Skip to content
Episode 396 June 5, 2024 · 01:12:13
396. Old Bourbon is the Name of This Game

396. Old Bourbon is the Name of This Game

Todd Ritter brings four "old" whiskeys to the Bourbon Road Bar: a 1970s dusty Old Lewis Hunter, Old McBrayer Bottled-in-Bond, the "Old Ritter" Yellowstone barrel pick, and Old Overholt 10 Year Cask Strength.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Welcome back to the Bourbon Road, where host Jim Shannon and returning guest Todd Ritter settle into the Bourbon Road Bar for a deep dive into whiskeys that share one thing in common: the word "Old" in their name. What starts as a simple thematic premise quickly becomes a rich journey through bourbon history, dusty hunting, and some genuinely surprising pours. Rob Carter was supposed to join the fun but had to bow out at the last minute — though his impressive 20-bottle lineup of "old" whiskeys was not forgotten.

Todd Ritter, a fixture in the Frankfurt Bourbon Society and a well-known figure across the whiskey YouTube community, curated four pours that span the full spectrum of what "old" can mean: a true dusty from a long-shuttered Kentucky distillery, a heritage brand revival done right, a barrel-pick tribute with a personal backstory, and a high-rye, high-proof aged rye that closes things out in style. Along the way, Jim and Todd rattle off dozens of whiskeys carrying the "old" banner — from bottom-shelf staples like Old Crow and Old Charter to unicorns like OFC and Old Rip Van Winkle — making this one of the most encyclopedic episodes the show has produced on a single theme.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Old Lewis Hunter 6 Year (86 Proof, Export/Italy Label, ~1974–1977 bottling): A genuine dusty from the Old Lewis Hunter Distillery in Lair, Harrison County, Kentucky — established 1861, eventually acquired by the Whiskey Trust and later Seagrams, closed 1974. This bottle carries an Italian import label and a mysterious "40 YARS" sticker over the age statement (Todd is offering a pour to anyone who can identify what YARS means). Despite a classically oxidized dusty nose, the palate delivers a beautiful cherry-plum cake with butterscotch drizzle — a remarkable survivor. (00:04:29)
  • Old McBrayer Bottled-in-Bond (100 Proof, 4 Years, 70% Yellow Corn / 18% Rye / 12% Malted Barley): A revival of a Lawrenceburg, Kentucky brand originally founded by Judge William H. McBrayer in 1847 — a name so storied that E.H. Taylor's signature reportedly appears on the original recipe. Produced at Wilderness Trail starting in 2016 and released by McBrayer Legacy Spirits, this bonded expression pours with a soft, sweet nose carrying rye spice and a hint of honey from the malted barley. The palate brings sweet candy, butterscotch, and a finish that blends red hot cinnamon candy with root beer. Available through McBrayerlegacyspirits.com and on secondary markets for approximately $60–$65. (00:19:53)
  • Old Ritter — Yellowstone Single Barrel Pick (115 Proof), by Limestone Branch / McBrayer Legacy Spirits: A Yellowstone single barrel pick chosen unanimously by Todd Ritter, Jason Chloe, the Mash and Journey crew, and Limestone Branch ambassador Stephen Fonte — reportedly sourced from Heaven Hill. The back label carries a custom sticker with Todd's face, earning it the "Old Ritter" name. Nutty on the nose with a peanut brittle quality, it opens up on the palate with big flavor, a touch of dark cherry, oak, and a long, lingering finish reminiscent of aged dusty bourbons from the 1980s and '90s. (00:52:26)
  • Old Overholt 10 Year Cask Strength Rye (approx. 121 Proof, 80% Rye / 20% Malted Barley): America's longest continuously running whiskey brand, originally distilled in Pennsylvania since 1810 and now produced by Jim Beam. This 10-year cask-strength expression is a significant step up from the standard Overholt lineup, retailing around $99. The nose is immediately distinctive — fruity, almost bubblegum-forward with hints of big red and juicy fruit. The palate delivers rye spice, a green herbal leaf quality, and a long, complex finish that keeps revealing itself sip after sip. (00:56:23)

Todd Ritter and Jim Shannon close the episode with a wide-ranging conversation covering dusty bottle hunting, the legal framework for selling sealed bottles in Kentucky, the revival of Pennsylvania-style high-rye whiskeys, the Limestone Branch experience, and a comprehensive rundown of nearly every whiskey brand with the word "old" in its name. Whether you are a bottom-shelf daily drinker or a trophy-bottle collector, this episode has something for every fan of the Bourbon Road.

Full Transcript

Old Lewis Hunter Old McBrayer Yellowstone single barrel Old Overholt dusty bourbon Todd Ritter Limestone Branch McBrayer Legacy Spirits bottled in bond cask strength rye Pennsylvania rye Heaven Hill Jim Beam Whiskey Trust bourbon history barrel pick high rye bourbon heritage bourbon brands Frankfurt Bourbon Society Stephen Fonte

The Conversation