Skip to content
Episode 325 December 21, 2022 · 01:21:55
325. Five Bourbons for Every Shelf - Talking Whiskey with Tyler

325. Five Bourbons for Every Shelf - Talking Whiskey with Tyler

Producer Tyler Wilson takes the mic and pours 5 of his favorites: Buffalo Trace single barrel, Elijah Craig Toasted, Smoke Wagon Uncut Batch 48, and the legendary C920 barrel proof.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Welcome back to The Bourbon Road! This week, hosts Jim Shannon and Brian Hyatt are joined by a very special guest — Tyler Wilson, the show's new producer and media director. Tyler steps out from behind the scenes to take a seat at the bar and share five of his personal favorite bottles, walking us through the pours that have shaped his bourbon journey. From a nostalgic daily sipper to a legendary barrel proof release, Tyler's selections paint a vivid picture of a passionate collector who loves the hunt just as much as the pour.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Buffalo Trace Single Barrel Store Pick (Hometown Liquors, Henderson, KY): Harlan Wheatley hand-selected single barrel bottled exclusively for Hometown Liquors in Henderson, Kentucky. A 90-proof expression that delivers warm baking spice, cinnamon roll, and a solid oak backbone. Tyler's cornerstone bourbon — the bottle that opened his eyes to sipping whiskey neat and kickstarted his collecting journey. (00:03:48)
  • Elijah Craig Toasted Barrel (Heaven Hill, 94 Proof): A 94-proof expression from Heaven Hill that takes the classic Elijah Craig small batch and finishes it in a toasted barrel for a noticeably richer, darker profile. Deep mahogany color with slow, thick legs. The nose and palate deliver brown sugar, toffee, dark caramel, and a hint of dried fruit — plum and raisin rather than fresh cherry. The characteristic Heaven Hill nuttiness rounds out a dessert-forward finish. Best sought around Elijah Craig Barrel Proof release windows, typically three to four times per year. (00:18:54)
  • Down Home Small Batch Toasted Barrel, Liquor Barn Pick, Batch LB4 (Whiskey Thief Distilling / MGP, 110.8 Proof): A 110.8-proof single barrel store pick for Liquor Barn, bottled by Whiskey Thief Distilling Company out of Frankfort, Kentucky using MGP distillate sourced from Lawrenceburg, Indiana. Medium-toast finish. Less sweetness up front than expected from a toasted barrel, with the flavor profile revealing itself more on the back of the palate — spice drop on the nose, spiced fruitcake depth, and a warm lingering finish that feels very much at home in the winter months. (00:34:20)
  • Smoke Wagon Uncut Unfiltered Batch 48 (Nevada H&C Distilling / MGP, 113 Proof): Batch 48 of the fan-favorite uncut, unfiltered expression from Las Vegas-based Smoke Wagon, bottled at 113 proof using MGP high-rye bourbon distillate (approximately 38% rye mash bill). Drier and less sweet than the toasted barrel expressions preceding it, with spiced leather, tobacco, and cigar on both nose and palate. A lively, almost pop-rocks-like tingle on the mid-palate gives way to a warm, lingering finish. Tyler notes that earlier batches in the 20s–40s range impressed him most, and that this remains a reliable crowd-pleaser for sharing with friends. (00:48:31)
  • Elijah Craig Barrel Proof C920 (Heaven Hill, 132.8 Proof): The September 2020 third release of Elijah Craig Barrel Proof, bottled at 132.8 proof — widely recognized as one of the last batches before proof levels began trending downward into the 120s and 110s. Gorgeous deep caramel color. The nose opens with cherry cola and rich sweetness. On the palate it is strikingly velvety and creamy for its proof, with almond extract, dark cherry, and a wave of warmth that builds gradually toward the finish rather than arriving all at once. A leather note emerges on the back end. Tyler purchased this at MSRP ($59.99) and considers it among the finest value pours in his collection. (01:01:47)

Tyler Wilson brings warmth, curiosity, and a well-stocked shelf to his first full on-air appearance, and it shows in every pour. Whether you are just starting your bourbon journey or are deep in the hunt for whales, this episode is a reminder that the best bottles are the ones you share with good company. Cheers, and we will see you down the Bourbon Road.

Full Transcript

Buffalo Trace single barrel Elijah Craig toasted barrel Elijah Craig barrel proof C920 Smoke Wagon uncut unfiltered Down Home whiskey Heaven Hill MGP Whiskey Thief Distilling Tyler Wilson bourbon collecting barrel proof bourbon toasted barrel finish high rye bourbon Kentucky bourbon store pick bourbon bourbon podcast Hometown Liquors Henderson Liquor Barn pick bourbon tasting

The Conversation