Skip to content
Episode 352 June 28, 2023 · 57:16
352. The Brian and Tyler Show

352. The Brian and Tyler Show

Brian Hyatt & Tyler Wilson sip Knob Creek 12, Yellowstone 115-proof, John J. Bowman Single Barrel, Old Forester Whiskey Row Fire, and a rare Heaven Hill Bottled-in-Bond 6 Year.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Brian Hyatt takes the helm solo this week on The Bourbon Road, joined by returning friend Tyler Wilson (The Digital Whiz Kid) while host Jim Shannon recovers from knee replacement surgery. The two settle into their home bars for a relaxed evening of pouring, nosing, and sipping through a varied lineup that spans everything from a reliable shelf staple to a genuinely rare piece of bourbon history.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Knob Creek 12 Year: A 100-proof, 12-year-old small batch bourbon from Beam Suntory. Tyler noses vanilla and caramel up front, finds a pleasant sweetness with mild heat on the palate, and notes brown sugar and vanilla mid-palate with a finish that is warm but not long. Solid value at MSRP around $65–$70. (00:03:14)
  • Yellowstone Hand-Picked Selection (Total Wine Exclusive, 115 Proof): A high-proof store pick from Limestone Branch Distillery bottled at 115 proof. Mash bill of approximately 75% corn, 13% rye, and 12% malted barley. Brian finds the nose decidedly sweet with cherry notes, while the palate delivers a surprising forward spice — likely driven by the rye and malted barley — alongside warmth that punches above its proof. Described as a bourbon that would shine on a cold winter evening. (00:03:47)
  • John J. Bowman Single Barrel Virginia Straight Bourbon: A single barrel expression from A. Smith Bowman Distillery in Fredericksburg, Virginia, aged approximately 9–10 years. Brian picks up an unusual green apple note on the nose that vanishes by the second smell, giving way to dark chocolate and leather on the palate with a long, warming finish. The chocolate character draws comparisons to the Woodford Reserve Chocolate Malt Whisper Series. (00:15:59)
  • Old Forester Whiskey Row Fire Commemorative (100 Proof, 7 Year): A 100-proof, 7-year-old bottling from Brown-Forman, filled July 7, 2015 — the day the four-alarm Whiskey Row fire was extinguished — and bottled in July 2022. Tyler describes a floral, slightly spicy nose with less sweetness than the Knob Creek, brown sugar and vanilla on the palate, and a finish that is pleasant but shorter than expected for the occasion. A portion of proceeds benefited Louisville first responders. (00:19:04)
  • Heaven Hill Bottled-in-Bond 6 Year (100 Proof): A now-discontinued expression from Heaven Hill Distillery, 100 proof and bonded at 6 years, with a mash bill of approximately 78% corn, 10% rye, and 12% malted barley. Discontinued around 2018, it once retailed under $12 and now commands $40–$50 on the secondary market. Both Brian and Tyler pick up peanuts on the nose, a smooth and sweet caramel-forward palate, and a finish that is short but thoroughly approachable — compared favorably to Russell's Reserve 10 Year for everyday sipping reliability. (00:34:19)

Tyler also shares a remarkable off-tasting-mat artifact: a mint-condition bottle of the original 1996 Woodford Reserve first batch, bottle number 3202, signed by master distiller Lincoln Henderson — a gift from an elderly neighbor after Tyler helped clear storm-damaged trees from her yard. The bottle remains sealed and serves as a window into bourbon history rather than a pour on tonight's mat.

From a discontinued Heaven Hill gem to a fire-born Old Forester commemorative, this episode is a reminder that great bourbon stories live in the bottle and in the people who share them. Get well soon, Jim — the Bourbon Road misses you.

Full Transcript

Heaven Hill Bottled in Bond Knob Creek 12 Year Yellowstone bourbon John J. Bowman Single Barrel Old Forester Whiskey Row Fire Limestone Branch Distillery A. Smith Bowman Distillery Heaven Hill Distillery Brown-Forman Beam Suntory Lincoln Henderson Woodford Reserve Buffalo Trace discontinued bourbon bottle in bond store pick bourbon Virginia straight bourbon bourbon tasting The Bourbon Road podcast Tyler Wilson Digital Whiz Kid