Skip to content
Episode 51 March 18, 2020 · 54:12
51. Kickin' Back by the Fire with Some Ol' Fo'

51. Kickin' Back by the Fire with Some Ol' Fo'

Jim & Mike taste 3 Old Forester single barrels (90, 100 & barrel strength), a Sagamore Rye store pick, and the new Baker's 7 Single Barrel by the fire.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt settle in by the fire at Jep the Bend Farm for Episode 51 of The Bourbon Road, with snow on the ground and a full tasting mat ahead. With Old Forester's newly announced George Garvin Brown Single Barrel program fresh on their minds — a significant upgrade from the longtime 90-proof store-pick format — the guys explore three expressions of Old Forester side by side, including a legacy Silver Dollar bar pick and two new offerings from the program: a 100-proof and a barrel-strength version clocking in between 130 and 135 proof. From there, they pivot to a barrel-select Maryland rye from Sagamore Spirit before Jim pulls a bottle of the newly rebranded Baker's 7 Single Barrel from Mike's collection to round out the night.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Old Forester Single Barrel 90 Proof (Silver Dollar / The Pearl Store Pick): A 90-proof, 4-year-6-month store pick selected by Louisville's Silver Dollar bar and available through their sister bottle shop, The Pearl of Germantown. The nose opens with banana nut bread and oak, while the palate delivers dry oak and a hint of tobacco with a short, slightly drying finish. (00:06:51)
  • Old Forester George Garvin Brown Single Barrel 100 Proof (Sample): Part of the newly launched barrel-selection program, this 100-proof expression presents a noticeably different character from its 90-proof sibling. Cherry, caramel, and vanilla dominate the nose, while the palate is sweeter and less drying, with a peppery, lingering finish that gives it an extra dimension of life. (00:10:19)
  • Old Forester George Garvin Brown Single Barrel Barrel Strength (Sample, ~130–135 Proof): The most dramatic of the Old Forester trio, this barrel-strength expression is markedly darker in the glass and opens with an intoxicating rush of honey, cherry syrup, and what Mike describes as Honey Smacks cereal. On the palate it is buttery, rich, and fruit-forward with a honey-cherry sweetness, dark fruit depth, and a warm, pepper-laced finish. (00:17:26)
  • Sagamore Spirit Rye Whiskey Barrel Select 110 Proof (Whiskey Crusaders / Mirage Fine Spirits Pick, Barrel #72, Floor 6 Rack 3, 6 Years): A 6-year-old, 110-proof Maryland rye selected by the Whiskey Crusaders and Mirage Fine Spirits. The nose carries an unusual malty, berry-forward quality that the guys find intriguing if a bit unexpected. The palate, however, is sweet, lightly berry-driven, and far more approachable than the nose suggests, with a medium-to-long finish and a gentle pepper note. (00:30:22)
  • Baker's 7 Single Barrel 107 Proof (8 Years 6 Months): The newly rebranded Baker's, transitioned from small batch to single barrel and dressed in a striking new bottle with a substantial cork stopper. At 107 proof and just over eight and a half years old, this barrel delivers a honey-oat nose with a savory backbone, dried fruit, and significant oak presence. The palate is rich and sipping-worthy, with a finish that pairs naturally with barbecue or country ham. (00:38:53)

The evening wraps up with chocolate-covered almonds making a surprise appearance at the tasting table, a lively conversation about Old Forester's expanding vision for their single barrel program, and a heartfelt thank-you to the Bourbon Roadies community for pushing the show to No. 28 on Apple Podcasts. As always, Jim and Mike keep it honest, keep it warm, and keep it your bourbon, your way.

Full Transcript

Old Forester George Garvin Brown Single Barrel Baker's 7 Sagamore Spirit Maryland rye barrel strength bourbon 100 proof bourbon single barrel bourbon Brown-Forman Jim Beam Bourbon Road podcast store pick bourbon rye whiskey Kentucky bourbon bourbon tasting barrel select Old Forester 1910 Whiskey Crusaders The Pearl Germantown Silver Dollar Louisville

The Conversation