Skip to content
Episode 140 February 24, 2021 · 43:51
140. Old Soul 15 Year and Some Good Times Honey

140. Old Soul 15 Year and Some Good Times Honey

Jim & Mike taste Cathead Old Soul 15yr bourbon & Good Times 'Mo Honey Ali' 120-proof honey-finished MGP wheater fireside.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt settle in by the fire at Jeff the Bin Farm on a frigid, icy Kentucky weekend for a long-form episode full of great sipping and great conversation. With Woodrow the podcast dog snoozing nearby, the guys dig into two genuinely unique whiskeys — one a mystery-mash-bill 15-year-old bourbon from a Mississippi blues distillery, the other a cask-strength honey-finished wheater that arrives courtesy of a scrappy local startup. Along the way they trace the origins of a strange mash bill that keeps turning up on bottles from multiple brands, tell the tale of Robert Leroy Johnson selling his soul at the crossroads, and preview some big upcoming guests and Louisville dinner plans.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Cathead Distillery Old Soul 15 Year Bourbon (2020 Rare & Limited Release): A 102-proof, 15-year-old bourbon bottled by Cathead Distillery of Jackson, Mississippi, carrying a distinctive mash bill of 78.5% corn, 13% rye, and 8.5% malted barley — the same spec that shows up across several brands including Three Chord and Chicken Cock. Deep amber in color with a wine-style bottle, the nose opens with tobacco, Copenhagen-like snuff notes, dark floral roses, and a touch of sourness. On the palate it delivers a buttery, dry, barrel-forward experience with zero corn sweetness, dark fruit, barrel spice, and a medium finish with a warming hug. Entered the barrel at 125 proof and bottled at 102. Available at Total Wine for approximately $129. (00:01:54)
  • Good Times Spirits "Mo Honey Ali" MGP Wheated Bourbon Finished in Honey Barrels: A single-barrel pick bottled at a commanding 120 proof by Louisville-area startup Good Times Spirits, sourced as an MGP wheated bourbon and finished in honey barrels — the 13th barrel the company has released. Approximately four to five years old and limited to roughly 180–200 bottles, this expression retails on the secondary market around $200. The nose leads with a young wood and floral honeysuckle character, with evident honey sweetness cutting through the high proof. The palate is immediately and unmistakably sweet — honeycomb, honey cereals, and a creamy, viscous texture — followed by a mid-palate barrel spice and a ginger snap finish that lingers. The proof is very present and the finish is long, making it an ideal after-dinner sipper. Bottled and labeled with black-and-white double-dip wax. (00:20:22)

Two very different whiskeys anchor this cozy fireside session — a dignified, dry, old-soul bourbon that rewards patient sippers and a bold, sweet, high-octane honey-finished wheater that announces itself from the first sip. The guys wrap up with a preview of coming episodes featuring Heaven Hill's Bernie Lubbers and the Lux Row father-and-sons team from Angel's Envy, plus a tease of their upcoming night out on Louisville's Whiskey Row.

Full Transcript

Intro/Music Mike Hyatt Tasting Bourbon Wheated Finished Kentucky Cathead Distillery Heaven Hill Angel's Envy MGP Cathead Distillery Old Soul Bourbon 15 year bourbon Jackson Mississippi bourbon mystery mash bill MGP wheated bourbon Good Times Spirits Mo Honey Ali honey barrel finished bourbon cask strength bourbon wheated bourbon bourbon finish high proof bourbon three chord bourbon chicken cock bourbon St Cloud bourbon bourbon road podcast Kentucky bourbon Mike Hyatt Jim Shannon