Skip to content
Episode 336 March 8, 2023 · 59:32
336. Distillery 291 with Michael Myers

336. Distillery 291 with Michael Myers

Michael Myers of 291 Distillery returns with four pours including the debut All Rye and a jaw-dropping 142-proof unreleased single malt.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon welcomes back Michael Myers, founder of 291 Distillery in Colorado Springs, for a deep dive into some of the most distinctive craft whiskeys coming out of the American West. Michael last appeared on the show back in episode 25, and a lot has changed — the distillery has grown from a 300-square-foot operation with a hand-built copper still to a 26,000-square-foot facility capable of producing 600 gallons a week. The conversation covers Michael's remarkable origin story: a fashion and beauty photographer living three blocks from the World Trade Center on 9/11, who eventually found his way to Colorado Springs and taught himself distillation from scratch, building his first still from copper photogravure plates.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • 291 Colorado Bourbon Whiskey Single Barrel Barrel Proof (126.1 proof): An 80% corn, 19% malt rye, 1% malt barley mash bill — the very first recipe Michael ever developed. Aged in Barrel Mill barrels and finished on toasted aspen wood staves, this barrel-proof expression pours a deep mahogany. The nose offers caramel and rye spice without being aggressive at over 125 proof. On the palate it opens with a rich, almost molasses-like sweetness before a firm wave of rye pepper takes over the back half. The finish is long, tannic in a pleasing way, and dry enough that Michael himself calls it a natural fit for a Black Manhattan with Averna. (00:03:21)
  • 291 Colorado Whiskey Single Barrel Barrel Proof (129.1 proof): A 61% malt rye, 39% corn mash bill that Michael considers his signature expression — the whiskey he set out to make when he founded 291. Finished on toasted aspen staves, it pours slightly lighter than the bourbon but still shows rich color. The nose is more floral and a touch less sweet than the bourbon. The palate delivers a candy-bright sweetness up front that gives way to stone fruit, a whisper of anise, and an earthy character that speaks directly to the malted rye grain bill. Viscous, sticking to the sides and back of the palate with a long peppery finish. Michael describes it as a bourbon drinker's rye. (00:20:48)
  • 291 All Rye Batch 1 (132.6 proof, 1,303 bottles): A brand-new label and one of the most talked-about bottles of the evening. Made from a marriage of two separately aged 100% malt rye whiskeys — one using Rootshoot malt from Colorado and the other using Weyermann malt from Germany — each matured in Barrel Mill barrels and finished on aspen staves before blending. Despite sitting above 130 proof, this whiskey is startlingly smooth and creamy, with a buttery nose, a silky mouthfeel, and a distinct note of orange on the mid-palate. The spice that defines most 291 expressions is dialed back here in favor of balance and grain sweetness. A limited release, available primarily in Colorado and Texas, with some inventory through Seelbach's. (00:32:33)
  • 291 Single Malt Experimental (142.8 proof, unproofed sample, ~4 years 9 months old): An unreleased experimental batch distilled roughly five years prior and aged in small barrels. A portion of the single malt barrels were previously blended with wheat whiskey for an earlier E-batch release; these eight remaining barrels were recently rediscovered, with one having lost water rather than alcohol in the Colorado climate and proofing out at a staggering 153 proof. Married together and sampled here at natural barrel proof, this whiskey defies its hazmat-level strength with a remarkably light and refined character. The nose is gentle and inviting. On the palate, golden raisin and aged tobacco leaf emerge with a dry, elegant finish. Anticipated for release in fall 2023 after competition submissions. (00:46:58)

On the Tasting Mat this episode reads like a master class in what mountain-climate aging and aspen wood finishing can do to carefully crafted grain bills. Michael Myers is a storyteller as much as a distiller, and his passion for making a whiskey that is distinctly Western — rugged, refined, and rebellious — comes through in every pour. Whether you are a longtime 291 fan or just discovering the brand, this episode is a compelling argument for seeking out everything this Colorado Springs distillery is producing. Be sure to check out 291 Distillery at distillery291.com or on Instagram and social media at @distillery291, and plan a visit if your travels take you through Colorado Springs.

Full Transcript

Michael Myers Tasting Interview Craft Distillery Visit Bourbon Rye Wheated Single Malt Cask Strength Single Barrel Colorado Texas 291 Distillery Michael Myers Colorado whiskey craft bourbon single barrel bourbon barrel proof bourbon malt rye whiskey single malt whiskey aspen wood finish Colorado Springs distillery high proof whiskey craft distillery American rye whiskey western whiskey Rootshoot malt Weyermann malt experimental whiskey black Manhattan Bourbon Road podcast Jim Shannon