Skip to content
Episode 396 June 5, 2024 · 01:12:13
396. Old Bourbon is the Name of This Game

396. Old Bourbon is the Name of This Game

Todd Ritter brings a dusty Old Lewis Hunter, Old McBrayer BIB, a "Old Ritter" Yellowstone barrel pick, and Old Overholt 10-Year Cask Strength to the Bourbon Road Bar.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Welcome back to The Bourbon Road, where host Jim Shannon and frequent guest Todd Ritter settle into the Bourbon Road Bar for a deep dive into one of whiskey's most storied descriptors: the word old. From a genuine dusty bottled decades ago to a lovingly named single-barrel pick, Todd curates four pours that span the full spectrum of what old can mean in American whiskey — heritage, craftsmanship, provenance, and even a little personal legend. Rob Carter was originally slated to join the fun but had to bow out last minute, though his impressive lineup photo (complete with an Old Rip Van Winkle) made a cameo in spirit.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Old Lewis Hunter 6-Year Bourbon (86 proof, export bottling, est. 1970s): A genuine dusty sourced from an Italian export market, this bottle hails from a Harrison County, Kentucky distillery founded in 1861 and shuttered by 1974. Bright and clear in the glass despite its age, it opens with a classic dusty nose before revealing a surprisingly vibrant palate of cherry, plum, and butterscotch drizzle — a remarkable survivor of four-plus decades in the bottle. (00:04:29)
  • Old McBrayer Bottled-in-Bond Bourbon (100 proof, 4 years, 70% yellow corn / 18% rye / 12% malted barley, Wilderness Trail / Bardstown Bourbon Co.): A revival of the legendary Judge William H. McBrayer brand first established in Lawrenceburg, Kentucky in 1847, this 2023 release was crafted in partnership with McBrayer Legacy Spirits. Soft and sweet on the nose with a honeyed malted-barley note, it delivers butterscotch, red-hot candy, and a hint of root beer on the finish — impressive complexity for a four-year bonded expression retailing around $60–$65. (00:19:54)
  • Old Ritter — Yellowstone Single Barrel Pick (115 proof, Limestone Branch Distillery): A Yellowstone single-barrel selection chosen unanimously by Todd Ritter, Jason Chloe, and fellow pickers during a session hosted by the legendary Stephen Fonte at Limestone Branch in Lebanon, Kentucky. Bearing a custom "Old Ritter" back label, this barrel-strength pick leans into peanut brittle, a touch of mint, and a cherry-laced finish reminiscent of well-aged Heaven Hill distillate — a pour Todd is saving bottles of for his children. (00:41:38)
  • Old Overholt 10-Year Cask Strength Rye (approx. 121 proof, 80% rye / 20% malted barley, Jim Beam): The longest continuously branded whiskey in American history steps into rarefied territory with this cask-strength, decade-aged expression. The nose bursts with fruit-forward juicy-gum notes and spice, while the palate delivers a bold rye punch layered with green herbal and mint-leaf character, lingering warmth, and genuine complexity — a standout that retails around $99 and may still be found in select markets. (00:56:23)

From dusty Italian exports to hand-labeled single barrels, this episode is a testament to how much history, heart, and flavor hide behind a single three-letter word. Todd and Jim also rattle off dozens of whiskey brands carrying the old name — from bottom-shelf workhorses like Old Crow and Old Charter to unicorns like OFC and Old Rip Van Winkle — making this one of the most encyclopedic bourbon conversations The Bourbon Road has offered in recent memory. Pour yourself something old, and enjoy the ride.

Full Transcript

Old Lewis Hunter Old McBrayer Yellowstone single barrel Old Overholt 10 Year dusty bourbon bottled in bond cask strength rye Limestone Branch Distillery McBrayer Legacy Spirits Todd Ritter Jim Shannon The Bourbon Road Stephen Fonte rye whiskey American whiskey history Whiskey Trust Old Fitzgerald Old Rip Van Winkle barrel pick Pennsylvania rye