Skip to content
Episode 184 July 28, 2021 · 01:19:45
184. Pappy Gate - Netflix's Heist - Bourbon King

184. Pappy Gate - Netflix's Heist - Bourbon King

Pappygate on the porch: Jim & Mike crack Eagle Rare 10 and Russell's Reserve 10 with Rob Carter & Matt Simons to unpack the Netflix *Heist* bourbon king story.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt take the show on the road — literally — recording Episode 184 from the newly built covered patio of longtime roadie Rob Carter's home in Shelbyville, Kentucky. Joined by returning guest Matt Simons, the foursome settles into Rob's backyard retreat, cigars in hand, to dig into one of bourbon's most talked-about scandals: the Netflix documentary Heist, specifically the two-part segment dubbed "The Bourbon King," which chronicles the so-called Pappygate theft at Buffalo Trace and, as many listeners may not have known, a simultaneous barrel theft at Wild Turkey. The conversation is candid, thoughtful, and occasionally philosophical — four guys who love bourbon reckoning honestly with questions of temptation, workplace culture, moral gray areas, and the difference between taking a nip and backing a truck up to the loading dock.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Eagle Rare 10 Year Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey: Produced at Buffalo Trace Distillery in Frankfort, Kentucky, this 90-proof, 10-year-old single-barrel bourbon is one of the most celebrated values in American whiskey. The guys find it consistently rewarding — oaky and a little smoky upfront, with a sweetness that opens into toffee and a pleasantly drying, spice-laced finish that lingers well. Rob notes a reliably detectable smokiness he always associates with this label, while Jim highlights its long, satisfying finish as the hallmark of its quality. At around $36 a bottle when you can find it, the table is unanimous that it punches well above its price. (00:04:15)
  • Russell's Reserve 10 Year Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey: Distilled at Wild Turkey Distillery in Lawrenceburg, Kentucky and bottled at 90 proof, this expression carries the Russell family name and a decade of maturation. On the nose it opens with maple syrup and pancake sweetness, leading into a palate that Mike's wife describes as cherry juice and that Matt characterizes as toffee and maple. It finishes clean with a gentle effervescent nose lift when sipped neat, making it approachable for newcomers while still rewarding for seasoned drinkers. Picked up at Paradise Spirits and Wine for $36.55, it earns easy praise as a 10-year bourbon at an honest price. (00:31:42)

The episode wraps with a spirited conversation about the bourbon boom, allocation culture, and whether the Netflix spotlight will drive even more curiosity — and demand — for Kentucky whiskey. The group also teases upcoming reviews of the Woodford Reserve Batch Proof 128.3, Wild Turkey 17 Year Bottled in Bond, Elmer T. Lee, and Buzzard's Roost Toasted Rye, plus details on the active bourbon blending contest open to roadies everywhere. As always, the crew keeps it real, keeps it respectful, and keeps the glasses full.

Full Transcript

Eagle Rare 10 Year Russell's Reserve 10 Year Buffalo Trace Wild Turkey Pappygate Netflix Heist documentary Toby Kurtsinger bourbon theft bourbon scandal Jimmy Russell Sazerac bourbon blending contest Kentucky bourbon Shelbyville Kentucky barrel theft bourbon allocation craft bourbon straight bourbon whiskey bourbon tasting Jim Shannon

The Conversation