Skip to content
Episode 291 August 3, 2022 · 56:20
291. Bourbon Highball Challenge

291. Bourbon Highball Challenge

Jim & Mike pour six bourbons — Rebel, Maker's, Larceny, Four Roses, Very Old Barton 100, and Wild Turkey 101 — into ginger ale to crown the ultimate highball.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt are back behind the bar — literally. Mike sets up shop in Studio 1A, the basement bourbon bar, for a laid-back summer tasting session that swaps the Glencairn for a red Solo cup and asks one simple question: which bourbon makes the best ginger ale highball? Six bottles spanning 80 to 101 proof, three different ginger ales, and two co-hosts with strong opinions make for one of the most approachable and genuinely fun episodes The Bourbon Road has produced. Whether you're a neat-only purist or a lifelong highball drinker, this one's worth your time.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Rebel Bourbon (80 Proof): A wheated bourbon from Heaven Hill's Rebel brand, bottled at 80 proof. Soft and approachable on its own, with gentle vanilla and caramel notes typical of a wheat-forward mash bill. Paired here with Seagram's Ginger Ale. (00:05:07)
  • Maker's Mark (90 Proof): The iconic red-wax-dipped wheated Kentucky Straight Bourbon from Loretto, bottled at 90 proof. Classic caramel, vanilla, and soft wheat sweetness define this universally available expression. Paired with Seagram's Ginger Ale. (00:09:59)
  • Larceny Small Batch (92 Proof): Heaven Hill's wheated bourbon bottled at 92 proof, known for its reputation as a capable mixer. Richer and fuller than the two preceding wheaters, with a warm, honeyed wheat character. Paired with Schweppes Ginger Ale. (00:16:02)
  • Four Roses Yellow Label (80 Proof): The entry-level expression from Four Roses Distillery in Lawrenceburg, Kentucky, bottled at 80 proof. A blend of Four Roses' proprietary yeast strains delivers floral, fruity, and lightly spiced notes, though the proof keeps it restrained. Paired with Schweppes Ginger Ale. (00:37:26)
  • Very Old Barton 100 Proof: A high-rye-leaning Kentucky Straight Bourbon from the Barton 1792 Distillery in Bardstown, a Sazerac property, bottled at 100 proof. Bold, spicy, and assertive with notes of black pepper, oak, and dried fruit. Paired with Canada Dry Ginger Ale. (00:44:26)
  • Wild Turkey 101 (101 Proof): The flagship expression from Wild Turkey Distillery in Lawrenceburg, Kentucky, bottled at 101 proof. Rich and full-bodied with notes of vanilla, toasted oak, citrus rind, and a characteristic sweetness that distinguishes it from high-rye competitors. Paired with Canada Dry Ginger Ale. (00:50:52)

Beyond the tasting, Jim and Mike catch up on bourbon industry news — including Jacob Call's departure from Green River Distillery, Jackie Zykan's exciting new venture called Head Barn alongside Royce Neely and the 5280 Whiskey Society crew, and a breakdown of the Barton 1792 Distillery's recent closure to public tours. They also preview their upcoming appearances at the Southern Whiskey Society event in Franklin, Tennessee on August 6th, the Kentucky Bourbon Festival in Bardstown in September, and Bourbon on the Banks in Frankfort, Kentucky on October 1st — where The Bourbon Road Lounge returns bigger than ever. Seldom Seen Farms maple syrup, beef jerky experiments, and the fine art of hydrating while drinking round out a warm, wide-ranging conversation between two friends who clearly love what they do.

Full Transcript

bourbon highball ginger ale bourbon Wild Turkey 101 Very Old Barton Larceny bourbon Maker's Mark Rebel bourbon Four Roses wheated bourbon high rye bourbon bourbon cocktail Kentucky bourbon Barton 1792 Heaven Hill bourbon mixer Jim Shannon Mike Hyatt The Bourbon Road Southern Whiskey Society Kentucky Bourbon Festival

The Conversation