Skip to content
Episode 448 June 11, 2025 · 59:04
448. High Proof and Higher Spirits: Four Whiskeys, One Wild Ride

448. High Proof and Higher Spirits: Four Whiskeys, One Wild Ride

Jim & Todd taste four whiskeys back-to-back: Pursuit United's Melwood BIB & Derby Town bourbon, 15 Stars Reserve Rye, and a jaw-dropping 156-proof Laws Whiskey House single barrel.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Todd Ritter settle into the Bourbon Road Bar in Simpsonville, Kentucky for a laid-back four-whiskey tasting session that spans the full proof spectrum — from a crisp bottled-in-bond pint all the way up to a barrel-proof rye that pushes the boundaries of what whiskey can be. Two bourbons anchor the first half, two ryes close things out, and the evening wraps with one of the highest-proof whiskeys ever featured on the show.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Pursuit United Melwood Bottled-in-Bond Bourbon (100 proof, 4 year, Kentucky): A 375 ml tribute to the historic Melwood Distillery that once stood near Pursuit United's current Louisville home. The nose opens with green apple, bubble gum, and a delicate floral lift — almost brandy-like at first impression. On the palate it's sweet and well-balanced, delivering apple pie, caramel, and vanilla buttercream, with a gentle spice on the back end and a warm, lingering finish. A quality bottle-and-bond available at the Pursuit United gift shop for $29.99. (00:04:05)
  • Pursuit United Derby Town 7-Year Barrel Proof Kentucky Bourbon (122.8 proof): A revival of the Derby Town brand once owned by General Distillers Corp., the successor to Melwood Distilling post-Prohibition, released in a 375 ml pint for $49.99. The nose carries dark fruit cake, molasses, and warm spice, while the palate opens with a buttery, oily wash that gives way to rich oak, caramel, and a silky, long-lasting finish. Textured and deeply satisfying at cask strength. (00:15:19)
  • 15 Stars Reserve Fine Aged Rye (95 proof, blend of 14-, 13-, 9-, and 8-year Kentucky, Tennessee, and Indiana ryes): Sourced by Rick and Ricky Johnson, this reserve blend carries the complexity of mature rye with a nose of lemon bar, fresh mint, chocolate, and bubble gum. The palate delivers honey, peachy apricot, and a gentle candy sweetness, finishing with mint, oak, and a hint of leather. Bottled at 95 proof with a viscous mouthfeel. MSRP $139.99. (00:29:13)
  • Laws Whiskey House San Luis Valley Rye Whiskey — Barrel 425X (156 proof, single barrel, Colorado): An extraordinary outlier barrel from Laws Whiskey House in Denver, shared by founder Alan Laws during Jim's visit to the distillery. The nose is surprisingly approachable — round, sweet rye with candy notes and a hint of rye toast. The palate opens with a buttery wash before pivoting to dark chocolate, clove, roasty smoke, burnt orange, toasted marshmallow, and a faint medicinal iodine note. Allocated to a Colorado retail store; release details to follow. (00:41:08)

Whether you're chasing an affordable bottled-in-bond find, a high-proof barrel pick, or the most extreme rye you'll ever encounter, this episode delivers something for every whiskey lover. Jim and Todd also share news on Old Forester's upcoming President's Choice Rye, Wyoming Whiskey's Buffalo Bill Cody bourbon, Lost Lantern's estate distillery summer collection, and a wealth of upcoming episodes featuring Rabbit Hole, Leierkin Bourbon Company, RD1, and the Pursuit United team.

Full Transcript

Tasting Bottled in Bond Distillery Visit Bourbon Rye Cask Strength Bottled in Bond Single Barrel Kentucky Tennessee Indiana Colorado Melwood Distillery General Distillers Melwood Distilling Old Forester Rabbit Hole Lost Lantern Pursuit United Melwood bourbon Derby Town bourbon 15 Stars Reserve Rye Laws Whiskey House San Luis Valley rye bottled in bond bourbon barrel proof bourbon high proof rye whiskey Kentucky bourbon Colorado whiskey Kenny Coleman Ryan Cecil Rick Johnson Ricky Johnson Alan Laws single barrel rye bourbon tasting craft whiskey Bourbon Road podcast