Skip to content
Episode 461 September 17, 2025 · 01:11:24
461. Hunting for Laughs with the Bourbon Hunters

461. Hunting for Laughs with the Bourbon Hunters

Todd goes solo with Dude Poole & JD Fritches of Bourbon Hunters, tasting an Old Forester single barrel pick and Pursuit Spirits' legendary "Minick's Muffins" barrel.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Todd Ritter holds down the fort solo this week while Jim Shannon is on vacation, but he is far from alone. Joining him are Dude Poole and JD Fritches, the duo behind the Bourbon Hunters podcast, for a conversation that is equal parts bourbon education, life philosophy, and genuine friendship. The guys trace their origin stories — from stolen sips of Jim Beam to ginger-ale-and-bourbon revelations to a COVID-era collector's awakening — and walk listeners through how a simple idea to record a road trip turned into 350 episodes of an entertainment-first bourbon show that just happens to feature a lot of great whiskey.

The Bourbon Hunters crew brought the pours, and they did not disappoint. The tasting mat features a pair of podcast barrel picks — one from Old Forester's single barrel program and one from Pursuit Spirits, the latter carrying a backstory involving a certain well-known bourbon journalist who had to surrender the barrel before it found its way into the Bourbon Hunters' hands and earned the nickname Minick's Muffins.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Old Forester 100 Proof Single Barrel (Bourbon Hunters Pick, Where Else High Floor 2): Bottled at 100 proof, this single barrel Old Forester was selected by the Bourbon Hunters at the Where Else High Floor 2 location and represents their very first legacy distillery barrel pick as a podcast. The nose opens with cherry-sweet fruit and a clean, inviting character that draws you in immediately. On the palate it delivers the hallmark Old Forester balance — ripe dark fruit, warm vanilla, and a polished mid-palate — without the heat that can accompany higher-proof expressions from the same distillery. A showcase of why the 100-proof mark is widely considered the sweet spot for Old Forester single barrels. (00:02:00)
  • Pursuit Spirits Single Barrel "Minick's Muffins" (Bourbon Hunters Pick, Relay Stave Finish): This Pursuit Spirits single barrel, finished with an independent stave company relay stave, was bottled somewhere in the 110-proof neighborhood and carries one of the more colorful origin stories in the Bourbon Hunters' barrel history — it was originally selected by bourbon media personality Fred Minnick before circumstances required it to be returned to the distillery's barrel program, at which point the Bourbon Hunters snagged it on their December bourbon blitz trip. The nose is immediately and almost aggressively breakfast-forward: pure maple syrup, pancake batter, and warm confectioners' sugar. The palate follows through with rich dark fruit, a deep maple sweetness, and a lush, layered mid-palate that balances sweetness with enough wood influence to keep things grounded. The relay stave treatment is evident throughout, adding a distinctive toasted, caramelized character that sets it apart from a traditional straight bourbon profile. (00:36:07)

Beyond the pours, the conversation covers how the Bourbon Hunters evolved their format from a traditional review show into something closer to a lifestyle podcast, the creation of their rotating barrel club for Patreon supporters, the joys and logistical headaches of doing your own barrel picks, and what it really means to build genuine friendships around a shared passion. If you have not yet found the Bourbon Hunters podcast, this episode is a perfect on-ramp.

Full Transcript

Bourbon Hunters podcast Dude Poole JD Fritches Old Forester single barrel Pursuit Spirits barrel pick relay stave bourbon podcast Todd Ritter The Bourbon Road Fred Minnick Wild Turkey Patreon bourbon club Columbus Ohio bourbon Where Else High Floor single barrel bourbon bourbon collecting bourbon tasting independent stave bourbon community

The Conversation