Skip to content
Episode 120 December 16, 2020 · 52:00
120. Exploring Vintage Bourbons with Dusty Dan

120. Exploring Vintage Bourbons with Dusty Dan

Dusty Dan joins Jim & Mike to crack open a 1955 Old Crow, a 1963 Stitzel-Weller Very Old Fitzgerald, a 1969 Early Times & a 1985 Old Granddad 114.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Welcome back to The Bourbon Road! This week, Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt are joined by a very special returning guest — Dusty Dan from Dusty Dan's Whiskey Reviews on YouTube. Dan made his first appearance back on episode 10 during the blind bottle challenge, and he's back to take us deep into the world of dusty bourbons: those forgotten, often overlooked bottles that have been sitting on liquor store shelves, in estate sales, and in grandparents' cabinets for decades. The conversation covers everything from how to hunt for dusties and what to pay for them, to why the whiskey made decades ago tastes so fundamentally different from what rolls off the line today — from grain selection and fermentation to copper stills and non-chill filtration.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • 1955 Old Crow 4 Year (National Distillers): A bottled-in-bond dusty from National Distillers that Dan describes as absolutely captivating. Rich caramel sweetness hits the front of the palate like a caramel dip, followed by cinnamon and nutmeg baking spices in the mid-palate. The finish offers a long, warm butterscotch note with a gentle hug. Remarkably oily and viscous for its age, with no off-putting dusty notes whatsoever — a testament to what Old Crow once was. (00:04:41)
  • 1969 Early Times (86 Proof): A pleasant surprise for Jim and Mike, who cracked this bottle fresh on air. The nose leads with floral honeysuckle, butterscotch, and a faint mustiness typical of a well-preserved dusty. On the palate it's buttery and oily with a signature waxy mouthfeel, a sharp rice-forward spice, and a clean, lingering finish. Approachable and remarkably well-preserved for a bottle over 50 years old. (00:09:18)
  • 1985 Old Granddad 114 (Barrel Proof): This mini carries an intriguing "barrel proof" designation that sparks debate about what that label meant in 1985. The nose blooms with rich honey and honeysuckle florals. The palate is bold and full-bodied with chewy bitto honey sweetness on the front, a sharp spice surge mid-palate, and a pronounced Kentucky hug on the finish with a touch of pleasant bitterness. A dramatically more developed and layered expression than modern OGD 114. (00:27:16)
  • 1963 Very Old Fitzgerald 8 Year Bottled in Bond (Stitzel-Weller): Dan's Stitzel-Weller showcase bottle. Waxy and oily on the mouthfeel, but what sets it apart is the sheer boldness and depth of flavor. The characteristic Stitzel-Weller profile delivers pronounced complexity rather than the flat vanilla-and-caramel undertones sometimes found in lesser dusties. Dan notes the flavors coat the entire palate with remarkable presence for a bourbon of this vintage. (00:31:55)

Beyond the glass, Dan shares tips on where to find dusty bottles — estate sales, Facebook groups, and antique shops — and what to watch out for, including refilled decanters and corks that have given up the ghost. He also offers a generous giveaway for Bourbon Roadies: the first two listeners to post a review of his YouTube channel and screenshot it in the Bourbon Roadies Facebook group will receive samples of the 1963 Very Old Fitzgerald and a 1977 Old Taylor. Raise a glass to the hunt, and as Dan always says — stay dusty!

Full Transcript

dusty bourbon Dusty Dan Dusty Dan's Whiskey Reviews Old Crow Early Times Old Granddad 114 Very Old Fitzgerald Stitzel-Weller National Distillers bourbon hunting vintage whiskey bottled in bond barrel proof estate sale whiskey antique bourbon Kentucky vintage whiskey law non-chill filtered bourbon old bourbon history bourbon collecting The Bourbon Road podcast

The Conversation