Skip to content
Episode 92 September 9, 2020 · 01:09:00
92. Bourbon Basics with Four Great Pours

92. Bourbon Basics with Four Great Pours

Derby Day basics: Jim & Mike walk through bourbon fundamentals over Evan Williams BiB, Peerless, Maker's 46 Cask Strength, and E.H. Taylor Four Grain.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Welcome back to The Bourbon Road! It's Derby Day in Simpsonville, Kentucky, and hosts Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt are settling in to do something a little different — go back to basics. Whether you're brand new to bourbon or just looking for a refresher, this episode is your guided tour through the fundamentals: mash bills, sour mash vs. sweet mash, bottle-in-bond requirements, char levels, barrel proof vs. proofed-down, small batch definitions, and the difference between wheated and rye-forward bourbons. All of it grounded in real pours from four carefully chosen bottles.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Evan Williams Bottled in Bond White Label (100 proof): A DSP KY-1 release from Heaven Hill, this four-year-old sour mash bourbon delivers a sweet, corn-forward nose with caramel, toffee, and a hint of almond. At around $18, it serves as a textbook example of what bottle-in-bond guarantees: minimum four years age, 100 proof, single distilling season. Clean and approachable with a straightforward finish. (00:09:27)
  • Peerless Small Batch Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey (109.8 proof): A sweet mash, no-water-added barrel proof expression from the recently resurrected Peerless Distillery in Louisville, crafted by Master Distiller Caleb Kilburn. Approximately four to five years old, it opens with floral and burnt sugar notes — think cotton candy caramel — with black pepper and cinnamon spice on the mid-palate. A long, pleasurable finish with lingering sweetness and warmth. (00:18:47)
  • Maker's Mark 46 Cask Strength Limited Edition (109.6 proof): A wheated bourbon finished with specially selected inner stave profile #46, bottled at cask strength without proofing down. The nose is rich with floral sweetness, a touch of ethanol, and deep syrupy notes evocative of maple and burnt caramel. On the palate it delivers an immediate sweetness followed by a surprising spice kick, with chocolate, dark fruit, cherry, and almond on the mid to back palate. Leather and oak emerge as it opens in the glass, rounding out a long and layered finish. (00:33:35)
  • Colonel E.H. Taylor Four Grain Bottled in Bond (100 proof): A limited, highly sought-after release from Buffalo Trace, this bottle-in-bond bourbon uses a four-grain mash bill of corn, rye, wheat, and malted barley. The nose is elegant — caramel waffles, confectioners sugar, a whisper of mint, and warm barrel spice. The palate is soft up front with gentle sweetness from the wheat, building through barrel spice and rye into a finish that evokes bourbon balls and a pleasant powdery sweetness. A layered and complex pour. (00:51:56)

Jim and Mike close out the episode with practical advice for newcomers: build a relationship with your local liquor store, explore bourbon bars before committing to bottles, and never leave your bourbon in a hot car on a Kentucky summer day. The Bourbon Roadies private Facebook group gets a shoutout as a welcoming, no-snobbery community for anyone at any stage of their bourbon journey. Now go find your bourbon road — and enjoy every mile of it.

Full Transcript

bourbon basics Evan Williams Bottled in Bond Peerless Distillery Peerless Small Batch Maker's Mark 46 Maker's Mark Cask Strength E.H. Taylor Four Grain Colonel E.H. Taylor bottle in bond wheated bourbon sour mash sweet mash mash bill barrel proof high rye bourbon Heaven Hill Buffalo Trace Kentucky bourbon bourbon for beginners bourbon tasting notes