Skip to content
Episode 462 September 24, 2025 · 57:26
462. Smoked Bourbon, White Wine Rye, and a Trip Abroad

462. Smoked Bourbon, White Wine Rye, and a Trip Abroad

Oak Lore NC rye, Sagamore's 4-year Albariño finish, and Holiday's hickory-smoked Ancient Cave bourbon hit the mat with Amzie Winning.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon is back from his European adventure — Belgian beer, French wine, German lagers, and a near-miss at La Maison du Whisky in Paris — and he's brought his appetite for bourbon with him. Joining Jim and co-host Todd Ritter is returning friend of the show Amzie Winning, and together the trio dives into a pair of themed lineups that span craft distilling, sourced whiskey, and some genuinely experimental finishing work.

The first half shines a light on Oak Lore Distilling Company out of Matthews, North Carolina, founded by neighbors Matt Simpkins and Tom Bogan. Their philosophy centers on community and the stories shared over a good drink — and the name itself is a tribute to the oak barrel staves that transform raw distillate into something worth talking about. Three of their expressions make it to the mat, giving listeners a well-rounded introduction to a brand that sources from both North Carolina and Kentucky.

The second half gets experimental with two exclusive pours. Sagamore Spirit out of Baltimore, Maryland brings a rye finished for four full years in Albariño barrels from nearby Bordy Vineyard — a white wine grape native to Galicia, Spain, that imparts something genuinely unlike anything the hosts have tasted before. Rounding out the night is a small-format release from Holiday Distilling in Weston, Missouri: a straight bourbon from their Ancient Cave Collection, finished in hickory-smoked American oak char barrels after seven-plus years of aging.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Oak Lore Four-Grain Bourbon Whiskey: A flagship spirit blending wheat, rye, corn, and malted barley, aged four to six years and bottled at 92 proof. Retails around $69.99. The nose opens with sweet cream and a warm oak undercurrent, leading to a savory, spice-forward palate with notes of allspice, light clove, and a subtle tea quality. The mash bill's complexity is present but well-integrated — more spice cabinet than fruit bowl. (00:07:03)
  • Oak Lore North Carolina Straight Rye Whiskey: A small-batch, grain-to-glass rye aged six-plus years, bottled at 92 proof for $69.99. A slightly piney, citrus-touched nose gives way to a palate that surprises — dark berry jam, biscuit, cereal grain, and a long finish that evolves through black tea and chocolate-covered espresso bean. Every sip reveals something a little different. (00:15:42)
  • Oak Lore Port Cask Finish Rye Whiskey (Story Series): Part of Oak Lore's limited Story Series, this rye is aged several years and then finished twelve to eighteen months in freshly dumped port wine barrels, bottled at 92 proof. The nose blooms with bright red fruit and grape skin. On the palate, raspberry, tawny toffee, caramel, and a pleasant grape-seed astringency frame a rye base that holds its own throughout the finish. (00:23:57)
  • Sagamore Spirit Albariño Cask Finish Rye Whiskey: Aged four years in new charred oak and then finished for an additional four years in Albariño wine barrels sourced from Bordy Vineyard in Maryland, bottled at 103 proof and retailing for $79. The nose is floral, perfumy, and fresh — wildflowers, a hint of mint, and a grappa-like grape must quality. The palate delivers wildflower honey, lavender, vanilla, allspice, anise, and a drying oak tannic quality on the back of the tongue. Finish lingers beautifully. (00:41:58)
  • Holiday Distilling Ancient Cave Collection Hickory Smoked Bourbon: A straight bourbon from Weston, Missouri, aged seven years and five months and finished in hickory-smoked, lightly charred American oak barrels. Bottled at 100 proof; available in 375ml format for $45 at the distillery. The nose is immediately reminiscent of smoked apple butter — warm baking spice, cinnamon, and gently grilled apple. The palate is rich and sweet with concentrated fruit and a whisper of campfire smoke that never overwhelms. (00:41:58)

From a North Carolina startup earning its stripes with sourced and blended whiskeys to a rye that spent as long in a white wine barrel as it did in new oak, this is an episode built around curiosity — about barrels, about origins, and about what happens when two neighbors decide to build something worth sharing. Grab a pour and settle in.

Full Transcript

Oak Lore Distilling Sagamore Spirit Holiday Distilling bourbon podcast North Carolina bourbon Maryland rye whiskey Albariño cask finish hickory smoked bourbon port cask finish rye four grain bourbon craft bourbon sourced whiskey Amzie Winning Bourbon on the Banks Frankfurt Kentucky MGP rye Ancient Cave Collection wine barrel finish small batch rye whiskey tasting

The Conversation