Skip to content
Episode 120 December 16, 2020 · 52:00
120. Exploring Vintage Bourbons with Dusty Dan

120. Exploring Vintage Bourbons with Dusty Dan

Dusty Dan joins Jim & Mike to crack open a 1955 Old Crow, 1963 Very Old Fitzgerald, 1969 Early Times, and a 1985 Old Grand-Dad 114.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Welcome back to The Bourbon Road, where hosts Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt crack open some rare and fascinating bottles with a very special returning guest: Dusty Dan of Dusty Dan's Whiskey Reviews on YouTube. Dan is a Maryland-based dusty bourbon hunter who has built a growing channel dedicated to tracking down and reviewing vintage bottles — those wonderfully aged, often forgotten gems found at estate sales, antique shops, and tucked-away Facebook groups. It's a reunion episode full of nostalgia, great conversation, and some genuinely impressive liquid in the glasses.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • 1955 Old Crow (4 Year, National Distillers): A remarkable example of what Old Crow once was at its peak. This vintage bottling delivers a rich caramel sweetness on the front — think caramel dipping sauce for fruit — followed by cinnamon and nutmeg baking spices in the mid-palate. The finish offers a lingering butterscotch note that coats the palate with warmth, all supported by a notably oily, viscous mouthfeel. The fatty acids are still fully present and the balance between sweetness and spice is exceptional for its age. (00:03:55)
  • 1963 Very Old Fitzgerald (8 Year, Bottled in Bond, Stitzel-Weller): A Stitzel-Weller produced wheated bourbon that exemplifies the depth and complexity this legendary distillery was known for. Waxy and oily on the palate, with bold, well-pronounced flavors that go far beyond subtle undertones. The vanillas and caramels are not faint whispers but fully developed and present, coating the entire palate with richness and a level of complexity that sets it apart from most modern expressions. (00:31:29)
  • 1969 Early Times (86 Proof): A genuine surprise and a crowd-pleaser on the tasting mat. The nose opens with lovely floral notes and a sweet, inviting butterscotch character with just a hint of the classic dusty note. On the palate it delivers a buttery, oily mouthfeel that is characteristic of pre-1970s bourbon production, with a sharp rice spice mid-palate that adds brightness and definition. The finish has a slightly waxy quality that lingers pleasantly without drying out the mouth. A well-preserved bottle that holds up beautifully after more than five decades. (00:09:17)
  • 1985 Old Grand-Dad 114 (Barrel Proof, National Distillers): Bottled when National Distillers was still at the helm, this expression showcases the brand at a particularly acclaimed point in its history. The nose is a gorgeous combination of honeysuckle floral notes and rich, chewy Bitto honey sweetness. On the palate, it is full-bodied and bold, with a wave of front-loaded sweetness giving way to a pronounced rye spice and white pepper that builds toward the back of the palate. The finish delivers a hearty Kentucky hug alongside a touch of pleasant bitterness that adds complexity and length. It drinks as big and characterful as the proof suggests. (00:28:22)

From the first pour to the last sip, this episode is a masterclass in why dusty bourbon hunting has become such a passionate pursuit for so many enthusiasts. Whether you're a seasoned dusty hunter or just whiskey-curious, Dusty Dan's expertise and the quality of liquid in these glasses make a compelling case for seeking out these vintage treasures. Head over to Dusty Dan's Whiskey Reviews on YouTube and Instagram to follow his ongoing hunt, and keep an eye on the Bourbon Roadies Facebook group for details on the exclusive sample giveaway Dan generously offered to listeners of this episode.

Full Transcript

Bourbon Road Intro/Outro Dusty Dan Mike Hyatt Tasting Bottled in Bond Interview Bourbon Wheated Cask Strength Bottled in Bond Kentucky National Distillers dusty bourbon vintage bourbon Old Crow Very Old Fitzgerald Stitzel-Weller Early Times Old Grand-Dad 114 National Distillers Dusty Dan bourbon hunting estate sale whiskey wheated bourbon bottled in bond bourbon collecting antique whiskey bourbon tasting pre-prohibition style bourbon history rare bourbon bourbon road