Skip to content
Episode 433 February 26, 2025 · 01:26:14
433. The Four Maltmigos Ride Again

433. The Four Maltmigos Ride Again

The Malt Migos — Jim, Todd, Amzie Winning & Super Rob — taste Town Branch, Old Pepper, Lost Lantern (St. George), and New Riff Single Malts to celebrate the new American Single Malt category.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

The Malt Migos are back together in the Bourbon Road Bar, and this time the subject is America's newest officially recognized whiskey category: American Single Malt. Jim Shannon and Todd Ritter are joined by Frankfurt Bourbon Society President Amzie Winning and Super Rob Carter for a four-bottle deep dive into this freshly codified spirit. With the TTB's rules taking effect on January 17th, the guys break down exactly what qualifies as an American Single Malt — 100% malted barley, distilled at a single U.S. distillery, aged in oak barrels up to 700 liters — and explore why this category could be a genuine global contender.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Town Branch Kentucky Single Malt: A 7-year-old, 87-proof whiskey from Lexington Distilling Company in Lexington, Kentucky. Bottled as a small batch, handmade expression, it pours an exceptionally pale straw color suggesting used-barrel aging. The nose delivers soft orchard fruits — peach, pear, and juicy fruit gum — with a clean, fresh character reminiscent of an unpeated Irish single malt. The palate follows suit with sweet stone fruit, a hint of green tea, and a gentle mid-palate warmth. Easy-drinking and approachable, with a retail of around $50 (found on sale for $35). (00:45:58)
  • Old Pepper Malt Whiskey: A 100-proof, 3-plus-year-old American Single Malt from Old Pepper Distillery in Lexington, Kentucky, made from 100% malted barley and aged in new charred oak. The nose opens with baked bread, a walk-in-humidor quality, and caramel sweetness, with a subtle underlying peat note that becomes clearer with time. The palate is rich and mouth-coating with dark stewed fruits, molasses, and a faint spice on the finish. Non-chill filtered character is evident in its heavier, oilier texture. Gift-shop pricing around $45. (01:01:34)
  • Lost Lantern Mountain Meadow (St. George Distillery): A 4-year-old, 107-proof American Single Malt sourced by Lost Lantern from St. George Distillery in Alameda, California — a four-barrel blend bottled as approximately 600 bottles. The color is startlingly pale, almost lighter than apple juice. The nose is arrestingly wine-like: Meyer lemon, white grape, floral notes, and what the group describes as dank Simcoe hops or a Heineken-like quality. The palate is smooth and citrus-forward with hoppy and mildly funky complexity that defies easy categorization as a whiskey on the nose alone. Retails around $150. (01:07:24)
  • New Riff Sour Mash Single Malt: A cast-strength, non-chill-filtered American Single Malt from New Riff Distillery in Newport, Kentucky. Stated at 7 years with reports of barrels up to 9 years, bottled at 113.8 proof. The mashbill incorporates five malted barleys including Maris Otter, Golden Promise, a barley wine-style malt, a Belgian quadruple-style malt, and approximately 10% Scottish peated malt. Aging utilized a complex array of cask types including red wine barrels (French and American oak), Portuguese brandy casks, and freshly dumped Oloroso Sherry casks, some of which were de-charred and re-toasted or re-charred. The deep amber pour delivers a nose of sweet feed molasses, dark cherry, green banana, vanilla birthday cake, and honey almond that evolves with each return. The palate is rich, dark, and tobacco-forward with leather, nutty sherry notes, and a long finish. Retails around $70. (01:27:46)

Bonus Pour — Single Cask Nation / Westland Distillery Sauternes Cask: A 9-year-old American Single Malt (distilled September 2014, bottled March 2024) from Westland Distillery in Seattle, Washington, selected and bottled by Single Cask Nation. Bottled at 104.6 proof (52.3% ABV), non-chill filtered with no color added, aged in a first-fill Sauternes cask. The Sauternes influence — a French white dessert wine known for noble rot fermentation — is immediately apparent on the nose: butterscotch and Werther's on the first pass, followed by a sweet-and-funky, almost ice-wine quality on subsequent nosings. A fascinating and layered bonus pour enjoyed outside the formal ranking. (01:52:30)

Whether you're a bourbon devotee looking for your next rabbit hole or a Scotch drinker curious what American distillers are doing with malt, this episode makes a compelling case that American Single Malt is a category worth watching — and drinking. The Malt Migos promise to reconvene at the Rare Eagle Bar for their next session, so stay tuned.

Full Transcript

American Single Malt Town Branch Kentucky Single Malt Old Pepper Distillery Lost Lantern Whiskey St. George Spirits New Riff Distilling New Riff Single Malt Single Cask Nation Westland Distillery Sauternes cask whiskey malted barley whiskey TTB American Single Malt rules Lexington Kentucky distilleries craft whiskey bourbon alternatives Frankfurt Bourbon Society Bourbon Road podcast peated American whiskey single malt tasting whiskey cask finishing

The Conversation