barrel by barrel, built on a mash bill closer to the 51% rye minimum than the high-rye Pennsylvania tradition. Floral and inviting on the nose with honeysuckle and candy sweetness, baking spice on the palate, and a caramel-forward finish that makes it one of the most approachable rye whiskeys on the market. A year-round sipper that has helped drive the modern rye renaissance. (00:23:44)
  • Michter's Limited Release Barrel Strength Kentucky Straight Bourbon: A Kentucky-only limited release bottled at 114.4 proof directly from the barrel with no water reduction beyond custom chill filtration. Deeply rich in color — a dark mahogany — with a nose and palate that expand on the small batch profile into something decidedly more decadent. Creamy and viscous on the palate with dark chocolate, vanilla, and a long, warming finish. Remarkably well-balanced for its proof. (00:43:59)
  • Michter's Limited Release Barrel Strength Kentucky Straight Rye: Bottled at 114.4 proof from a single barrel, this expression takes the floral elegance of the standard single barrel rye and amplifies it into something altogether more substantial. Honey butter and honeysuckle dominate the nose, with prominent baking spice, citrus, and a richness on the palate that is viscous and lingering. Widely regarded internationally, this barrel strength rye commands a devoted global following. (01:00:01)

Beyond the whiskey, Andrea and Dan pull back the curtain on Michter's six core production philosophies, the history of the Fort Nelson Distillery in downtown Louisville, and the next generation of talent rising through the ranks. If you've been curious about what separates Michter's from the crowd, this is the episode to pour a glass and settle in for.

Full Transcript

Intro/Show opener Big Chief (ad read - Seldom Seen Farms) Andrea Wilson Unknown guest/staff member Mike Hyatt Tasting Bourbon Rye Single Barrel Small Batch Kentucky Pennsylvania Fort Nelson Distillery Michter's Distillery Andrea Wilson Dan McKee barrel strength bourbon barrel strength rye Kentucky straight bourbon Kentucky straight rye small batch bourbon single barrel rye master of maturation master distiller Shively Kentucky Fort Nelson Distillery low barrel entry proof heat cycling bourbon maturation Pam Howman bourbon tourism American whiskey bourbon tasting