Skip to content
Episode 257 April 6, 2022 · 01:20:01
257. At Castle and Key Distillery

257. At Castle and Key Distillery

Brett Connors (Castle & Key Whiskey Wizard) pours Restoration Bourbon Batch 2, two single-barrel ryes, and a sneak peek at their unreleased white wheat bourbon.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt roll the Red Chariot right down the road to one of Kentucky's most storied distillery sites — Castle & Key in Millville, just outside Frankfort — for a sit-down with Brett Connors, the self-styled Whiskey Wizard and blending mind behind some of the most exciting new whiskey coming out of the historic Old Taylor property. Brett walks Jim and Mike through the distillery's revival story, from machetes and porta-potties to 36,000 barrels a year, and shares his philosophy on blending by vintage rather than chasing consistency at scale. Along the way, the conversation winds through E.H. Taylor's original bourbon tourism hustle, the legacy of the on-site warehouses, and what's quietly aging in white wheat barrels that has Mike already planning a return trip.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Castle & Key Restoration Bourbon Batch 2: The second inaugural bourbon release from Castle & Key, bottled at 99 proof — a whisper above barrel strength — from a mash bill of 73% white corn, 10% rye, and 17% malted barley. All barrels were aged on-site in Warehouse B, averaging around four years and six to seven months with a mix of Char 3 and Char 4 toasted barrels. The nose opens with an airy, almost piney whisper — cedar and pine nuts — alongside a subtle tartness reminiscent of orange peel. The palate is notably creamy and buttery with a long, spice-driven finish that lingers like a good salsa. (00:01:57)
  • Castle & Key Restoration Rye Single Barrel (Serial #~Low, ~119 proof): One of the earliest Restoration Rye single barrels sold through Castle & Key's on-site retail space, now sold out. The mash bill runs 63% rye, 17% yellow corn, and 20% malted barley, bottled at approximately 119 proof from the third floor of Warehouse B. The nose delivers an earthy, mineral quality — fresh-pulled carrots from the garden, zesty citrus, and rounded earthiness. On the palate it blooms into cinnamon Twizzler-style candy notes: bright, sweet, and slightly citrusy with a stone-fruit character that reflects the high barley percentage and upper-warehouse aging. (00:22:27)
  • Castle & Key Restoration Rye Single Barrel (Serial #1216, 121.1 proof): A second single barrel rye from the same mash bill — 63% rye, 17% yellow corn, 20% malted barley — bottled at 121.1 proof, likely from the fourth floor of Warehouse B. The nose leans toward baking cabinet: warm spice, sassafras, and spiced apple rings with a slight medicinal sweetness. The palate continues in that direction with layered baking spice, stone fruit, and a long, balanced finish. Despite the elevated proof, it drinks with a sense of poise that belies its barrel strength. (00:48:51)
  • Castle & Key Restoration Wheat Bourbon Single Barrel (Work in Progress): An informal preview pour of Castle & Key's unreleased weeded bourbon, distilled from 73% white corn, 10% white wheat, and 17% malted barley. Sourced from white wheat grown by the Holcomb family at Walnut Grove Farm in Adairville, Kentucky — the same variety introduced to Kentucky for the Triscuit plant. Still short of the team's five-year minimum for release, this barrel nonetheless shows a strikingly soft, velvet-smooth entry with Triscuit-like cracker notes on the nose and a palate that hints at phyllo dough, pie crust, and sweet bread. Rich and pillowy in texture with depth that promises to deepen with another year of age. (01:03:36)

On the Tasting Mat:

Castle & Key has quietly assembled one of the more compelling young whiskey portfolios in Kentucky, and this conversation with Brett Connors makes it clear that patience and a light blending hand are the house philosophy. Whether you're chasing the sold-out Batch 2 bourbon or keeping an eye out for whatever the wheat barrels become, a visit to the grounds — botanical gardens, spring house, boiler room and all — is reason enough to point the car toward Millville.

Full Transcript

Ad Read/Intro (The Bourbon Road) Mike Hyatt Brett Connors Tasting Distillery Visit Bourbon Single Barrel Kentucky Castle & Key Castle and Key Brett Connors Restoration Bourbon Restoration Rye white wheat bourbon EH Taylor Jim Shannon Mike Hyatt Bourbon Road Kentucky bourbon single barrel rye craft distillery Frankfort Kentucky bourbon blending weeded bourbon warehouse aging bourbon tasting whiskey wizard high malt bourbon bourbon tourism