Skip to content
Episode 92 September 9, 2020 · 01:09:00
92. Bourbon Basics with Four Great Pours

92. Bourbon Basics with Four Great Pours

Derby Day basics: Jim & Mike pour Evan Williams BIB, Peerless Small Batch, Maker's 46 Cask Strength, and a rare E.H. Taylor Four Grain to school you on bourbon fundamentals.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Welcome back to The Bourbon Road! Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt are recording on a very special day — Kentucky Derby Day — from Jim's basement in Simpsonville, Kentucky. With no fans in the stands at Churchill Downs this year, the guys settle in with four carefully chosen bottles to walk new and curious bourbon lovers through the fundamentals of what makes bourbon bourbon. From mash bills and sour mash versus sweet mash, to bottled in bond regulations, barrel char levels, cask strength, and the difference between wheated and high-rye expressions, this episode is a friendly and approachable primer on the spirit they love most.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Evan Williams Bottled in Bond White Label (100 Proof): A classic Heaven Hill expression and an excellent entry point for new bourbon drinkers. At around $18 a bottle, this 100-proof, minimum four-year-old bottled-in-bond bourbon carries the historic DSP KY-1 designation on the front label. Corn is front and center on both the nose and palate, with notes of caramel, toffee, and a touch of almond — hallmarks of the Heaven Hill distillery character. A reliable, consistent pour that exemplifies what a well-made, affordable sour mash bourbon can deliver. (00:09:56)
  • Peerless Small Batch Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey (109.8 Proof): Crafted by Master Distiller Caleb Kilburn at the resurrected Kentucky Peerless Distilling Company in Louisville, this cask-strength small batch is a sweet mash bourbon — meaning every fermentation batch starts clean with no backset carried over. No water is added before bottling. The nose opens with floral notes, burnt sugar, and a cotton-candy sweetness reminiscent of carnival fare. On the palate, black pepper and cinnamon spice take the lead, with a Jolly Rancher-like sweetness underneath. The finish is long and warming, with lingering spice and sweetness — and notably absent is the pronounced "Kentucky hug" often associated with sour mash expressions. (00:18:42)
  • Maker's Mark 46 Cask Strength Limited Edition (109.6 Proof): A special and highly anticipated limited release from the iconic Loretto, Kentucky distillery, this wheated cask-strength bourbon lands at 109.6 proof straight from the batch with no proofing water added. The secondary grain is wheat rather than rye, lending the classic Maker's sweetness, while the seared French oak stave profile (Stave Profile No. 46) adds additional complexity. The nose carries a notable alcohol presence alongside floral and maple syrup notes. The palate opens with a soft wheated sweetness up front before transitioning to a surprisingly bold spice on the back end — dark fruit, chocolate-covered cherries, and a touch of almond round out the mid-palate, with leather and oak emerging as the pour opens up. A long, layered finish makes this one of the standout pours of the session. (00:33:39)
  • Colonel E.H. Taylor Four Grain Bottled in Bond (100 Proof): A rare and highly sought-after limited release from Buffalo Trace Distillery, this bottled-in-bond expression features a four-grain mash bill of corn, rye, wheat, and malted barley — a nod to old-world grain complexity. At 100 proof, it is approachable yet deeply layered. The nose is elegant and restrained, with caramel, Belgian waffle, confectioners' sugar, and a surprising whisper of fresh mint. On the palate, a soft wheated sweetness greets the front of the tongue before the characteristic E.H. Taylor barrel spice takes over — think bourbon balls from Rebecca Ruth Candies in Frankfort, Kentucky, with a dusting of powdered sugar. The finish carries a pleasant, dry tannic quality. Secondary market pricing has reached $600–$700 a bottle, reflecting its legendary status. (00:51:21)

Whether you're brand new to bourbon or simply want a refresher on the language and lore of America's native spirit, this Derby Day session is a warm and welcoming tour through some of the key concepts every bourbon lover should know. Raise a glass — just maybe skip the mint julep.

Full Transcript

bourbon basics Evan Williams Bottled in Bond Kentucky Peerless Distilling Peerless Small Batch Maker's Mark 46 Cask Strength Colonel E.H. Taylor Four Grain Buffalo Trace Distillery Heaven Hill wheated bourbon sour mash sweet mash bottled in bond mash bill cask strength barrel char bourbon education Kentucky Derby small batch bourbon high rye bourbon bourbon for beginners

The Conversation