Skip to content
Episode 402 July 17, 2024 · 01:06:03
402. A Review of Five New Whiskeys

402. A Review of Five New Whiskeys

Jim & Todd taste High & Wicked Bourbon & Rye, Old Forester 1924, Hardin's Creek Golden Origins corn whiskey, and Green River Full Proof.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Todd Ritter are back behind the mics for a tasting-focused episode, working through five whiskeys that have been quietly accumulating on the shelf. From a transparency-forward Kentucky NDP label to a storied Brown-Forman release and a value-priced full-proof from Western Kentucky, this one is built for anyone who loves discovering bottles they may have overlooked.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • High & Wicked Kentucky Straight Bourbon Small Batch: A bold and distinctive high-rye bourbon distilled in Kentucky, aged five years in new white oak with a medium toast and number four char. The mash bill is 51% corn, 39% rye, and 10% malted barley, bottled at 104 proof (52% ABV) and non-chill filtered. The nose opens with dark cherry, rich caramel, and layered fruit, leading to a palate that delivers immediate sweetness from the wood sugars before giving way to deep barrel spice, oak, and a long, warming finish. Distillery source is not disclosed on the label. MSRP approximately $82. (00:03:46)
  • High & Wicked Kentucky Straight Rye: Distilled by New Riff Distilling in Newport, Kentucky, this five-year-old straight rye carries a mash bill of 91% rye and 9% malted barley, bottled at 98.2 proof (49.1% ABV) and non-chill filtered. The nose offers rye cracker, fresh spearmint, and light cereal grain. On the palate it is clean and cooling, with dry grain character, a light sweetness that builds toward the back, and notes of green apple and anise that emerge with time in the glass. MSRP approximately $82. (00:16:53)
  • Old Forester 1924 10 Year Old Kentucky Straight Bourbon: Aged a full decade and bottled at 100 proof (50% ABV), the 1924 is inspired by the era when Brown-Forman continued distilling for medicinal purposes during Prohibition and acquired barrels from closing distilleries. The nose presents brownie, dark caramel, and a signature banana note characteristic of Old Forester's yeast. The palate is silky and velvety, with an exotic spice profile featuring cardamom, cinnamon, and allspice alongside almond extract and praline sweetness. Oak is present but restrained for the age. MSRP approximately $120. (00:31:34)
  • Hardin's Creek Golden Origins 11 Year Old Corn Whiskey: Part of Jim Beam's Hardin's Creek series, this 11-year-old corn whiskey is aged in used barrels and bottled at 106 proof (53% ABV). The color is noticeably lighter than a comparable bourbon, and the nose is delicate — sweet corn, caramel, and a grilled-corn character that concentrates beautifully under a covered glass. The palate is creamy and sweet with corn pudding richness, very low oak influence despite the age, and an approachable, dessert-like finish that hints at where further aging could take this style. (00:38:07)
  • Green River Full Proof Kentucky Straight Bourbon: Drawn from the same 70% corn, 21% rye, 9% malted barley mash bill as Green River's standard and bottled-in-bond expressions, this full-proof release comes in at 117.3 proof (58.65% ABV). The nose is classically Kentuckian with caramel, dark cherry, and a dusting of cayenne pepper. The palate opens with an immediate and pronounced oiliness, delivering intense caramel, ripe dark fruit, and a spice-forward finish with excellent texture and weight. No age statement. MSRP approximately $45. (00:46:39)

Five bottles, five different stories — and proof that the most interesting pours on the shelf are not always the loudest names in the room. Whether you chase high-rye bourbons, age-stated releases, or full-proof bargains, this episode has a lead worth following.

Full Transcript

High and Wicked bourbon High and Wicked rye Old Forester 1924 Hardin's Creek Golden Origins Green River Full Proof New Riff Distilling Jim Beam Brown-Forman Kentucky straight bourbon corn whiskey high rye bourbon full proof bourbon NDP whiskey Kentucky bourbon bourbon tasting bourbon reviews Bardstown Bourbon Company Green River Distillery barrel proof bourbon whiskey podcast

The Conversation