Skip to content
Episode 307 September 28, 2022 · 50:17
307. Bourbon With Seldom Seen Farms

307. Bourbon With Seldom Seen Farms

Kevin Holly of Seldom Seen Farm joins Mike to talk bourbon-barrel-aged maple syrup, 5,000 maple trees, and a fall cocktail built on New Riff Red Turkey Wheat.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Mike Hyatt (Big Chief) flies solo this week on The Bourbon Road, welcoming a very special guest who has been teased on the show for years — Kevin Holly of Seldom Seen Farm in Mountainville, Ohio. Kevin's bourbon-barrel-aged maple syrup has been a staple recommendation on the podcast, and this episode finally brings him to the microphone to tell the full story: from buying a 60-acre farm for a terminally ill horse named Seldom Seen, to tapping nearly 5,000 maple trees through miles of tubing, to aging syrup in spent bourbon barrels and shipping product to distilleries across the country. It is a story of sweat equity, small-farm resilience, and the surprisingly deep connection between the maple and bourbon industries.

Mike sips on the New Riff Red Turkey Wheat Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey — a bottled-in-bond, 100-proof wheated bourbon built on an heirloom grain dating to the 1870s — while Kevin pours a New Riff Single Barrel (Barrel #8202, 103 proof, four-year minimum age). The conversation covers Kevin's timber-frame sugar house, the science of sap collection, the angel's share of maple syrup, and Kevin's growing roster of distillery partners including New Riff, Leapers Fork, Treaty Oak, and Bard Distillery. Mike also mixes up a fall cocktail — the Cozy Maple Pumpkin Bourbon Cocktail with Apple Cider — showcasing just how versatile Seldom Seen's barrel-aged syrup can be beyond the old-fashioned.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • New Riff Red Turkey Wheat Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey: Bottled-in-bond at 100 proof with a mash bill of 70% corn, 25% heirloom Red Turkey wheat, and 5% malted barley, aged a minimum of five years. A rare bottled-in-bond wheated bourbon built around an heirloom grain prized by artisan bakers and distillers alike for its expressive, slightly rustic flavor profile. (00:04:30)
  • New Riff Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey (Barrel #8202): A single-barrel selection at 103 proof, aged a minimum of four years. Poured by guest Kevin Holly, this barrel-strength expression showcases New Riff's signature bold character at a hair above triple digits. (00:05:20)

Seldom Seen Farm's bourbon-barrel-aged maple syrup makes a starring appearance in Mike's original fall cocktail — the Cozy Maple Pumpkin Bourbon Cocktail with Apple Cider — combining New Riff Red Turkey Wheat bourbon, orange bitters, pumpkin purée, pumpkin spice, apple cider, and a cane-sugar-rimmed rocks glass. Listeners can find Kevin Holly and all of Seldom Seen Farm's products — including bourbon-barrel-aged coffee, bourbon barbecue sauce, maple sugar, and maple cotton candy — at seldomseenmaple.com, and in person at the New Riff gift shop and at Bourbon on the Banks in Frankfort, Kentucky.

Full Transcript

Mike Hyatt Unknown Announcer Kevin Holly Tasting Bottled in Bond Interview Bourbon Wheated Bottled in Bond Single Barrel Kentucky Ohio Bard Distillery New Riff Seldom Seen Farm Kevin Holly New Riff Distilling Red Turkey Wheat bourbon bottled in bond bourbon barrel aged maple syrup wheated bourbon single barrel bourbon maple syrup Bourbon on the Banks Leapers Fork Distillery Treaty Oak Distilling Bard Distillery Garrison Brothers old fashioned cocktail fall bourbon cocktail craft maple syrup Ohio farming bourbon cocktail recipe heirloom grain whiskey