Skip to content
Episode 401 July 11, 2024 · 01:09:06
401. Distillery 291 - Good Guy, Bad Guy and Experimental Whiskeys

401. Distillery 291 - Good Guy, Bad Guy and Experimental Whiskeys

Jim Shannon visits Distillery 291's Michael Myers in Colorado Springs to taste Bad Guy, Good Guy, and two rare E-Series Kentucky-barrel-finished whiskeys.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon heads west to Colorado Springs for a return visit with Michael Myers, founding distiller and CEO of Distillery 291, recording inside the distillery's barrel room. The two old friends catch up on the evolution of Colorado's craft whiskey scene, the role of malted grains and Aspen staves in 291's unmistakable house style, and what it means to blaze your own trail as a self-taught distiller. Michael shares the origin stories behind Bad Guy and Good Guy, walks through his experimental E-Series philosophy, and explains how the high-altitude, arid Colorado climate conspires with his custom-fabricated pot stills to produce whiskeys of uncommon concentration and depth — all in a fraction of the time it might take elsewhere.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • 291 Bad Guy Colorado Whisky: A four-grain weeded bourbon-style whiskey at 120.6 proof, built from 59% corn, 29% malted wheat, 9% malted rye, and 3% malted barley, aged approximately two and a half years. Rich and syrupy on the nose with a heavy sweetness and a bold, coating mouthfeel; the wheat grain softens the entry while the barrel delivers a long, warm chest-hugging finish. (00:24:07)
  • 291 Good Guy Colorado Rye Whisky: A first-of-its-kind four-grain weeded rye at 123.2 proof, mirroring the Bad Guy recipe but with the grains inverted — 59% malted rye, 29% wheat, 9% corn, and 3% malted barley. Spicy and floral on the nose with a punchy, buttery rye-muffin palate leaning toward dark rye bread; tropical notes of mango and pineapple emerge from the white dog character beneath. Limited to approximately one thousand bottles across two batches. (00:25:57)
  • 291 E14 Colorado Rye Whisky Finished in Kentucky Rye Barrels: The flagship 61% malted rye / 39% corn rye harvested at barrel proof, then finished for three and a half years in used Kentucky rye barrels with periodic water additions, bottled at 134.1 proof. Concentrated and surprisingly soft on the palate with pronounced oak influence, a traditional bourbon-adjacent sweetness on the nose, and a texture reminiscent of a much older whiskey; drinks with the depth and maturity of a seven-plus-year expression. (00:41:31)
  • 291 E15 Colorado Bourbon Whisky Finished in Kentucky Bourbon Barrels: The flagship 80% corn / 19% malted rye / 1% malted barley bourbon finished in used Kentucky bourbon barrels, bottled at 129.2 proof. More subdued on the nose than E14, with a distinctive sassafras and root beer character; the secondary bourbon barrel lends a softening sweetness that rounds and quiets the usual 291 boldness into something subtle and approachable for the proof. (00:54:51)

Michael and Jim also reflect on the broader craft whiskey landscape — the geographic regionalization taking hold across American craft distilling, the growing prestige of malted-grain whiskeys, the outsized role of Colorado's arid climate on evaporation and concentration, and what it takes to keep experimenting after thirteen years. If you've never made it to Colorado Springs, Michael makes a compelling case: tour the distillery, grab a cocktail at the tasting room, and pair it with a hike through Bear Creek before settling in at the Broadmoor for a nightcap. Cheers.

Full Transcript

Distillery 291 Michael Myers Colorado whiskey craft bourbon malted rye weeded bourbon weeded rye Bad Guy whiskey Good Guy whiskey E-Series whiskey experimental whiskey Colorado Springs distillery high altitude aging Aspen stave barrel finishing four-grain mash bill American single malt all rye whiskey craft distilling bourbon road podcast

The Conversation