Skip to content
Episode 27 October 16, 2019 · 01:36:33
27. Inside Kentucky Peerless with Master Distiller Caleb Kilburn

27. Inside Kentucky Peerless with Master Distiller Caleb Kilburn

Master Distiller Caleb Kilburn joins Jim & Mike to pour four expressions — Small Batch Bourbon, Small Batch Rye, Citrus & Cedar, and Vintage Manhattan singles.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt welcome listeners to another trip down the Bourbon Road from Louisville, Kentucky, where they sit down with Caleb Kilburn, Master Distiller at Kentucky Peerless Distilling Company. Caleb walks them through his remarkable journey from a dairy farm in Salt Lick, Kentucky, to helming one of the most acclaimed craft distilleries in the country — all before the age of 30. Along the way, the conversation covers sweet mash philosophy, barrel warehouse strategy, the science behind distillation, and the unforgettable sell-out release of Peerless's first bourbon in over a century.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Kentucky Peerless Small Batch Bourbon: Peerless's flagship small batch bourbon, released at barrel strength around 109–110 proof with no added water. A carefully assembled blend of individually graded barrels chosen for complementary strengths across the flavor wheel. Tasting notes include caramel and toffee on the nose, with earthy undertones of leather, tobacco, burnt oak, dried orange zest, and a peppery, lingering finish. (00:02:01)
  • Kentucky Peerless Small Batch Rye: A Kentucky-style rye featuring corn in the mash bill alongside rye, released at barrel strength. This expression carries the heritage of the award-winning two- and three-year-old releases and has now been updated to a four-year-plus age statement. Tasting notes include spearmint, citrus, cedar, floral aromatics, tea, and spice, with balance as its defining hallmark. (00:23:03)
  • Kentucky Peerless Single Barrel Bourbon – Citrus and Cedar: A distillery-exclusive single barrel bottled at barrel strength near 110 proof. Named for its defining characteristics, this barrel opens with cedar and orange-spice notes, evolving over time toward a sweet, savory smoke quality with tea-like herbaceous complexity and a dry, citrusy palate. (00:49:23)
  • Kentucky Peerless Single Barrel Bourbon – Vintage Manhattan: A distillery-exclusive single barrel bottled at barrel strength near 110 proof. Named for its wine-like character, this barrel delivers an immediately aromatic, floral, and richly sweet nose with notable oak presence. The palate is full and viscous, with dark stone fruit, plum, raisin, a touch of Luxardo cherry syrup, and a depth that Caleb describes as his personal favorite of the four expressions poured. (01:12:07)

Caleb Kilburn's story is one of self-driven passion, honest work ethic, and a genuine love for the craft — from whittling cedar sticks at horse shows to engineering the pipe systems that now produce award-winning whiskey. Kentucky Peerless Distilling Company is located at 10th Street in Louisville's historic Whiskey Row district, offering grain-to-glass tours on the half hour. Visitors can explore their single barrel offerings in the gift shop or reach out about barrel selections at kentuckypeerless.com.

Full Transcript

Narrator/Intro Mike Hyatt Caleb Kilburn Tasting Interview Distillery Visit Bourbon Single Barrel Small Batch Kentucky Kentucky Peerless Distilling Kentucky Peerless Distilling Caleb Kilburn small batch bourbon small batch rye single barrel bourbon barrel strength whiskey sweet mash craft distillery Louisville Kentucky Whiskey Row master distiller Kentucky rye whiskey barrel selection Jim Shannon Mike Hyatt The Bourbon Road bourbon tasting craft whiskey barrel aging distillery tour