Skip to content
Episode 291 August 3, 2022 · 56:20
291. Bourbon Highball Challenge

291. Bourbon Highball Challenge

Jim & Mike run 6 bourbons — Rebel, Maker's Mark, Larceny, Four Roses, Very Old Barton 100, and Wild Turkey 101 — through a ginger ale highball challenge.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Welcome back to The Bourbon Road, where Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt pull up a stool at the bourbon bar and get hands-on with six accessible bottles to find out which bourbon makes the best ginger ale highball. Mixing things up from their fan-favorite Coke challenge episode, the guys stock the bar with three wheated bourbons and three rye-forward bourbons, ranging from 80 to 101 proof, and work through each one in a red Solo cup with four ounces of ginger ale and an ounce of bourbon over ice.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Rebel Bourbon (80 Proof): A wheated bourbon at entry-level proof from Heaven Hill. Light and approachable on the palate, with the wheat-forward softness sitting quietly behind the carbonation of Seagram's ginger ale. A gentle, easy-drinking pour that lets the ginger take the wheel. (00:05:07)
  • Maker's Mark (90 Proof): The iconic red-wax wheated bourbon from Loretto, Kentucky, now mixed with Seagram's ginger ale. At 90 proof, the spirit begins to assert itself just a touch more than the Rebel, offering a slightly fuller presence in the glass with that recognizable soft wheat sweetness. (00:09:59)
  • Larceny (92 Proof): Heaven Hill's wheated bourbon steps up in proof and pairs here with Schweppes ginger ale. The extra proof and the slightly sweeter, less spicy character of the Schweppes allow the bourbon to show up with a richer color and a more noticeable whiskey presence. A bottle long recognized as a capable mixer. (00:16:02)
  • Four Roses Yellow Label (80 Proof): The approachable entry-level expression from Four Roses Distillery in Lawrenceburg, Kentucky, blended from multiple mashbills and yeast strains for a floral, lightly spiced profile. At 80 proof, mixed with Schweppes ginger ale, the spirit struggles to push through the carbonation and ginger spice. (00:26:26)
  • Very Old Barton 100 Proof: A Sazerac product distilled at Barton 1792 Distillery in Bardstown, Kentucky, this rye-forward bourbon brings a noticeable kick at 100 proof. Mixed with Canada Dry ginger ale, the spirit's spice and warmth shine through in a way that earlier, lower-proof pours could not manage. A well-priced bottle that punches well above its weight class in a highball setting. (00:37:26)
  • Wild Turkey 101 (101 Proof): The flagship expression from Wild Turkey Distillery in Lawrenceburg, Kentucky. At 101 proof and with a slightly sweeter character than the Barton, this rye-grain bourbon paired with Canada Dry ginger ale delivers a balanced, full-flavored highball with warmth, sweetness, and just enough spice to keep things interesting all the way to the bottom of the cup. (00:42:52)

Along the way, Jim and Mike swap stories from recent bourbon events, preview their upcoming appearances at the Southern Whiskey Society in Franklin, Tennessee, the Kentucky Bourbon Festival in Bardstown, and the Bourbon on the Banks festival in Frankfort where the Bourbon Road Lounge returns bigger than ever. They also catch listeners up on whiskey industry news, including master distiller changes and the formation of a new venture called Hidden Barn. Whether you take your bourbon neat or in a tall glass over ice, this episode is a reminder that great bourbon should be enjoyed however you damn well please.

Full Transcript

Ad read/intro Mike Hyatt Unknown Tasting Interview Bourbon Wheated Kentucky Tennessee Four Roses Distillery Wild Turkey Distillery Heaven Hill Wild Turkey Four Roses bourbon highball ginger ale bourbon Wild Turkey 101 Maker's Mark Larceny bourbon Rebel bourbon Very Old Barton Four Roses wheated bourbon rye bourbon Barton 1792 distillery Heaven Hill bourbon cocktails bourbon mixers Kentucky bourbon festival Southern Whiskey Society Hidden Barn whiskey Jackie Zykan bourbon proof bourbon tasting