Skip to content
Episode 184 July 28, 2021 · 01:19:45
184. Pappy Gate - Netflix's Heist - Bourbon King

184. Pappy Gate - Netflix's Heist - Bourbon King

Jim, Mike, Rob Carter & Matt Simons sip Eagle Rare 10 & Russell's Reserve 10 on Rob's back porch while breaking down Netflix's Pappygate documentary.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt take The Bourbon Road outside for the first time, recording live from the newly refurbished back porch of roadie Rob Carter in Shelbyville, Kentucky. Joined by returning guest Matt Simons, the four settle in with cigars and glasses in hand for a deep-dive conversation inspired by the Netflix series Heist — specifically the two-part episode "The Bourbon King" — which chronicles the now-infamous Pappygate scandal. The discussion covers the theft of Pappy Van Winkle bottles and whole barrels of Wild Turkey from Buffalo Trace and Wild Turkey distilleries, the culture of employee perks historically embedded in the bourbon industry, the ethics of theft (no matter how glamorous the product), and what this story means for the broader bourbon boom. Expect honest, unscripted reflection from four guys who love bourbon, know the industry, and aren't afraid to hold themselves to the same moral standard they apply to anyone else.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Eagle Rare 10 Year Single Barrel Bourbon: A Buffalo Trace Distillery expression bottled at 90 proof with a mash bill heavy in corn. This 10-year-old Kentucky straight bourbon pours a rich amber and delivers aromas of oak, vanilla, and a subtle smokiness. On the palate, tasters noted a sweet entry, a moderate spice mid-palate, and a long, drying, oaky finish with a pleasantly smoky character that lingers. At roughly $36 at retail in Kentucky, the group agreed it represents exceptional value and remains a benchmark accessible bourbon when you can find it. (00:04:15)
  • Russell's Reserve 10 Year Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey: Produced at Wild Turkey Distillery in Lawrenceburg, Kentucky, and bottled at 90 proof, this expression carries a high-corn, low-rye Wild Turkey mash bill aged a full decade. The nose opens with maple syrup, toffee, and a warm sweetness reminiscent of pancake syrup. The palate follows through with ripe fruit — one taster's wife describes it as "cherry juice" — and a smooth, sweet finish with just enough nose effervescence to remind you of the proof. Picked up at Paradise Spirits and Wine for $36.55, it was praised as a go-to bottle that is still widely available and consistently rewarding. (00:31:50)

Four friends on a covered patio, cigars burning, fans humming — this is The Bourbon Road at its most relaxed and most honest. Whether you have seen the Netflix episodes or not, Rob and Matt bring fresh perspectives that push Jim and Mike to examine not just what happened in Frankfurt, Kentucky, but why it happened, who it hurt, and what grace looks like when good people make bad decisions. Stick around for tasting notes on the bottles that tie directly to the two distilleries at the center of Pappygate, and keep your ears open for details on the Bourbon Road blending contest — entries are closing fast.

Full Transcript

Intro/Outro voiceover Rob Carter Mike Hyatt Matt Simons Tasting Interview Bourbon Single Barrel Kentucky Buffalo Trace Distillery Wild Turkey Distillery Buffalo Trace Wild Turkey Eagle Rare 10 Year Russell's Reserve 10 Year Buffalo Trace Distillery Wild Turkey Distillery Pappygate Pappy Van Winkle Bourbon King Netflix Heist Netflix Toby Kurtsinger bourbon theft bourbon heist Kentucky bourbon bourbon tasting bourbon podcast Sazerac Jimmy Russell bourbon culture craft bourbon bourbon ethics bourbon history