Skip to content
Episode 402 July 17, 2024 · 01:06:03
402. A Review of Five New Whiskeys

402. A Review of Five New Whiskeys

Jim & Todd crack five bottles: High & Wicked bourbon & rye, Old Forester 1924, Hardin's Creek Golden Origins corn whiskey, and Green River Full Proof.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Todd Ritter settle in with five whiskeys that have been accumulating on the shelf, each one worth a conversation on its own. The lineup spans high-rye Kentucky bourbon, a straight rye from Newport, a decade-old Old Forester release, an 11-year corn whiskey from Hardin's Creek, and a full-proof offering from Green River Distilling Co. — covering ground from well-known distillery names to a newer NDP label worth seeking out.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • High & Wicked Small Batch High Rye Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey: 104 proof (52% ABV), 5 years old, 51% corn / 39% rye / 10% malted barley, distilled in Kentucky, bottled by High & Wicked in Harrodsburg, KY. Non-chill filtered, aged in new white oak with medium toast and #4 char. Jim and Todd find dark cherry, caramel, and a rich sweetness on the nose that gives way to a layered spice and oak-forward palate that punches well above its stated age. MSRP ~$82. (00:03:46)
  • High & Wicked Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey: 98.2 proof (49.1% ABV), 5 years old, 91% rye / 9% malted barley, distilled by New Riff Distilling in Newport, KY, bottled by High & Wicked in Harrodsburg, KY. Non-chill filtered. The nose leads with rye cracker, spearmint, and a light grain character. The palate is clean and cooling with mild sweetness, light fruit, and a touch of anise that opens up with time in the glass. MSRP ~$82. (00:17:01)
  • Old Forester 1924 10-Year-Old Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey: 100 proof (50% ABV), 10 years old, distilled and bottled by Old Forester / Brown-Forman, Louisville, KY. Inspired by the distillery's history of operating through Prohibition, the 1924 delivers a nose of dark brownie, banana, and caramel that transitions to a silky, velvety palate studded with cardamom, allspice, almond, and praline — a distinctive and memorable spice character that sets it apart in the Old Forester lineup. MSRP ~$119.99. (00:31:46)
  • Hardin's Creek Golden Origins 11-Year-Old Kentucky Straight Corn Whiskey: 106 proof (53% ABV), 11 years old, sourced from Jim Beam's Hardin's Creek program, aged in used oak barrels. The lighter amber color signals the used-barrel aging. The nose offers sweet grilled corn and caramel, and the palate is creamy, sweet, and richly corn-forward — a corn pudding profile that Jim and Todd suggest will only grow more complex with additional years in wood. Part of a limited Barrel & Box set. (01:00:14)
  • Green River Full Proof Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey: 117.3 proof (58.65% ABV), no age statement (assumed minimum 4 years), 70% corn / 21% rye / 9% malted barley, distilled and bottled by Green River Distilling Co., Owensboro, KY. Returned to barrel-entry proof. A warm, spice-forward nose with pepper and cayenne leads into an intensely oily, caramel-and-dark-cherry palate with remarkable texture for the price. MSRP ~$45. (01:00:14)

Five bottles, five distinct personalities — from an NDP label that overdelivers on transparency and flavor to a decades-old Kentucky institution offering its most powerful expression yet. Jim and Todd close out with a listener challenge: be the first to post a bourbon with a 51% corn mash bill in the Bourbon Roadies Facebook group for a chance to win merch and sample pours. The Kentucky Bourbon Festival in Bardstown (September 13–15) and Bourbon on the Banks in Frankfort (first Saturday in October) are both on the calendar — come find the crew.

Full Transcript

Tasting Bourbon Rye Cask Strength Small Batch Kentucky Green River Distilling New Riff Distilling Brown-Forman Jim Beam Old Forester Green River New Riff High and Wicked High and Wicked bourbon High and Wicked rye New Riff Distilling Old Forester 1924 Old Forester ten year Green River Distilling Green River full proof Hardin's Creek Hardin's Creek Golden Origins corn whiskey high rye bourbon Kentucky straight bourbon Jim Beam Brown-Forman barrel proof bourbon NDP bourbon Kentucky bourbon festival Bardstown Kentucky bourbon reviews