Skip to content
Episode 325 December 21, 2022 · 01:21:55
325. Five Bourbons for Every Shelf - Talking Whiskey with Tyler

325. Five Bourbons for Every Shelf - Talking Whiskey with Tyler

Producer Tyler Wilson brings 5 of his favorites — Buffalo Trace single barrel, Elijah Craig Toasted, Elijah Craig Barrel Proof C920 & more.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Tyler Wilson — show producer and media director for The Bourbon Road — steps out from behind the scenes and into the tasting chair for episode 325. Tyler brings five personally selected bottles that trace his bourbon journey from everyday comfort pours to high-proof showstoppers, giving hosts Jim Shannon and Brian Hyatt a window into the palate of the man who keeps the show running. Expect honest talk about hunting allocations, the allure of toasted barrel finishes, dusty bottles gone wrong, and why a Kroger trip can sometimes turn into the score of a lifetime.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Buffalo Trace Single Barrel Store Pick – Hometown Liquors, Henderson, KY: A Harlan Wheatley hand-selected single barrel bottled exclusively for Hometown Liquors in Henderson, Kentucky. Standard Buffalo Trace proof range. Tyler's gateway bourbon and sentimental favorite, this pick leans spicier than the standard release with prominent baking spice, cinnamon roll, and a solid oak backbone. (00:05:48)
  • Elijah Craig Toasted Barrel – 94 Proof: Heaven Hill's secondary-barrel-finished expression places the small-batch juice into a toasted oak barrel for a rich, dessert-forward result. Deep mahogany color, aromas of raisin, plum, and a subtly leathery edge, with flavors of brown sugar, toasted caramel, toffee, and a persistent nuttiness characteristic of Heaven Hill's distillate. (00:18:53)
  • Down Home Medium Toast Single Barrel – Liquor Barn Pick, 110.8 Proof (LB #4): Sourced from MGP in Lawrenceburg, Indiana and bottled by Whiskey Thief Distilling Company in Frankfort, Kentucky, this barrel-strength, medium-toast single barrel is a Liquor Barn exclusive. The nose offers spice-drop character; the palate is more back-loaded than expected at this proof, delivering spiced fruitcake, mature oak, and a warm lingering finish. (00:33:35)
  • Smoke Wagon Uncut Unfiltered – Batch 48, 113 Proof: Produced by Nevada H&C Distilling (Smoke Wagon) in Las Vegas using MGP high-rye bourbon distillate (approximately 38% rye mash bill). Batch 48 is among the earlier releases Tyler regards most highly. Relatively dry on the nose with ethanol lift, the palate delivers leather, tobacco, cigar-like depth, and a distinctive pop-rocks tingle from the elevated rye content. (00:48:32)
  • Elijah Craig Barrel Proof C920 – 132.8 Proof (September 2020): The third and final release of 2020 from Heaven Hill's flagship barrel-proof program, this approximately 12-year-old bourbon represents one of the last batches before proof levels began trending lower. Velvety and creamy on entry for its proof, with a nose of cherry cola and caramel, a rich mid-palate of almond extract and dark fruit, and a warming leather finish that builds gradually. (01:01:36)

Tyler Wilson rounds out the episode with candid reflections on chasing whales, the occasional disappointment of hyped releases, and why sharing a bottle with good friends will always be the point. Whether you're a daily Buffalo Trace sipper or a barrel-proof fanatic hunting C920s on your lunch break, this episode is a reminder that the best bourbon is the one in your glass right now.

Full Transcript

Buffalo Trace Elijah Craig Barrel Proof Elijah Craig Toasted Barrel Smoke Wagon Uncut Unfiltered Down Home Whiskey Heaven Hill MGP Whiskey Thief Distilling Liquor Barn single barrel barrel proof bourbon toasted barrel finish high rye bourbon Kentucky bourbon Tyler Wilson Jim Shannon Brian Hyatt bourbon collecting allocated bourbon The Bourbon Road podcast