Skip to content
Episode 433 February 26, 2025 · 01:26:14
433. The Four Maltmigos Ride Again

433. The Four Maltmigos Ride Again

Amzie Winning & Super Rob Carter join Jim & Todd to taste Town Branch, Old Pepper, Lost Lantern (St. George), and New Riff American Single Malts — plus a Westland Sauternes bonus pour.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

The Malt Migos are back in the Bourbon Road bar, and this time Jim Shannon and Todd Ritter are joined by Amzie Winning (Frankfurt Bourbon Society President and Bourbon on the Banks board member) and Super Rob Carter for a deep dive into one of the most exciting new official categories in American whiskey: American Single Malt. With the category formally codified into law on January 17th, the guys celebrate by tasting four very different expressions — ranging from a light, fruit-forward Kentucky sipper to a complex, multi-malt, multi-barrel beast from Northern Kentucky — and capping the night with a stunning bonus pour aged in Sauternes casks. Along the way, the group breaks down the TTB regulations that define the category, debates barrel entry proofs, explores what makes malted barley so expensive, and wonders whether Kentucky distilleries will ever fully win over their bourbon-loving home crowd.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Town Branch Kentucky Single Malt: A 87-proof, seven-year-old single malt from the Town Branch Distillery (Lexington Distilling Company) in Lexington, Kentucky. Aged in used barrels, this expression pours a pale straw color reminiscent of an Irish whiskey or Japanese single malt. The nose delivers light orchard fruits — peach, pear, and juicy fruit gum — while the palate stays soft, sweet, and approachable with stone fruit and a gentle mid-palate warmth. A great entry point for whiskey newcomers. (00:05:15)
  • Old Pepper Malt Whiskey: A 100-proof American single malt from Old Pepper Distillery in Lexington, Kentucky, made from 100% malted barley and aged over three years in new charred oak. The nose opens with baked bread, humidor-like tobacco, and a subtle earthiness, with caramel and vanilla emerging on closer inspection. The palate is rich with stewed dark fruits, molasses, and a light peat influence that adds complexity without dominating. A full-coating, satisfying pour that punches well above its modest price. (00:21:30)
  • Lost Lantern Mountain Meadow (St. George Spirits): A 107-proof, four-year-old American single malt sourced by Lost Lantern from St. George Spirits in Alameda, California — a four-barrel batch bottled in an edition of roughly 600. The color is strikingly light, yet the nose is wildly complex: Meyer lemon, floral notes, citrusy dank hops, juicy fruit, and an almost wine-like quality that prompts comparisons to a late-harvest Riesling or ice wine. The palate follows suit with bright citrus, herbal notes, and a lingering finish. A genuinely surprising and singular whiskey. (00:34:55)
  • New Riff Sour Mash Single Malt: A cask-strength, non-chill-filtered American single malt from New Riff Distilling in Newport, Kentucky, bottled at 113.8 proof. The mash incorporates five distinct malts — including Maris Otter, Golden Promise, a barley wine-style malt, a Belgian quadruple-style malt, and Scottish peated malted barley (approximately 10% of the blend). Matured in a combination of new charred oak, de-charred and re-toasted barrels, red wine casks, Portuguese brandy casks, and freshly dumped Oloroso Sherry casks. The nose shifts constantly — green banana, birthday cake vanilla, honey, almond, and sweet feed molasses. The palate is dark, rich, and warming with leather, dried fruit, tobacco, and a long finish. A cigar-worthy nightcap. (00:48:20)
  • Single Cask Nation — Westland Distillery Single Malt (Sauternes Cask, Bonus Pour): A 104.6-proof (52.3% ABV), nine-year-old American single malt distilled at Westland Distillery in Seattle, Washington in September 2014 and bottled by Single Cask Nation in March 2024. Aged in a first-fill Sauternes cask, non-chill filtered with no added color. The nose opens with a wave of butterscotch and Werther's candy before giving way to a sweet-sour, funky, wine-forward character recalling noble rot fermentation. The palate is layered and long, with a finish that lingers well. Brought by Amzie Winning as the night's unranked bonus pour. (01:01:00)

Whether you're a lifelong Scotch devotee, a dedicated bourbon fan, or just someone who loves discovering what American distillers can do when handed a new canvas, this episode makes a compelling case that American Single Malt is a category worth exploring. Seek out your regional distilleries, check the clearance shelf at your local retailer, and don't be afraid to take a flyer on something that looks more like a glass of wine than a whiskey — you might just be surprised. Cheers, roadies, and we'll see you down the Bourbon Road.

Full Transcript

American single malt Town Branch Kentucky single malt Old Pepper Distillery New Riff single malt Lost Lantern whiskey St. George Spirits Westland Distillery Single Cask Nation Maris Otter malt Golden Promise malt Sauternes cask whiskey Frankfurt Bourbon Society peated malt whiskey Kentucky craft distillery TTB whiskey regulations cask strength whiskey non-chill filtered whiskey Amzie Winning bourbon podcast single malt whiskey tasting