Skip to content
Episode 51 March 18, 2020 · 54:12
51. Kickin' Back by the Fire with Some Ol' Fo'

51. Kickin' Back by the Fire with Some Ol' Fo'

Jim & Mike taste new Old Forester single barrels at 100 proof & barrel strength, plus Sagamore Rye and the new Baker's 7 single barrel.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Welcome back to The Bourbon Road, where Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt pull up chairs by the fire at Jep the Bend Farm for a cozy, wide-ranging episode packed with pours. With snow on the ground outside and Woodrow the dog settled in at their feet, the two hosts dig into some exciting new releases and a few personal picks, making for one of their most varied tasting sessions yet.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Old Forester Single Barrel (90 Proof) – Silver Dollar Store Pick: A 4-year, 6-month-old single barrel bottled at 90 proof, selected by The Silver Dollar bar in Louisville and available through The Pearl of Germantown. Published notes of banana nut bread, tobacco, and dry oak hold up on the palate, with a slightly thin mouthfeel, a drying oak finish, and a touch of heat that surprises for its proof point. Priced at $45. (00:06:52)
  • Old Forester George Garvin Brown Single Barrel (100 Proof) – Sample: One of two new expressions in Old Forester's revamped single barrel program, this bottle moves away from the legacy 90-proof format. This sample, selected by Old Forester's Jackie Zykan, leads with cherry, caramel, and vanilla on the nose, with a sweeter, less drying palate than the 90-proof expression and a notably peppery finish. (00:10:19)
  • Old Forester George Garvin Brown Single Barrel (Barrel Strength, ~130–135 Proof) – Sample: The barrel strength companion to the 100-proof release, this sample delivers a dramatically different experience. Honey dominates the nose — think honey cereal — while the palate opens up with butter, cherry, and dark fruit, rounding into a warm, lingering finish with a peppery rye character. Barrel strength ranges estimated at 130–135 proof. (00:17:26)
  • Sagamore Spirit Rye Whiskey – Barrel #72, Whiskey Crusaders / Mirage Fine Spirits Pick (110 Proof, 6 Years): A barrel-strength Maryland straight rye whiskey, floor 6, rack 3, picked by Mirage Fine Spirits and Whiskey Crusaders in 2019. The nose is distinctive and somewhat polarizing — malty, with a dark fruit or berry quality — while the palate delivers surprising sweetness, a light berry character, and a peppery finish. Drinks smoother than its 110-proof billing might suggest. (00:30:44)
  • Baker's 7-Year Single Barrel (107 Proof): The newly rebranded Baker's, now a single barrel expression rather than a small batch, aged 8 years and 6 months in this particular barrel and bottled at 107 proof. The nose carries honey nut cereal, oats, and a savory, meaty quality, with some dried fruit and notable oak influence. A rich, sipping-forward whiskey that the hosts suggest pairs naturally with barbecue or country ham. (00:40:44)

Jim and Mike close out the night reflecting on the state of the bourbon industry — from distilleries listening to consumer demand for higher proofs, to the enduring value of single barrel programs and the history buried (literally) in Louisville's Cave Hill Cemetery. Whether you're a barrel-strength devotee or a sweet-sip traditionalist, this episode has something to reach for. See you down the Bourbon Road.

Full Transcript

Mike Hyatt Tasting Interview Bourbon Rye Single Barrel Small Batch Kentucky Old Forester Old Forester George Garvin Brown single barrel Baker's 7 single barrel Sagamore Spirit rye barrel strength bourbon single barrel bourbon 100 proof bourbon Maryland rye whiskey Jim Shannon Mike Hyatt The Bourbon Road podcast Brown-Forman Kentucky bourbon rye whiskey barrel pick Silver Dollar Louisville Whiskey Crusaders The Pearl of Germantown bourbon tasting bourbon history