Skip to content
Episode 26 October 9, 2019 · 01:00:00
26. Third Pour - Basement Bottle Kill and Private Bourbon Blend

26. Third Pour - Basement Bottle Kill and Private Bourbon Blend

Jim & Mike clean out the bar with Jim Beam Black, Old Forester 1910, Henry McKenna 10-Year Bottle in Bond, and Jim's secret house blend "Old Hoot."

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt pull up a couple of chairs in Jim's basement for a laid-back hang session, cleaning out the bar and catching up on everything from the Kentucky Bourbon Festival in Bardstown to an upcoming birthday trip to Nashville. No guests, no agenda — just two friends working through some bottles that are running low and letting the conversation flow wherever it wants to go.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Jim Beam Black Extra Aged: A step above the standard Jim Beam white label, this 86-proof Kentucky straight bourbon delivers warm caramel and oak on the nose with a slightly drying mid-palate and a short-to-medium finish. Light in color for a supposedly extra-aged expression, but genuinely enjoyable and an excellent value at roughly $22. (00:03:44)
  • Old Forester 1910 Old Fine Whiskey (Second Release, 93 Proof): Inspired by an apocryphal 1910 distillery incident that produced what Old Forester calls the first double-barreled bourbon, this 93-proof release is noticeably darker than the Beam Black and carries rich dark caramel, toasted marshmallow, honeysuckle, and a subtle chocolate note. The extra time in a second charred barrel adds depth and a syrupy body without making the oak oppressive. (00:15:15)
  • Henry McKenna 10-Year Single Barrel Bottle in Bond (Barrel #4648, Barreled June 2007): A 100-proof Heaven Hill single barrel that showcases everything the Bottle in Bond designation promises — every pour from a different barrel is its own small adventure. This particular barrel opens with a slightly dusty warehouse nose before revealing cinnamon toast, brown sugar, buttered granola, crème brûlée, and a long, warm finish with very little pepper. (00:27:32)
  • Jim's House Blend "Old Hoot" (Blend 5A, Batch 2, Bottle 7, 100 Proof): A private label Kentucky straight bourbon blend developed by host Jim Shannon, bottled in a Stag Jr.-style bottle with a custom label. Nosing reveals sweet cherry, caramel, and a darker raisin-like fruit note. On the palate it delivers honey, caramel, and a surprisingly assertive peppery punch on the back end that drinks closer to 105–110 proof than its actual 100. The recipe is Jim's secret. (00:44:01)

Along the way, Jim and Mike recap their time at the Bardstown Bourbon Festival — bourbon mimosas at the civic breakfast, a seminar on maturation from Moonshine University, a tour of the Getz Museum, and a lunch meetup with the Bourbon Lens podcast and the Mash and Drum Whiskey Room YouTube channel. They also look ahead to a loaded October release calendar: the Buffalo Trace Antique Collection, Pappy Van Winkle, Little Book Chapter 3, the Fort Garr Foundation 10-Year, and a tantalizing tease of Woodford Reserve's upcoming Masters Collection release that Jim has already tasted straight from the rick house. Pull up a chair — this one feels like hanging out with old friends.

Full Transcript

Jim Beam Black Old Forester 1910 Henry McKenna Bottle in Bond Heaven Hill bourbon blend home blending infinity bottle Bardstown Bourbon Festival Buffalo Trace Antique Collection Pappy Van Winkle Little Book Chapter 3 Woodford Reserve Masters Collection Fort Garr Foundation Elijah Craig 18 year Elijah Craig 23 year Bourbon Road podcast Kentucky straight bourbon single barrel bourbon bottle in bond bourbon tasting