522. The OG Returns: A Bottled in Bond Celebration with Randy Minnick
OG co-host Randy Minnick returns for a Bottled in Bond deep-dive: Starlight, Whiskey Acres Rye, Heaven Hill Double Mash, and Rittenhouse 10 Year 250th Anniversary.
Reviews
Show Notes
Welcome back to The Bourbon Road, episode 522! Hosts Todd Ritter and Jim Shannon are joined by a very special guest — Randy Minnick, the original co-founder and co-host of the podcast from its earliest days. Randy returns for a deep dive into one of his all-time favorite whiskey categories: Bottled in Bond. The conversation covers the rich history of the Bottled in Bond Act of 1897, what the designation truly means today versus its origins as a consumer protection standard, and why craft distilleries earning the label is a meaningful nod to tradition. It's a warm, nostalgic reunion full of great stories, laughs, and four exceptional pours.
On the Tasting Mat:
- Starlight Bottled in Bond Bourbon: A blend of Starlight Distillery's three-grain and four-grain mash bills, aged four to five years, bottled at 100 proof. MSRP $60. From Starlight, Indiana — a farm and winery operation that added distilling in 2013 — this bourbon opens with lush vanilla cream on the nose, evolving into peach and stone fruit. The palate delivers more vanilla, raspberries, and caramel with a smooth, sessionable finish. (00:03:12)
- Whiskey Acres Bottled in Bond Rye: An estate-distilled 100-proof rye from DeKalb, Illinois, made with a mash bill of 75% rye and 25% corn, aged four to five years. MSRP $55. Double Gold winner at the 2021 San Francisco World Spirits Competition. The nose is fresh and bright — floral, lavender, fresh-cut grass, and a hint of mint and anise. On the palate, butterscotch emerges alongside spice notes reminiscent of Indian fennel seeds, with a shiny, lively finish. (00:12:34)
- Heaven Hill Bottled in Bond Double Mash: A nine-year-old 100-proof American bourbon from Heaven Hill, blending two-thirds of their traditional mash bill (78% corn, 10% rye, 12% malted barley) with one-third of their wheated bourbon mash bill (68% corn, 20% wheat, 12% malted barley). MSRP $50. The nose is a walk into a bakery — vanilla icing, cinnamon, and buttered pastries. The palate brings honey, vanilla cream, cinnamon spice, and bright Anjou pear, with a warm, rounded finish that drinks slightly bigger than its proof. (00:27:08)
- Rittenhouse Rye 10 Year Bottled in Bond — United States 250th Anniversary Commemorative Edition: A special release from Heaven Hill bottled at 100 proof from 90 hand-selected barrels. Mash bill of 51% rye, 35% corn, and 14% malted barley. MSRP $100, approximately 15,000–20,000 bottles. Named after Rittenhouse Square in Philadelphia, the brand dates to 1934. The nose erupts with dark berries — blackberries, raspberries, and plums — framed by buttery pastry crust. The palate is an emphatic blackberry cobbler experience, rich and seamless from first sip through a long, luscious finish. (00:36:16)
Four states, four distilleries, four expressions of one of American whiskey's most storied legal designations — tonight's lineup is a masterclass in what Bottled in Bond can be across age, grain, and geography. Randy Minnick's return to the mic is as smooth as the pours, and his passion for the category is as sharp as ever. Raise a glass to tradition, to great whiskey, and to old friends back on the road.
Full Transcript
It's been a week of Mondays but the weekend's here Dust on my boots and a smile with my beard Neon summin' low whether it knows our name Same old bar stools but it never feels the same We raise a glass to the miles we've made To the stories told and the dues we've paid Amber light in a crystal glow A little burnin' Where the good times roll Passing bottles like a piece of soul Every pore's a memory, every sip a spark Lighting up the night in the Kentucky dirt Ain't no mail, just the ties we've sewn On the long winding bird
All right, listeners, welcome back to another episode of The Bourbon Road. I'm Todd Ritter, and with me as always is my co-host, Jim Shannon. Jim, who do we got with us tonight?
Oh my God, the OG is in the house. Oh, stop. The OG. Yes. Yes, Randy Minnick. Randy Minnick, co-host numero uno from, I don't know, 100 years ago. Glad to have you back. Coming back for a special episode on one of his favorite topics, which is bottled in Bond. Randy, you were the bottled in Bond guy from the early Bourbon Road series.
Yes. I just, I like it. It's my wheelhouse.
It's perfect.
It's a great thing. You didn't have to wait 500 episodes to do this.
I know, you know, I just mentioned, hey, if you guys ever have one, I'd love to be there. Cause I knew you would bring some great stuff, great stuff. All right.
Well, for those listeners who don't know Randy have not had the opportunity to listen to Randy on air or meet Randy at one of the events that we go to, uh, go into the way back machine on the bourbon road.com and go and just hit rewind and let it keep rewinding and rewinding and rewinding. and rewinding and rewinding.
And eventually, just keep scrolling way down.
You'll hit our first 20 episodes. And in that first 20 episodes, Randy and I founded the Bourbon Road, started the podcast and basically launched what today is a 500 plus episode podcast. Randy, welcome back again.
Thank you gentlemen for having me.
He's living off the royalties now.
Yeah. We got to send those checks every month, right?
Right.
It's like 20 episodes I'm done. Just send me a check. $0.18, yes. All right. Well, you know, as always, Randy, we like to get to that first pour. So you ready?
I'm ready.
All right.
Our first pour is... What are we starting with to see?
Starlight Bottled and Bond Bourbon. Starlight, of course, is in Starlight, Indiana. This is a blend of their three-grain and four-grain mashbills using barrels aged four or five years. MSRP is $60. Obviously, since it's a bottled and bond, it is 100 proof. Starlight is pretty cool because it started out as an orchard and winery in 2001 and then didn't start distilling bourbons and rice until 2013. I'd be curious to know if they've got some 13-year barrels way back when. I know they released a 10-year recently.
Now I will, I will say this, you know, one of the things, okay, let's, let's taste this whiskey before I start diving into some technical jargon. What do you say? Okay. All right. So starlight love, love it. I mean, it's, uh, it's not too far from where we live. It's about an hour away, not even quite an hour. A great, um, sort of a, uh, farm retreat in Indiana and starlight Indiana. And, uh, yeah, what started as sort of a family farm project and a, and a fun place to take your family on the weekends has morphed into, uh, a little bit more than that. And they distill now. So. Lots of fun. I'm hitting my nose on this, Todd.
It's like vanilla cream. Yes. Yes.
Yes.
You nailed it. Just some classic notes there. A lot of vanilla, though. Brown sugar.
A little bit of peach. Oh, a stone fruit, stone fruit.
I'm getting, I'm getting that fruit too.
Yep. So this is, uh, this is kind of, uh, sort of a peach and peaches and cream kind of thing. Is that, is that rounded out a little bit? I like that peaches and vanilla cream. What do you think, Randy?
I'm getting some, a little bit of sweetness and I'm wondering if it's not like, you know, they were a winery, you know, before they started distilling. I'm just, I'm thinking almost like a sweet port or something, you know, as far as the, the initial.
It's interesting you just say that they do a lot of, they take a lot of their wine barrels, obviously, and do a lot of finishes. I've seen like pork, sherry, brandy's of course, Tokai.
Brandy, I think that's what was one of the first ones that they used to do. When I went there, they hadn't started distilling quite yet. And then they picked it up, and I think they had some other spirits, but I don't remember bourbon. The wines were always pretty good.
When they first started out, you could, uh, you could go on hay rides, pick apples and pumpkins. We went there for pumpkins every year and feed the fish in the pond. Right. And they, and they had a restaurant there and that was about it. That was about it. And then of course they've expanded significantly. And, uh, the farm has split into, uh, Hubers and Starlight now both. So, I mean, it's two separate entities, but yeah. This is a great nose. I'm really looking forward to tasting it.
Let's get to it. Cheers. Cheers.
Oh, wow. Yeah, that is right on point with the nose. Agreed. The vanilla is still there in spades. Very nice. That is a tasty bonded whiskey. Some red fruits.
That's, yeah, that's what I'm getting a lot of actually.
Very vanilla, very vanilla.
It kind of went from peaches and cream to like raspberry and cream to me though, a little bit, a lot of caramel.
I see that. I would agree with that.
Yeah. It took the berry turn, huh? The berry turn. I like it.
So Randy, what is it about Baldwin Bonds that kind of?
If I was to tell you what I'm really thinking, you guys would laugh at me. But it's almost like because they go to the effort to do Baldwin Bond, they put a little more tender loving care into the product. And that's just me, the way I feel it. That Hunter, to me, is a great place to be just because you get some really good flavor. but it's not as hot as some of the stuff you guys like to drink. So it's, to me, it's just a smooth, I don't know, a smooth way to finish the day.
I think you kind of have to think back to when it was declared, bottled and bond. back in the day, back in the late 1800s, it was in an effort to stop the proliferation of substandard whiskeys, right?
Well, they didn't call it fire water for anything. There was probably quite a bit of kerosene. What else do they call it?
They call it all kinds of things. Rectified. Yeah.
Rectifiers. Yeah.
So back in the day when you got a bottle in bond, you knew you were getting some primo stuff. Now today, most whiskey's good. So, Bottle and Bond does still stand out as an icon in the class, but it doesn't have the same distinction that it had back in the day when it was going against, you know, whiskey that had been rectified and mixed with who knows what. You know rock gut they called it or whatever. Yeah Yeah, so I mean it but one thing I have to talk about here Todd is that you know a couple of things about what makes bottle and bond bottle and bond One is that it's made under a single master distiller at a single distillery in a single distilling season It is barreled and delivered in bottles after four years only, it has to be at least four years, after four years into 100 proof bottles and it have to be glass bottles and they have to be It has to be aged in a bonded warehouse that's under government control. Now those bonded warehouses are no longer truly under government control, but every distillery that makes bonded whiskey declares a bonded warehouse. Right. And the, the question I have about this whiskey is in your opening statement about this whiskey, you said four and five year olds.
I think they do batches though. So that might be it. So sometimes it's a four year bottle to bond. Sometimes it's a five.
Okay. But never the mixture of the two because that wouldn't be a single distilling season. Right. Got it. Okay. So this was a sample. I was ready to fire up my weapons here.
Yeah. So this is a sample they sent us, so I didn't have like all the information that, you know, some bottles have. This was a media sample.
I mean, there can be bonded whiskeys that are 15 years old. It doesn't really matter as long as they maintain that bonded storage and they are 100 proof. and they met all the requirements, you know, single distilling season, single master distiller, one distillery, and a bottle of warehouse, and then it still qualifies. And there are some 10-year bottling bonds, right? I mean, think about some of the ones that are out there.
Yeah, we're gonna, we're actually gonna go up the age ladder on our bottling bonds today. Yeah, excited. Any other notes on this one? This is a really good whiskey. I know.
I'm very surprised and impressed. I like it.
Yeah, I wouldn't mind having a bottle of this. This would be a porch pour, a porch sipper, whatever you want to call it. I could session this one, no doubt. Randy and I could sit down on his back deck, look over at Crabbe Tree Falls and make a bottle of this go away, couldn't we?
I probably so. take long.
All right. Shall we move on? Let's do it. All right. Our second one we're going to have tonight is from Whiskey Acres. This is their bottom bond rye. So we're actually going to switch gears and go to a rye. So their match bill is 75% rye, 25% corn. MSRP is $55 and Whiskey Acres is located in DeKalb, Illinois. So we're kind of keeping it in the Midwest, if you will. It's an estate distilled 100-proof rye. It won double go to the San Francisco World Spirits Competition in 2021. And this is another one where some batches are four years and others are five years. And this is one of those that was our darling of 2025 when we had that single barrel from lost line and it really knocked our socks off.
Yeah, whiskey acres has a habit of carrying over the pleasing youthful notes of a whiskey into the later years as it ages. And not a lot of people can do that effectively. Early whiskies, young whiskies have sometimes off-putting notes, right? They don't taste great. But with that are some youthful notes that are amazing. The brightness and the sweetness that you get and the nice corn notes that you get with a whiskey. This is a rye, I'm not sure what the mash bill is, but... 75-25. 75-25. Okay. So those, sometimes those youthful notes that are distinctive of a younger whiskey disappear when it gets older and you hate to lose some of them. You're glad to see some of them go, but some of them you hate to lose. Right. And whiskey acres has a habit of carrying the better of those over into the later years. So that's great.
Little floral.
Yeah. Fresh, right? It's got kind of a,
Fresh cut grass might be like, uh, like walking through a meadow. I'm getting a little like lavender almost.
Yeah. I think you're right. And you know, there might be a little bit of like, as you're cutting the grass in that meadow, you might be trimming up some mint as you go. There might be a little bit of mint in the grass.
I'm even getting a little of your, uh, anise a little bit.
Yeah. Got some nice rye notes. This is a, this would be a youthful rye, but well balanced. The nose is very pleasing on it. This is a, this is a spring and summer sipper rye.
Yeah, I agree with that.
Early season, right?
Right.
All right. Shall we taste? Yep. Cheers. Cheers.
Cheers. Don't laugh. That took me a little different direction. Didn't like cream, like butterscotch. Like, I don't know why there's certain ones. I can pull some butterscotch from this.
Yeah. The niece kind of rose to the top for me a little bit. Your whore hound candies a little bit, a little whore hound, little, um, that little, uh, you guys ever eat Indian food? Yeah. You know, when you're, you know, when you're checking out at the counter and you're paying for your meal after you're all done and they've got that little bowl of spices there and you can pick some up and chew on them. That's what I remember that. Yeah. That's great. Yeah. This is, uh, fresh and, uh, bright and shiny. Shiny. Shiny is a good word. Yeah. Shiny is great. I like it. This reminds me of pin hook a little bit.
Hmm. Which is impressive because pin hook. Well, I know some of their pin hook is castle and key, but there for a while wasn't MGP.
Yeah. Yeah, it's good.
So tell me, guys, what are some of your What are your favorite bottled and bonds? I know Jim's a big OG, heaven and hell speaking of OGs that old heaven and hill that used to be like for $14. Oh yeah.
The six year bond that you can't get anymore that I still have like three or four bottles of. Randy was just here. He was down at the bar. I think he saw, he saw him sitting there, didn't you?
Yeah, I had some.
Yeah.
Yeah. That's the best presence you ever gave me, Jim. Yeah.
Good stuff.
Henry McKenna.
Henry McKenna, and we were talking earlier in the show about, you know, bottom bonds can be older. The 10-year bottling bond from McKenna.
Yep, yep. I love that one. That one's, I got some at the house, believe it or not. They've opened up here in Virginia. I'm able to get some of that stuff that I was not able to get.
And one of the things about those, and you know, it's kind of the same with Blanton's, Blanton's isn't a bottle and bomb, but Blanton's is one of those single barrels that you get that, um, that varies a lot, right? You get great ones, you get good ones, and you get ones that are okay. And the same thing goes for Henry McKenna. You know, you can get great ones because McKenna is not only a bottle and bond whiskey. It's not a batch whiskey. It's a single barrel. So, um, you can get some great ones. You can get some good ones and you get some, Oh, they're okay. You know, but I've had some great McKenna's really good McKenna's and it's just the luck of the draw. When you pull one off a shelf, you never know what you're going to get. It's always going to be at least good, but you don't know if it's going to be great or not. That was a, what is it? Six or eight years ago, the, McKenna won Bourbon, like won the Bourbon of the Year Best in Show at San Francisco about eight years ago. Yep. They just got that one great barrel. They just sang, you know.
Yeah.
I think it's great to see some of these craft guys coming out with Baldwin bonds. It's kind of like I guess like a notch on the belt kind of thing for some of these places. I mean, even Jackson Purchase just released one recently, which is kind of exciting.
Yeah, I think it's a great thing. It's sort of a tradition that doesn't have teeth anymore because it's not something that's truly enforced and maintained. But, you know, it's definitely
It's good to see. Extra steps have been taken.
Extra steps have been taken and they're taken in honor of tradition more than they are in order to keep in step with requirements, right? It's really a tradition thing.
I think it's great. Yeah, we've even talked about, for our Whiskey Six show, kind of having a dive into like how important is the bottle in the bond to different fans of bourbon. Yeah. Which yeah, we'll dive into that too much, but it could be a fun topic. Well, it's a fun topic.
Who was it? Who was it? Stag that didn't necessarily agree with that? Him and him and Taylor, I guess. Well, they just didn't agree on anything.
So, yeah.
Well, they didn't have to agree. Stag body mouth, right?
Yeah.
So I did do, I asked AI a question today because I thought, I wonder if it's smart enough to figure it out. And I asked how many Baldwin Bond whiskies had the Bourbon Road reviewed on there. And it couldn't give me, it was very, being very finicky. I did this, I used Gemini today. I mean, I could have used our own website to probably come up with a number, but I thought maybe, I thought Joe and I give us a nice round number of like how many you guys had tried and you know, the other co-hosts, but it did say we've had over 1,421 different reviews on there now.
Yeah. That's amazing.
Can you believe it? I can't. We were just trying to survive from one show to the next in the old days. You know what I mean?
It's not just, yeah. Yeah. It's not just, uh, 1,421 reviews, but it's 1,421 reviews that are documented, recorded on the website. You can search. So, I mean, there, that's a big deal. That's quite a corpus of reviews. I just like that word magic there.
Yeah, it's kind of like plethora. Yeah, plethora. There you go. Plethora.
I was going to say, we have had a plethora of pores, right?
Yeah.
Plethora of calories, all that good stuff.
Well, both those whiskies were really good. I was going to say- Very different. And, you know, again, to make sure that we keep this show both enjoyable, fun, and educational, we did just have a rye whiskey that's a bottle and bond. And, you know, you could talk to some people and some people might say, wait a second, bottle and bonds are supposed to be bourbons. No, they can be ryes. But not only can they be rise, they can be Jen's, they can be vodkas. They can be any American made spirit that is. Bonded that follows the bond the bonded rules. So yes, you can have any bonded I've had bonded Jen I've had bonded vodka's I don't know if I've had a bonded brandy Bonded brandy. We've had bonded brandy. That's right So pretty pretty interesting not a lot of that out there.
It's pretty rare, but it does exist So, what do you guys think take a break and come back with two more
Let's do it. Let's keep sipping on these two though. I mean, I've got a little bit left and we're going to do winter, winter chicken dinner at the end and pick a best of show. So yeah, let's dive in during the break here and we'll come back folks. When we do, we'll have two more whiskies and lots more fun. So don't go away. We'll be right back. All right, roadies, we finally, finally released our brand new website. We hope you get a chance to check it out at the bourbonroad.com. It is a total rewrite remake revamped. We've done it for you. We have all 500 or so episodes on there with all the details searchable. All you know all the show notes everything you can search by it You want to go find out what we talked about on an episode way back when you can do it We've also got our tasting notes our reviews of over 1320 whiskies. They're all on there Todd nice our tasting notes our rating for the whiskey We even cue up the episode on the tasting notes To where we tasted on the show. So as you're reading our tasting notes, you can play it listen to us talk about it So I think we're the only podcast that does that that's pretty cool So another thing we have on there is our blog articles. We've got over 250 blog articles on there. We're putting new ones out all the time. And the all new roadie bar is now on the Bourbon Road website. So if you're a roadie, come on, sign up, get in there. We have a chat room. We've got a place where you can post what's going on in your Bourbon world. We have a calendar of all the events that are coming up. We'll be posting in there our drawings, so as we're giving things away, you'll be able to come in there and sign up for the randomizer to get picked. You'll also be able to sign up on lists to come to something that we're sponsoring. Todd's got a great event that we're putting on in the fall, and everybody can come in and sign up for that. And we've also got coupons from our vendors for percentages off on stuff. Definitely take the time to come to the website. Check it out. We do want you to come in and sign up and join in. It's a lot of fun. It's free. It doesn't cost you anything. You're certainly welcome to donate if you want to, but it's free for all roadies. So come check it out.
All right, listeners, welcome back to the second half of the show. We're with the OG co-host of The Bourbon Road. We're gonna get you a shirt, Randy. The OG co-host, I like it. But we've been diving into some bottling the bonds per Randy's request. So maybe he'll request something else and I'll just have to, that way we get him back on the show. What do you think, Jim?
I think we should, yeah. Sounds good to me.
All right. So what did we have in the first half? Yeah, I was going to say the first pour we had was the Starlight Baldwin & Bond bourbon. That's a blend of their three grain and four grain mash builds. Follow that up with the Whiskey Acres Baldwin & Bond rye. So we've gone from Indiana to Illinois, but now we're going to up that age and we're going to dive into some Kentucky stuff.
All right.
All right, so our first one, actually, these are both from Heaven Hills, so may give you a clue as to what we're getting to dive into. And this first one is the Bault and Bond Double Mash. So this is a nine-year-old Bault and Bond. MSRP is $50. It's called a double mash bill because it is a blend composed of two-thirds traditional bourbon mash bill, which is their 78 corn, 10% rye, 12% malted barley, and they're a third blend of the weeded bourbon mashbill, which is 68% corn, 20% wheat, and 12% malted barley. And you'll see this one out on the shelf, and it kind of has the look of, I guess, the second coming of the Heaven and Hill Bottom of the Bond, which took the place of your favorite gem, what they Raised it a year. It was turned into a seven year bottle of wine and the price went up to about 50 or 60, I think. Yes. Yeah. So this one looks about like that, but it says double mash and then it's got kind of a red, red color rather than that blue that the, and this is a, this is an American whiskey.
Okay.
So there we go, there's another variety, another variety that makes it into bottle and bottle, an American whiskey, because of the weeded whiskey that's put in here, right? Oh, no, they're calling it a bourbon. So what's the second match bill again?
The match bill was 68% corn, 20% wheat, and 12% multi-garlic. Oh, got it, so it's a weeded bourbon. Got it, okay. I thought you said a wheat, I thought you said a... Wheat whiskey. No, I do feel like they're really like pushing, like pushing the limit on a lot of things anymore.
Yeah. Yeah. Bernheim, if they had to put some Bernheim in here, we'd had a American whiskey. Yeah. All right. So I'm getting a little bit of that sweet cream too, on this one that we got on the starlight, maybe a little honey, a little honey. Good call out. I was going to say the proof is up on this, but no, it's 100 proof, but it has more proofiness to it, I should say.
Proofiness. I think it might be that oak presence that's kind of giving it a little more oomph.
Not charred, more toasted than charred maybe, but.
Yeah, the nose is just going into a bakery shop and having all those iced donuts and iced this, that, and the other, the vanilla iced pastries. A little bit of cinnamon, but not too much. Butter. Yeah, I love it. This is a pastry shop for me.
Yeah. Now I'll never forget that every time I see the bottle. It's a pastry shop. Yeah.
Pastry shop. Yeah, I'll tell you what, Frankfurt, where Todd's from, they have all kinds of donut shops around here. It's like the donut shop haven. Which is bad for me because I can walk to a mall.
That's why I walk. When I go have a donut, I always walk to where I go have a donut. It makes me feel less guilty.
We have no donut shops. If we want a donut, we have to go to Kroger's and go to the, the Krispy Kreme cabinet back at the bakery. Is there a bakery in Shelbyville though? There's no bakeries in Shelbyville that I know of. Unless I missed it. But yeah, we can get donuts, but they're usually delivered super early in the morning or something. And they're not quite fresh. I think sometimes even like Speedway has them or something like that, but it's not the same as going into your two or three donut shops you have there. And plus you have a bakery too.
Yeah. Yeah. I'm literally like a two minute walk from one of our local bakeries.
Oh my gosh. I would be walking down there having coffee and a pastry.
It's a blessing and a curse. Yeah. But shout out to Andy's bakery.
Andy's bakery. Now I know we often get like a peanut shell kind of thing.
Are you getting that on this at all?
Man, I'm solid in the bakery room. I can't smell the peanut right now.
The caramel's there, but it's not up front, you know?
We might pick it up on the palate. Let's dive in.
Yeah, cheers. Cheers.
Yeah, there's a little bit there.
Still... Your honey's still there big time, Randy.
Yeah. Yeah. Good call out, Randy. I think, uh, honey and then they still have vanilla cream and vanilla cream and honey.
Yeah. I mean, imagine mixing those two together, putting it on something.
Yeah. Not getting a whole lot of the, um, kind of the caramel here. I'm getting more, um, Oak and, um, Kind of a, maybe a little bit of cinnamon spice.
Yes, the cinnamon's there. I'm almost getting like some brighter fruits rather than like a cherry kind of thing. It's almost like, we said it not too long ago, the anju pear, like that red pear kind of thing. Yeah. That's a great whiskey.
That's really good. It is. $50, huh? Yes.
For nine years, no less. That is one thing I find pretty fascinating for the most part is, I mean, McKenna, like you said, is a 10 year and it's what, 50, 60 bucks? I mean, I think it got a little elevated when, like you said, it won all those awards, people kind of, or some of these stores kind of do an extra 15, 20 on it. But I think it's kind of come back down to
I can remember it was somewhere between 28 and 32. Those days are gone. Was that pre-pro Jim? No, I'm kidding. Funny thing is I remember, I remember when all the hoopla was going on around it. I went and bought a case of the McKenna 10 year and I got bottles that were barrel numbers 4,450 or something, 4,460. And the one that won San Francisco was 4461 or something like that. So I had one bottle that was off the same Rick as the as the barrel that won San Francisco. Now it's not the same barrel, but off the same Rick anyway. And I was like, oh man, that's pretty cool. But you know how it goes in the whiskey biz. You can have the next barrel over and it'd be totally different. So true.
Well, they all had the same chance. Let's just put it that way.
I'm actually kind of sitting here trying to think, is there another bottle in the bond that does single barrels? Oh, I guess, no, no. Yeats Taylor single barrels. Oh yes, that would be one. Yeats Taylor single barrel would be one. Yep, yes.
And I'm not sure the age of those. I'm going to say around seven probably.
I would guess yes, six, seven probably. Um, can't think of anything else though.
Yep. I don't know. There are more. We just can't come up with them. So.
Yeah.
All right. I'm registered. I got it. I got it locked in. I'm trying to compare it to those first two a little bit.
Anybody else getting white chocolate on the back end?
Ooh. Want to hit it again, Randy? I could see that.
I don't know. I think the creaminess kind of pushed me that way, you know, that the vanilla cream you were talking about, I guess. I don't know.
Yummy. I think this is.
This is a good representation because of a bottom to bottom because it's still got a little heft to it and a little oak character, a little spice. Yeah. Like Jim said, it drinks a little warmer than a hundred.
But it's not too hot, you know, on that back end where you usually get the spice. Right. It had a very nice finish, I thought.
Agreed. All right. All right. Well, this one I'm pretty excited for. This could be the lock, but we'll see. So this is Rittenhouse United States 250th Anniversary Commemorative Edition. We've had a few of those in the past, the 250th anniversary. So this came out back in May, but this is a 10-year ball and a bond straight rye. Released by Heaven Hill, like I said in May, MSRP on this is $100. It has a mash bill of 51% rye, 35% corn, 14% multi-barley. For this release, they chose 90 barrels that were And the release was about, it said somewhere between 15,000 bottles to 20,000 bottles. So I kind of figured it's probably more like 17, 17, five. The cool thing about this is the late, sorry.
No, I'm sorry to interrupt. You go right ahead.
The label features the Liberty Bell on it. Rittenhouse Rye is named after Rittenhouse Square located in Philadelphia, which is a seven-acre public park planned by William Penn and Thomas Holm in the late 17th century. The park itself was named after David Rittenhouse, an astronomer and clockmaker.
So yeah, it's a grand old brand. It's been around. It's been in continuous production since the 1800s. Is that correct?
No, it's not. I've actually got that info too. You're thinking of Overholt. Overholt, sorry. Both came from Pennsylvania though. That's right.
Both come from Heaven Hill.
Right. So Rittenhouse started as a brand in 1934, which that is literally right after the repeal of prohibition by continental distilling that was based in Philadelphia. Continental closed in the late 1980s. 1980s and changed hands among several owners until Heaven Hill acquired it in the mid 1990s. Oddly enough, despite Rittenhouse being a Pennsylvania rye style in the older days, which kind of was like 75% rye or higher, it has been converted to the more corn based Kentucky style. Kentucky rye. Yep. So there you go. Little, little history for you. Yeah. Ooh. It's like a berry patch. Yep. Yeah.
And I'm getting some kind of dark fruit. Yeah. Plums. Blackberries. Raspberries. Strawberries.
I don't know. Yeah. All the berries.
Yep.
One might call it a berry medley.
You're getting a little bit of that. Um, like what's, what's that? What's that called? When you make a, uh, a berry pie that has the crosshatch dough across the top of it. Um, I call that delicious, but I know, but what's it called? And then they sprinkle sugar crystals on, on top of them.
Yeah, stop.
It starts with a C. I can't remember it. Oh my gosh. It's been a long night. It starts with a C. Hmm. Cobbler. This is a, this is a berry cobbler. The butter crust was sugar sprinkled on it.
Oh, yeah. And it's like a blackberry cobbler.
Who called out the berries? Was that you, Ton? Or you, Randy? I think we all did.
We all did, really, I think.
This one's just screaming berries.
There's not a whole lot of else to it. It's blackberry cobbler with that wonderful butter crust.
It's almost like... And you just kind of get like this slice of rye toast, too.
I'm sorry. I had to taste it. I'm ahead of you guys. Sorry. Cheers, by the way. Cheers, by the way.
I'll ask AI how many times Jim's jumped the gun too early. That'd be kind of interesting if it knew that. Wait till it hits your palate. I can't wait to hear what you say.
friggin blackberry jam.
And it stayed that way on the palette too.
Oh my God. It kind of pushes the, the red berries out of the way and says, I'm blackberry. And yes, that's exactly, I tried this last night cause I wanted to so bad just to get a preview. And I was like, wow, I gotta have a bottle of this.
I was going to say, where did you say that? I can get a bottle of this. But anyway,
I'm sure they didn't cheat and put blackberries in a barrel on this. I know, right? Oh my goodness. It's almost too good to be true. It's almost like somebody cheated here. Somebody put real fruit in the barrel on this because you normally get hints of something. This is slam dunk.
And it's so smooth. That 10 years, 10 years. agent on this thing.
I hate to put a ringer in there, but this was once I got a bottle of this and you know, I knew Randy wanted to do this bottle to bond. I'm like, let's, this would be a good one to do. So cheers to you guys. Oh, cheers.
Oh, thank you for that choice. Cheers to you, man. This is awesome. That's delicious.
Wow. Four really good whiskeys tonight. And not a bad one in a bunch. Not a bad one in the bunch. It's going to make a winner winner chicken dinner. Just a little bit of a challenge tonight.
All these are definitely must try. So I will say that we always say that, but. If you see these, give them a whirl for sure.
I think the, I think the, you know, the four distilleries that are highlighted tonight are all distilleries that we have been super surprised with at times and always pleased with. I mean, they, you know, Starlight always puts out a great bottle.
And that's wine too. I've always been pleased with their wine. So I was looking forward to the bourbon. I was like, I know how they do their business. This was some good stuff here.
And whiskey acres. I mean, I just, I don't know. I don't know what to say about whiskey acres other than who are you? Where are you? I mean, where do you come from? How did you, how did you, how did you learn to make such great whiskey? Cause they really do. And of course, heaven hill goes without saying, they, uh, they're just a gold standard and Rittenhouse rye, uh, the S the old, the old Rittenhouse standard hundred proof bottle that is in every well in the country for rye, for rye cocktails. Um, it's just amazing. And then they put out something like this as a 10 year bottle and bond rye. It's just amazing. So good.
Yeah. I'd be curious to know what Mr. Baldwin upon himself, Bernie Lubbers thinks of this one. Yep.
Well, he would have only good things to say since he's employed by them. I'm sure. Oh yeah. That's something. Yeah, that's really good. All right. So has everybody taken their notes and tallied up the scores and decided who's who and what's what and got your top three? I do. I do too. Uh, Randy, how are you doing? You got your top three?
I do.
All right. So what do you want to do this time? I think I went first last time.
Okay. I'll go first. My third place is going to be the Whiskey Acres. Okay. I enjoyed that. It does have some graininess to it because they're a state grown and that, like you said, during our chat about that, they do kind of like to show the grains a little bit, but it was very pleasant, very floral. Yeah, I rather enjoyed it.
And I'm going to lean starlight on that one. So, um, and the reason I'm going to do that is because we're getting into the cooler air and a spring and summer sipper is not on my menu right now. So, um, I'm leaning a little bit more towards the starlight, which I thought might fit the season a little bit better. Um, I think they're both great whiskies. I could go either whiskey acres or starlight, but because of the season, I'm going to go starlight for my number three.
Randy? Whiskey Acre has just barely beat out Starlight for me. But I see what you're saying. I would probably rather have Starlight in a hot toddy. up here on the mountain this time of year maybe than the Whiskey Acres and save that more for spring. I see what you're saying there, but I think I'm going to go with Whiskey Acres for my third.
All right, so Whiskey Acres is a solid third right now. All right, Todd, where are you at on number two?
All right, my second place is actually going to be the Starlight. Oh, okay. There's some really nice flavors there. And Jim chose it third. And yeah, I was very impressed.
And we're going to be all over the board tonight. Cause I'm going to go number two for the heaven hill. It is just definitive bottle and bond whiskey. The picture of this bottle ought to be in the dictionary right next to the word bottle. So I think, I think it just defines it. It's very, um, middle of the road, solid representation of what you expect out of a bottle and bond whiskey. And, but yeah, I mean, you can't go wrong with either choice, Randy.
Yeah, Heaven Hill for my second. I'll be looking for the Redbots, just to put it that way. It's very pleasantly surprised. I love it.
All right, Todd, numero uno. Numero uno is the written house. But I'm going to say this. I think I had Heaven Hill like it was like second, third and fourth was really close. But I think The written house shine so much from heaven hill that it really outshined that the double match to me. So that's kind of why I pushed it down to fourth, but that written house is something special. If you can find a poor, try that. Cause it's, it's, it's something.
All right. Same for me. 10 written house, 10 year bottle and bond and absolute gem, delightful, um, blackberry cobbler. It is just, it's, it's just delicious. It's, it's amazing. And it is, I'm, I'm in search of a bottle right now.
So, um, Christmas is coming. Yeah. So when you're searching for that, I don't know that I've had. any kind of whiskey recently that was so powerful, lean one particular way. The berries in this, I mean, all the way across from your nose to the finish was fantastic. Yeah, that's my number one choice. I'll be looking for a bottle too, Jim.
Merry Christmas, Randy. Wow. Four, four really good whiskeys, four whiskeys that I would say, um, the larger portion of our listeners have not tried yet.
So I had not tried any of these and most excellent. Great choice of stock. Great.
You're very welcome. I'm glad we could do this.
So what was the price on that written house again?
It's a hundred bucks for a 10 year bottom bond. So it's, it's right there. It's that 10 a year. Yeah.
Yep. It's a special pour. It's definitely something that, yeah, I mean, I think you could give it to anybody and they would say blackberries. I don't see how you could not. You know, I mean, even somebody who doesn't, hasn't developed their palate for whiskey drinking yet, I think would probably still get blackberries on it. It's that problem.
And if they couldn't, I was gonna say, if they couldn't tell you what it was, they would look at you like, I know what that flavor is, and then you would say it and they'd be like, that's it. Yeah. Yeah.
I knew it was dark berries, but you guys pointed me towards the blackberries. I was like, it's dark. It's just very, like I said, the nose, through the palate, through the finish, the berries were there.
Yeah. I mean, if you, if you took a piece of, uh, of rye toast and you put blackberry jam on it and butter, you would still be pretty darn close. It doesn't have to be, it doesn't have to be blackberry copper. It could be rye toast with blackberry as in butter on it. I mean, it's just really, really good. Wow. Great show. Great, great matchup. I hope the listeners got some insights tonight into some bottles they need to have their eyes open for. Starlight, Whiskey Acres, Heaven Hill. Heaven Hill is always a winner. Two great pours out of Heaven Hill, I think. If I have to go back and figure out what the one, two, three is based on all our votes, I would say Rittenhouse took number one. Heaven Hill took number two because Randy and I both got it, I think. And then Whiskey Acres took number three because Todd and Randy both picked that one. So one, two, and three. That doesn't mean the Starlight's not a great whiskey. It obviously is a very good whiskey. I picked it second, so it depends on how you score. That's right. You picked it second. That math gets a little complicated. I think that's beyond me right now. So I'm not going to try that.
Well, try all four and you won't be disappointed.
The Randy way. Yeah, exactly.
Well, Randy, thank you for flying in from Virginia and joining the show tonight. I appreciate it.
I appreciate you guys having me, man. This is fun for me. Where's the clue? It's about to get into the time when we don't come down off this mountain unless we have to.
Just be careful as winter out on your walks. I mean, you're up in the great. Well, it's not the great white north, but you're up in the the Blue Ridge Mountains there and you're I mean, you're, you're at the top of a mountain. It literally takes you 20 to 25 minutes just to get to civilization.
Well, to get down to go to civilization. Once we get down the mountain, we're 20 minutes from everywhere, but getting down.
I mean, when you get down the mountain, you've got a post office and a restaurant and a, and a tackle shop.
And then you got to go 20 minutes either way to get to Walmart. So, you know.
At least there's no Dollar General there, so that's good.
Dollar General is the closest grocery store to us. They've got a wonderful one. Sometimes, you know, with duty calls. Yeah, man, these will be some good pours to look forward to this winter, I think.
All right, folks. Well, you can find the bourbon road on all shows, social media outlets. You can find us on Instagram, Twitter, YouTube, TikTok, Facebook threads. But you know what? The place we really want you to join us up in that is at the bourbon road.com. That's where we've got the bourbon road bar. Um, you come to that website, the bourbon road.com. You can sign in, sign up, become a roadie. It's free. Get your own ID card. You get your own tasting journal where you can keep records of what you're tasting. You share those tasting notes out with other friends. You can also pop into our conversations there and share with share with everybody pictures of what you're drinking, what you're talking about, your great finds on the shelf. It's always a lot of fun. Todd is always running some kind of giveaway on there. He's giving away something right now. I think you haven't drawn on that yet. Have you done the first of each month? First of each month. So he's going to be drawing on what is it next month?
It is a Castle & Key single barrel that the Effective Bourbon Society chose. It's a nine-year weeded bourbon. Oh, wow.
Okay.
Well, come on in, folks. It doesn't cost anything to sign up to get on the pick for that. Come on in and check it out. You might be the winner that walks away with the bottle. So all of our distilleries are giving us bottles to share out as samples to our listeners. So definitely check out the bourbonroad.com. a time i get together every week on a wednesday we'll do an episode sometimes you know it's like a guest like randy no g from the early days of the bourbon road sometimes we got the distillery master distillers on All kinds of people, lots of fun. We hope you'll join us every single week. We're always laughing, we're always drinking whiskey, we're always having a good time. We'd love to have you with us every week. The best way to make sure you don't miss out on it is to scroll to the top of that app you're on, hit that subscribe button. That way you'll get that notification that Jim and Todd have dropped another episode You can put those headsets on and join us for another hour of whiskey bliss. So we'd love to have you with us every week. It's a lot of fun. But until the next time, we'll see you down.
Where the good times roll Passing bottles like a piece of soul Every pore's a memory, every sip a spark Lighten up the night in the Kentucky dark Yeah, we laugh too loud, let the worries go Find a little truth in the afterglow Ain't no man Just a ties-leaf song On the long winding bourbon road Here's to the nights that turned into dawn To the friends who stayed when the rest moved on To the clink of glass and the stories spun And the quiet peace when the night is done On a bourbon road we ain't alone Every mile's marked by the love we've known From barrel to bottle to the hearts we hold there's a fire that never gets old so pour it up let the moment slow a little bit of life in every glow yeah forever we'll call this home on the long winding
The Conversation