Skip to content
Episode 81 August 5, 2020 · 47:35
81. Post Quarantine - Old Fitz 9 year and Rhetoric 25 Year

81. Post Quarantine - Old Fitz 9 year and Rhetoric 25 Year

Mike's out of quarantine! Jim and Mike crack open Old Fitzgerald 9yr Spring 2020 and Orphan Barrel Rhetoric 25yr back at Jephthubin Farm.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Welcome back to The Bourbon Road! After a tough two weeks in quarantine following Vivian's COVID-19 diagnosis, Mike Hyatt is finally out of isolation and back at Jephthubin Farm in Shelbyville, Kentucky. Jim Shannon joins him in person to celebrate with two very special pours — a gracious gift from Bourbon Roadies moderator Adam Boothby, and a rare find from a local liquor store run on Mike's first day of freedom.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Old Fitzgerald Bottled in Bond 9 Year Spring 2020 Release (Heaven Hill): A wheated Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey bottled at 100 proof. The nose is delicate and floral — honeysuckle, butterscotch, a hint of apple, and subtle oak. On the palate it's rich and buttery with notes of honey, light citrus, and a touch of green apple. The finish lingers with warm cinnamon spice and barrel oak. Mash bill is wheat-forward as expected from Heaven Hill's Old Fitzgerald line, presented in the brand's iconic decanter-style bottle. (00:04:20)
  • Orphan Barrel Rhetoric 25 Year Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey (Diageo / Heaven Hill distillate): Bottled at 91 proof from a high-corn mash bill of 86% corn, 6% rye, and 8% malted barley, this is among the oldest commercially available American whiskeys on the market. The nose is bold and characterful — dusty butterscotch, baking spices, nutmeg, and aged oak with a funky, well-developed depth. The palate opens with butterscotch and baking spice but reveals surprising restraint in tannins and drying for its age. The finish is relatively short, fading gently rather than lingering. Retails around $140 but commands up to $600 on the secondary market. (00:26:31)

Jim and Mike also look back on the quarantine period — painting columns, building a workshop, staying stocked thanks to neighbors and friends — and look ahead to upcoming tastings, new merchandise, and continued growth of the Bourbon Roadies community. It's good to be back on the road.

If you'd like Jim and Mike to lead a bourbon tasting for your group — private gatherings up to 100 people — visit thebourbonroad.com to get in touch. And if you haven't already, please subscribe and leave a five-star review on iTunes to help the show keep the doors of distilleries open.

Full Transcript

Old Fitzgerald Heaven Hill bottled in bond wheated bourbon Orphan Barrel Rhetoric 25 Year bourbon tasting Kentucky bourbon Diageo Stitzel-Weller bourbon quarantine Jephthubin Farm Mike Hyatt Jim Shannon Bourbon Road podcast Bourbon Roadies Adam Boothby high corn mash bill aged bourbon bourbon review

The Conversation